感染预防与感染性疾病领域的混合效果-实施研究:叙述性综述
研究常用效果指标包括患者安全、服务效率和患者死亡率,实施指标包括干预与实施保真度、可接受性、采纳、可行性及实施决定因素。综述指出混合研究方法标签不一致、效果与实施结局概念重叠及报告碎片化等问题,建议标准化报告并扩展至多样地理与资源环境。
要点
- 混合效果-实施研究可加速IPC/ID证据转化,但当前应用仍有限。
- 常见效果结局包括患者安全、服务效率和患者死亡率。
- 常见实施结局包括保真度、可接受性、采纳、可行性和实施决定因素。
核心结论
- 混合效果-实施研究在IPC/ID领域应用有限,改善报告标准化并扩展至多样环境可提升干预影响力。
主要发现
- 纳入研究多来自高收入国家,常用效果结局包括患者安全、服务效率和患者死亡率。
- 频繁报告的实施结局包括干预与实施保真度、可接受性、采纳、可行性及实施决定因素。
- 研究采用了多种实施科学的概念理论、模型和框架。
- 存在混合方法标签不一致、效果与实施结局概念重叠(尤其保真度)及临床效果与实施结果分开报告的碎片化问题。
临床怎么用
- IPC/ID干预研究和质量改进项目可考虑采用混合效果-实施设计,同步评估临床效果与实施过程。
- 报告时应明确区分并标签混合设计类型,分别呈现效果与实施结局以提高可比性。
局限性
- 为叙述性综述,仅纳入英文发表的急性住院环境研究,可能限制结论外推。
- 纳入研究多来自高收入国家,地理与资源环境多样性不足。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Hybrid effectiveness-implementation studies simultaneously assess clinical effectiveness and implementation, thereby accelerating the translation of research into healthcare practice. Such designs are relevant in infection prevention and control (IPC) and infectious diseases (ID), where research-informed interventions frequently face barriers to real-world adoption, implementation, and sustainment. Implementation science offers methods and frameworks to bridge this research-to-practice gap, but the application of hybrid studies remains limited in IPC/ID. OBJECTIVES: This narrative review aims to give an overview and characterize the use of hybrid effectiveness-implementation studies in IPC and ID research by identifying hybrid studies and protocols, analysing IPC/ID interventions and implementation strategies employed, summarizing implementation and effectiveness outcomes reported, and identifying gaps and opportunities for advancing the field. SOURCES: We systematically searched Medline, Embase, CINAHL, Cochrane, and Clinicaltrials.gov to identify study reports, study protocols, and trial registries published in English, addressing both implementation and clinical effectiveness of IPC/ID interventions in acute inpatient settings. CONTENT: Twenty-six hybrid effectiveness-implementation studies were included, predominantly from high-income countries. The studies commonly evaluated effectiveness outcomes such as patient safety, service efficiency, and patient mortality. Frequently reported implementation outcomes included intervention and implementation fidelity, acceptability, adoption and feasibility, and implementation determinants (barriers and facilitators). Diverse conceptual theories, models, and frameworks from implementation science were employed. We identified opportunities for improving hybrid study reporting, including inconsistent labelling of hybrid methods, conceptual overlap between effectiveness and implementation outcomes, particularly fidelity, and fragmented reporting practices separating clinical effectiveness and implementation results. IMPLICATIONS: Improving and standardizing reporting of hybrid studies, and expanding hybrid studies to diverse geographical and resource settings could substantially enhance the impact of IPC/ID interventions. Clearer distinction and labelling of hybrid designs and increased methodological rigour would improve comparability across studies, facilitating broader learning and greater real-world applicability of IPC/ID research.
引用
- Clack L, Schultes MT, Albers B, et al. Hybrid effectiveness-implementation studies in infection prevention and infectious diseases: a narrative review. Clin Microbiol Infect. 2025. PMID: 41176163. doi:10.1016/j.cmi.2025.10.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。