新发疾病暴发中延迟正确诊断的历史模式与当代启示
该综述通过分析历史上初始诊断偏差导致延迟识别新发威胁的案例,结合2025年刚果(金)不明原因急性发热性疾病暴发的官方通报,归纳诊断挑战的结构性、方法学和社会文化因素,并提出五项循证干预措施以减少诊断延迟。
要点
- 截至2025年4月初,刚果(金)赤道省不明原因急性发热聚集性病例已排除主要病毒性出血热病原体。
- 诊断挑战不仅限于个体认知,还包括全球卫生系统结构性偏见、方法学局限和社会文化因素。
- 五项循证干预:系统考虑多重工作假设、建设可持续本地诊断能力、加强临床与公共卫生沟通网络、实施认知去偏策略、强化One Health监测平台。
核心结论
- 历史误诊为将暴发应对从被动反应转变为前瞻性预判提供了关键教训,有望通过更早、更准确地识别复杂生态和社会背景下的新发病原体来避免未来流行病。
研究设计与样本
- 综述:从同行评议出版物中选择初始诊断不确定的说明性案例,并分析世界卫生组织非洲公报和刚果(金)卫生部2025年2月至3月初的官方通讯。
主要发现
- 截至2025年4月初,卫生当局继续调查赤道省不明原因急性发热聚集性病例,临床特征最初提示病毒性出血热,但主要病毒性出血热病原体现已被排除。
- 从所选历史和近期暴发可推断,诊断挑战超越个体认知,涉及全球卫生系统的结构性偏见、方法学局限和社会文化因素。
关键数值与推荐
- 五项循证干预:系统考虑多重工作假设、发展可持续本地诊断能力、增强临床医生至公共卫生沟通网络、实施认知去偏策略、加强One Health监测平台。
临床怎么用
- 在暴发应对中系统考虑多重工作假设,并建设可持续的本地诊断能力以减少诊断延迟。
- 加强临床医生与公共卫生之间的沟通网络,并实施认知去偏策略。
- 强化One Health监测平台以提升新发病原体早期识别能力。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The gap between early diagnostic assumptions and final diagnoses in disease outbreaks represents a persistent challenge in global health despite advancements in diagnostic and response capabilities. OBJECTIVES: To analyse the unfolding 2025 outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) through the lens of historical cases where initial misattributions contributed to delayed recognition of novel or unexpected threats with varying public health consequences; identifying patterns from past outbreaks that can inform current diagnostic approaches and response strategies. SOURCES: We selected illustrative examples from peer-reviewed publications, focusing on cases with initial diagnostic uncertainties that highlight specific diagnostic patterns relevant to the current DRC outbreak. For the ongoing DRC outbreak, we analysed official World Health Organization Africa bulletins and communications from the DRC Ministry of Health through February and early March 2025. CONTENT: As of beginning of April 2025, health authorities continue investigating clusters of unexplained acute febrile illness in Équateur Province with clinical features that were initially being suggestive of a viral haemorrhagic fever. Primary viral haemorrhagic fever pathogens have now been excluded. From selected historical and recent outbreaks, it can be deduced that diagnostic challenges extend beyond individual cognition to include structural biases in global health systems, methodological limitations and sociocultural factors. IMPLICATIONS: We identified five evidence-informed interventions to mitigate diagnostic delays: systematic consideration of multiple working hypotheses, development of sustainable local diagnostic capacity, enhancement of clinician-to-public-health communication networks, implementation of cognitive debiasing strategies, and strengthening of One Health surveillance platforms. Historical misdiagnoses offer crucial lessons for transforming outbreak response from reactive to anticipatory, potentially averting future epidemics through earlier, more accurate recognition of emerging pathogens within their complex ecological and social contexts.
引用
- Pellejero-Sagastizábal G, Bulescu C, Gupta N, et al. Delayed correct diagnoses in emerging disease outbreaks: historical patterns and lessons for contemporary responses. Clin Microbiol Infect. 2025. PMID: 40222556. doi:10.1016/j.cmi.2025.04.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。