疟疾快速诊断试验与镜检指导非洲单纯发热疟疾治疗
在尼日利亚农村社区,训练有素的社区卫生员对2148名疑似疟疾儿童进行SD-Bioline快速诊断试验(RDT)和厚血涂片镜检,其中1860名有完整寄生虫学数据。RDT阳性且能吞咽者接受青蒿琥酯联合治疗,不能口服者无论RDT结果均接受直肠青蒿琥酯预转诊。RDT敏感性94.3%、特异性41.6%,存在假阴性结果。
要点
- 训练有素的社区卫生员使用RDT指导疟疾治疗是可行的。
- SD-Bioline RDT敏感性94.3%、特异性41.6%,阴性预测值86.1%。
- RDT假阴性可发生于高寄生虫密度血症,可能与非恶性疟原虫感染或前带效应有关。
核心结论
- RDT可用于指导疟疾管理,并由训练有素的社区卫生员成功用于诊断。
- 但存在RDT假阴性结果,可能削弱对结果的信心和防控效果。
研究设计与样本
- 在3个非洲国家的选定农村社区开展疟疾研究,报告寄生虫学结果。
- 尼日利亚社区卫生员对2148名疑似疟疾儿童进行RDT和厚血涂片,1860名(86.6%)有完整寄生虫学数据被分析。
- 不能口服药物的儿童无论RDT结果均接受直肠青蒿琥酯预转诊并转诊至最近卫生机构。
- 尼日利亚和布基纳法索在研究结束时由经验丰富的研究者重新读取RDT卡和血涂片。
主要发现
- 入组儿童平均年龄30.4±15.7个月。
- 疟疾寄生虫血症患病率:社区卫生员RDT为77.8%(1447/1860),专家临床研究助理RDT为77.6%(1439/1855),镜检(金标准)为54.1%(862/1593)。
- 社区卫生员读取SD-Bioline RDT的敏感性和特异性分别为94.3%和41.6%,阴性和阳性预测值分别为86.1%和65.6%。
临床怎么用
- 在社区点使用RDT指导疟疾治疗,尤其由训练有素的社区卫生员操作。
- 对RDT阴性但临床高度怀疑疟疾者,需考虑假阴性可能,结合镜检等进一步评估。
- 不能口服药物的儿童应接受直肠青蒿琥酯预转诊并转诊,无论RDT结果。
局限性
- RDT假阴性结果可能由非恶性疟原虫感染或前带效应导致。
- RDT特异性较低(41.6%),存在过度治疗风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The World Health Organization recommends that malaria treatment be based on demonstration of the infecting Plasmodium parasite specie. Malaria rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) are recommended at community points of care because they are accurate and rapid. We report on parasitological results in a malaria study in selected rural communities in 3 African countries. METHODS: In Nigeria, community health workers (CHWs) performed RDTs (SD-Bioline) and thick blood smears on all children suspected to have malaria. Malaria RDT-positive children able to swallow received artemisinin-based combination therapy (Coartem). In all countries, children unable to take oral drugs received prereferral rectal artesunate irrespective of RDT result and were referred to the nearest health facility. Thick blood smears and RDTs were usually taken at hospital admission. In Nigeria and Burkina Faso, RDT cassettes and blood smears were re-read by an experienced investigator at study end. RESULTS: Trained CHWs enrolled 2148 children in Nigeria. Complete parasitological data of 1860 (86.6%) enrollees were analyzed. The mean age of enrollees was 30.4 ± 15.7 months. The prevalence of malaria parasitemia in the study population was 77.8% (1447/1860), 77.6% (1439/1855), and 54.1% (862/1593) by RDT performed by CHWs vs an expert clinical research assistant vs microscopy (gold standard), respectively. Geometric mean parasite density was 6946/µL (range, 40-436 450/µL). There were 49 cases of RDT false-negative results with a parasite density range of 40-54 059/µL. False-negative RDT results with high parasitemia could be due to non-falciparum infection or result from a prozone effect. Sensitivity and specificity of SD-Bioline RDT results as read by CHWs were 94.3% and 41.6%, respectively, while the negative and positive predictive values were 86.1% and 65.6%, respectively. The level of agreement in RDT reading by the CHWs and experienced research staff was 86.04% and κ statistic of 0.60. The malaria parasite positivity rate by RDT and microscopy among children with danger signs in the 3 countries was 67.9% and 41.8%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: RDTs are useful in guiding malaria management and were successfully used for diagnosis by trained CHWs. However, false-negative RDT results were identified and can undermine confidence in results and control efforts.
引用
- Falade CO, Ajayi IO, Nsungwa-Sabiiti J, et al. Malaria Rapid Diagnostic Tests and Malaria Microscopy for Guiding Malaria Treatment of Uncomplicated Fevers in Nigeria and Prereferral Cases in 3 African Countries. Clin Infect Dis. 2016. PMID: 27941107
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。