抗菌药物敏感性报告方式对初级医生不当处方决策的影响
B版:报告完整鉴定和药敏结果但无注释)对医生选择抗菌治疗的影响。结果显示,在场景1、2和3中,收到B版报告的医生选择抗菌治疗的概率显著更高(P<0.01),在实习医生和更资深医生中均显著;场景4(住院场景)两组无差异。结论提示,在低 acuity 门诊场景中,隐去药敏结果并附注释可显著影响初级医生避免不当处方。
要点
- 隐去药敏并附注释可减少初级医生在门诊场景中的不当抗菌处方。
- 完整报告药敏而无注释时,医生更倾向选择抗菌治疗(场景1-3,P<0.01)。
- 该效应在住院场景(场景4)中未观察到。
核心结论
- 在低 acuity 门诊场景中,隐去抗菌药物敏感性结果并结合微生物学家注释,显著影响初级医生避免不当处方抗菌药物。
- 在住院场景中,报告方式对处方决策未见显著影响。
研究设计与样本
- 使用四个无抗菌治疗指征的临床案例场景,随机分配至A版(不报告药敏,附微生物学家注释)或B版(报告完整鉴定和药敏,无注释)报告。
- 医生从多项选择中选出首选治疗。
主要发现
- 场景1、2和3中,收到B版报告的医生选择涉及抗菌治疗的答案概率显著更高(P<0.01)。
- 该显著性在实习医生和更资深医生中均存在。
- 场景4(住院场景)中,A版和B版两组的答案无差异。
临床怎么用
- 在低 acuity 门诊场景的微生物报告中,可考虑隐去药敏结果并附微生物学家注释,以辅助减少不当抗菌处方。
- 住院场景的报告中,该策略的效应未显现,需结合临床判断。
局限性
- 研究为问卷调查,非真实临床决策观察。
- 场景数量有限(四个),结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Inappropriate antimicrobial use drives antimicrobial resistance and is a global public health problem. This study examined whether withholding antimicrobial susceptibilities in combination with interpretive comments on microbiological reports influenced the decision to inappropriately prescribe antibiotics in a controlled survey. METHODS: Seventy junior doctors attending educational sessions were given one of two surveys describing four clinical case vignettes (scenarios) in which antimicrobial treatment was not indicated. They were asked to select their preferred treatment from multiple choices. In the scenarios labelled 'A', the laboratory report did not report antibiotic susceptibilities, but included comments from the microbiologist. In the scenarios labelled 'B', the laboratory report included full organism identification and susceptibility results without additional comments. RESULTS: For scenarios 1, 2 and 3 there was a significantly higher probability ( P < 0.01) that the doctor selected an answer involving antibiotic treatment if he/she received the 'B' version of the scenario where reports included antimicrobial susceptibilities, but no interpretive comments. This was significant in both interns and more senior doctors. In scenario 4, of which there were two versions, there was no difference seen in the answers between the groups given scenario A or B. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this survey suggest that withholding antimicrobial susceptibility results in combination with interpretive comments on microbiology reports significantly influences the decision of junior doctors to prescribe antibiotics in low-acuity outpatient setting scenarios (represented in scenarios 1-3), but not in inpatient scenarios (represented in scenario 4).
引用
- Papanicolas LE, Nelson R, Warner MS, et al. Influence of antimicrobial susceptibility reporting on junior doctors' decision to prescribe antimicrobials inappropriately. J Antimicrob Chemother. 2017. PMID: 27999044. doi:10.1093/jac/dkw525
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。