各国成人初级诊疗标准治疗指南与WHO AWaRe推荐的一致性分析
该研究分析了6个WHO区域24个国家的成人标准治疗指南中11种常见感染的抗生素推荐,与WHO AWaRe Book进行一致性比较。结果显示首线口服抗生素方案中Access组占65.7%、Watch组占34.3%,区域间差异明显,肠热症、非血性胃肠炎和膀胱炎一致性较高,而社区获得性肺炎、口腔牙科感染和急性中耳炎一致性较低(P=0.0089)。
要点
- 全球首线口服抗生素方案中Watch组占34.3%,需关注抗菌药物管理
- 西太平洋区域Access组推荐比例最高(76.4%)
- 社区获得性肺炎、口腔感染和急性中耳炎与AWaRe一致性较低
核心结论
- 成人标准治疗指南首线抗生素推荐与WHO AWaRe Book呈中等一致性,存在区域差异。
- 将首线推荐与AWaRe Book对齐有助于抗菌药物管理项目。
研究设计与样本
- 分析6个WHO区域24个国家的成人标准治疗指南,覆盖11种初级诊疗常见感染。
- 比较各国指南与WHO AWaRe Book的首线抗生素推荐一致性。
主要发现
- 共收集522种不同的首线口服抗生素方案。
- Access组抗生素占65.7%,Watch组占34.3%,Reserve组推荐有限。
- 西太平洋区域Access组推荐比例最高(76.4%)。
- 肠热症、非血性胃肠炎和膀胱炎一致性较高,CAP、口腔牙科感染和AOM较低(P=0.0089)。
关键数值与推荐
- Access组抗生素占首线口服方案的65.7%。
- Watch组抗生素占首线口服方案的34.3%。
- 西太平洋区域Access组推荐比例为76.4%。
- 感染特异性一致性差异显著(P=0.0089)。
临床怎么用
- 临床选择首线抗生素时应参考WHO AWaRe分类,优先使用Access组药物。
- 针对一致性较低的感染(如CAP、AOM、口腔感染)需加强指南对齐和 stewardship 干预。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Aligning national standard treatment guidelines (STGs) with WHO AWaRe Book recommendations where appropriate is a key antimicrobial stewardship goal. Antibiotic recommendations in national STGs vary significantly, creating gaps that require evaluation to help address rising AMR rates. METHODS: We analysed adult STGs from 24 countries in six WHO regions for 11 infections commonly seen across countries in the primary care section of the WHO AWaRe Book. These included acute otitis media (AOM), pharyngitis, sinusitis, community-acquired pneumonia (CAP), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, lower urinary tract infections, gastroenteritis (bloody and non-bloody), oral and dental infections, skin and soft tissue infections and enteric fever. National STGs were compared with WHO AWaRe recommendations to assess alignment of first-line antibiotic recommendations. RESULTS: 522 different first-line oral antibiotic regimens were collected from the different STGs in 24 countries across 6 WHO regions. Access antibiotics were recommended in 65.7% of the regimens, while Watch antibiotics accounted for 34.3% of first-line recommendations globally, with limited recommendations of Reserve antibiotics. The Western Pacific Region (76.4%), showed the highest proportions of Access group antibiotic recommendations. Infection-specific analysis showed significant variation in alignment, with a higher alignment for enteric fever, non-bloody gastroenteritis and cystitis, and a lower alignment for CAP, oral and dental infections, and AOM (P = 0.0089). CONCLUSION: First-line antibiotic recommendations in adult STGs showed moderate alignment with WHO AWaRe Book treatment guidance, with regional variability. Aligning first-line recommendations with the WHO AWaRe Book guidance in primary care would assist stewardship programmes.
引用
- Arooj H, Saleem Z, Majeed A, et al. Alignment of national standard treatment guidelines with WHO AWaRe recommendations for adult primary care infectious diseases: implications for antimicrobial stewardship. J Antimicrob Chemother. 2026. PMID: 41878880. doi:10.1093/jac/dkag099
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。