利用英国肉牛与绵羊数据比较多种国际抗生素使用基准化指标
该研究基于英国686家肉牛和绵羊养殖场超过16,200次抗生素销售记录,量化了不同生产体系抗生素使用模式,并比较七种欧洲和北美开发的抗生素使用指标。结果显示犊牛育肥场抗生素使用显著更高,四环素类和β-内酰胺类按质量占主导,七种指标间一致性良好(>0.9)。
要点
- 犊牛育肥场的抗生素使用显著高于其他养殖类型。
- 四环素类和β-内酰胺类按质量占主导,但多数养殖类型中其剂量当量与宏内酯类相似。
- 七种国际抗生素使用指标间观察到良好一致性(>0.9)。
核心结论
- 可靠的指标对于准确基准化养殖场至关重要,有助于维持养殖户对监测系统公平性的信心,尤其在排名与财政补贴或处罚挂钩以及谈判畜禽产品进出口准入时。
研究设计与样本
- 对英国686家不同养殖类型的养殖企业超过16,200次抗生素销售事件的数据集进行定量分析,生成七种国际抗生素使用指标的相关系数矩阵。
主要发现
- 犊牛育肥场的抗生素使用显著更高。
- 所有养殖类型中,四环素类和β-内酰胺类按质量占主导,但在多数养殖类型中其剂量当量与宏内酯类相似。
- 七种指标间观察到良好一致性(>0.9)。
关键数值与推荐
- 七种国际抗生素使用指标间一致性良好(>0.9)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Accurate surveillance of livestock antibiotic usage (ABU) at the farm level is an increasingly important part of national antibiotic stewardship initiatives. Numerous ABU indicators or metrics have been developed in Europe and North America but the comparability of these metrics is poorly understood. For policymakers, understanding the relationship between metrics is important when considering the risks posed by ABU and how to regulate them, at the national level, and regulate international trade access in livestock products between countries who use different ABU metrics. OBJECTIVES: To quantify the patterns of ABU among beef (cattle) and lamb (sheep) production systems. To explore ABU variation between farm types across seven ABU metrics developed in Europe and North America using a common dataset of sheep and beef farms' antibiotic purchases from the UK. METHODS: A dataset of >16 200 antibiotic sales events to 686 farm enterprises of different types underwent quantitative analysis. Correlation matrixes were generated for seven international ABU metrics. RESULTS: ABU was significantly higher among calf-rearers. Across all farm types, tetracyclines and β-lactams were the predominant groups by mass, but represent a similar dose equivalent to macrolides across most farm types. Good agreement (>0.9) was observed between metrics. CONCLUSIONS: Reliable metrics to accurately benchmark farms are crucial for maintaining confidence of farmers in the fairness of any surveillance system, especially when the ranking of any given system may be linked to financial subsidies or penalties and also when negotiating import and export access for livestock products between countries.
引用
- Davies P, Hyde R, Corbishley A, et al. Comparison of multiple international metrics for benchmarking antibiotic usage (ABU) using UK beef and sheep data. J Antimicrob Chemother. 2023. PMID: 37584148. doi:10.1093/jac/dkad259
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。