头孢地尔对碳青霉烯耐药肠杆菌目细菌药敏试验的纸片扩散法、MIC梯度试条法与肉汤微量稀释法比较
本研究在100株全基因组测序的碳青霉烯耐药肠杆菌目细菌及827株连续碳青霉烯非敏感肠杆菌目细菌中比较头孢地尔药敏试验方法。CE-IVD肉汤微量稀释板分类一致率达95.0%,MIC梯度试条法分类一致率仅63%且极重大误差达94.9%,纸片扩散法在前瞻性比较中分类一致率81.7%、极重大误差23.3%。作者认为CE-IVD肉汤微量稀释法准确,应避免使用MIC梯度试条法,纸片扩散法可用于筛查但需以肉汤微量稀释法确认。
要点
- CE-IVD肉汤微量稀释板分类一致率95.0%,极重大误差2.8%,重大误差1.6%,重复性高。
- MIC梯度试条法分类一致率仅63%,极重大误差94.9%,因严重低估MIC值。
- 纸片扩散法在前瞻性比较中分类一致率81.7%,极重大误差23.3%,21.3%菌株落在技术不确定区。
核心结论
- 商品化CE-IVD肉汤微量稀释法(ThermoFisher)用于难治性肠杆菌目细菌的头孢地尔MIC测定是准确的。
- 仅针对铜绿假单胞菌配制的MIC梯度试条法(Liofilchem)应避免使用。
- 纸片扩散法可能可用于筛查,但许多碳青霉烯耐药肠杆菌目细菌需用肉汤微量稀释法重新测试以确定最终分类。
研究设计与样本
- 研究比较纸片扩散法、MIC梯度试条法与肉汤微量稀释法对碳青霉烯耐药肠杆菌目细菌的头孢地尔药敏试验。
- 首先使用100株全基因组测序的碳青霉烯耐药肠杆菌目细菌比较上述方法。
- 随后对827株连续碳青霉烯非敏感肠杆菌目细菌(包括634株碳青霉烯酶生产者)前瞻性比较纸片扩散法与CE-IVD肉汤微量稀释法。
- 参考方法为使用缺铁Mueller-Hinton肉汤制备的冷冻肉汤微量稀释板。
主要发现
- 与参考方法相比,CE-IVD肉汤微量稀释板分类一致率95.0%(95%CI 88.8-97.9),极重大误差2.8%(95%CI 0.4-14.2),重大误差1.6%(95%CI 0.3-8.7),重复性高。
- MIC梯度试条法分类一致率仅63%(95%CI 53.2-71.8),极重大误差94.9%(95%CI 83.1-98.6),因严重低估MIC值。
- 纸片扩散法分类一致率77%(95%CI 67.9-84.2),另有8%的菌株落在18-22 mm的技术不确定区。
- 前瞻性比较中,纸片扩散法分类一致率81.7%(95%CI 79.0-84.2),极重大误差23.3%(95%CI 15.1-34.2),重大误差4.9%(95%CI 3.6-6.7)。
- 此外,21.3%(95%CI 18.6-24.2)的碳青霉烯耐药肠杆菌目细菌落在技术不确定区。
临床怎么用
- 商品化CE-IVD肉汤微量稀释法(ThermoFisher)被作者认为用于难治性肠杆菌目细菌的头孢地尔MIC测定是准确的。
- 仅针对铜绿假单胞菌配制的MIC梯度试条法(Liofilchem)被作者认为应避免使用。
- 纸片扩散法被作者认为可能可用于筛查,但许多碳青霉烯耐药肠杆菌目细菌需用肉汤微量稀释法重新测试以确定最终分类。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Cefiderocol is a catechol-substituted cephalosporin dedicated to the treatment of infections caused by multidrug resistant gram-negative rods. Cefiderocol susceptibility testing might be complex. We compared cefiderocol susceptibility testing methods on a relevant collection of carbapenem-resistant Enterobacterales. METHODS: CE-IVD (European CE marking required for all in vitro diagnostic (IVD)) broth microdilution (BMD) plate (ThermoFisher, Waltham, MA, USA) using regular Mueller-Hinton broth, MIC test strip (Liofilchem, Teramo, Italy), and disk diffusion (Liofilchem) were compared to a frozen BMD plate prepared with iron depleted Mueller-Hinton broth. First, a collection of 100 entirely sequenced carbapenem-resistant Enterobacterales was used to compare these methods. Then, a prospective comparison of disk diffusion and CE-IVD BMD was performed on 827 consecutive carbapenem non-susceptible Enterobacterales including 634 carbapenemase-producers. RESULTS: Compared to reference method, CE-IVD BMD plate gave 95.0% (95% CI, 88.8-97.9) categorisation agreement (CA), 2.8% (95% CI, 0.4-14.2) very major errors (VME), and 1.6% (95% CI, 0.3-8.7) major errors (ME) with high reproducibility. MIC strip gave only 63% (95% CI, 53.2-71.8) of CA and 94.9% (95% CI, 83.1-98.6) of VME due to critical underestimation of the MICs. Disk diffusion gave 77% (95% CI, 67.9-84.2) CA with additional 8% of the isolates within the area of technical uncertainty of 18-22 mm. Prospectively, disk diffusion gave 81.7% (95% CI, 79.0-84.2) CA, 23.3% (95% CI, 15.1-34.2%)VME, and 4.9% (95% CI, 3.6-6.7) ME. Additionally, 21.3% (95% CI, 18.6-24.2) of CRE were within the area of technical uncertainty. DISCUSSION: Commercial CE-IVD BMD (ThermoFisher) is accurate for cefiderocol MIC determination in difficult-to-treat Enterobacterales whereas MIC test strip (Liofilchem), that was formulated for Pseudomonas aeruginosa only, should be avoided. Disk diffusion might be useful for screening, but many of these CRE have to be re-tested using BMD to assess definitive categorization.
引用
- Bonnin RA, Emeraud C, Jousset AB, et al. Comparison of disk diffusion, MIC test strip and broth microdilution methods for cefiderocol susceptibility testing on carbapenem-resistant enterobacterales. Clin Microbiol Infect. 2022. PMID: 35533970. doi:10.1016/j.cmi.2022.04.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。