简化版三步手消法与WHO六步法等效的随机交叉试验
两组手部细菌基线密度无差异(p 0.513),干预组手消后对数减少因子中位数4.45高于WHO组3.91(p 0.021),提示三步法在实验条件下不劣于甚至优于六步法。
要点
- 三步简化手消法在实验条件下杀菌效果不劣于WHO六步法
- 简化手法更易执行,可能提高手卫生依从性
- 结果来自实验条件,临床推广前需结合实际依从性评估
核心结论
- 在实验条件下,WHO六步「如何手消」技术可简化为三步法,基于医护人员手部细菌计数减少结果,三步法不劣于六步法。
研究设计与样本
- 按欧洲手卫生产品测试规范评估杀菌效果,受试者手部以大肠埃希菌污染。
主要发现
- 手卫生前细菌密度WHO组中位数6.37 log10 CFU(IQR 6.19-6.54),干预组6.34 log10 CFU(IQR 6.17-6.60),p 0.513。
- 手卫生后对数减少因子干预组中位数4.45(IQR 4.04-5.15),WHO组3.91(IQR 3.69-4.62),p 0.021。
临床怎么用
- 简化三步法操作更简单,可作为提高手卫生执行依从性的候选方案。
- 实验条件下的杀菌结果需在真实临床场景中进一步验证后再推广。
局限性
- 为实验条件研究,手部以大肠埃希菌人工污染,非真实临床场景。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The World Health Organization (WHO) issued guidelines on hand hygiene recommending a six-step 'how to hand rub' technique for applying alcohol-based hand rub. However, adherence to all six steps is poor. We assessed a simplified three-step technique and compared it to the conventional WHO six-step technique in terms of bacterial count reduction on healthcare workers' hands. METHODS: Thirty-two participants were randomly assigned to clean their hands following the six-step 'how to hand rub' technique (WHO reference group) or a simplified three-step technique (intervention group). Assignments were reversed after 1 day. The degree of bacterial killing was assessed following the European norm for testing hand hygiene products. Hands were contaminated with Escherichia coli, and the mean logarithmic reduction in bacterial counts was compared between both techniques. RESULTS: Bacterial density before hand hygiene performance did not differ between the WHO reference group (median 6.37 log10 CFU, interquartile range (IQR) 6.19-6.54) and the intervention group (median 6.34 log10 CFU, IQR 6.17-6.60, p 0.513). After hand hygiene, the logarithmic reduction factor was higher in the intervention group (median 4.45, IQR 4.04-5.15) compared to the WHO reference group (median 3.91, IQR 3.69-4.62, p 0.021). CONCLUSIONS: The WHO six-step 'how to hand rub' technique can be simplified to a 3-step procedure based on the reduction of bacterial counts on healthcare workers' hands achieved under experimental conditions. The proposed technique is easier to perform and could improve adherence to the execution of hand hygiene action.
引用
- Tschudin-Sutter S, Rotter ML, Frei R, et al. Simplifying the WHO 'how to hand rub' technique: three steps are as effective as six-results from an experimental randomized crossover trial. Clin Microbiol Infect. 2017. PMID: 28062315. doi:10.1016/j.cmi.2016.12.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。