指南推荐产后血栓预防的风险阈值估算
该研究基于日内瓦大学医院2019年1月344名分娩女性的病历资料,比较RCOG、ACOG和ACCP指南的产后血栓预防推荐比例,并用Sultan模型间接估算个体VTE绝对风险。结果显示各指南推荐比例差异显著,RCOG推荐40.1%的总分娩人群使用预防,而ACOG和ACCP仅推荐35.0%和40.0%的剖宫产人群。指南推荐肝素预防的风险阈值似乎很低,可能对应较高的需治疗人数。
要点
- RCOG指南推荐40.1%的总分娩人群和88.8%的剖宫产人群进行血栓预防。
- ACOG和ACCP指南分别推荐35.0%和40.0%的剖宫产人群进行血栓预防。
- 推荐预防人群的估计VTE风险分别为0.12%(RCOG)和0.20%(ACOG/ACCP剖宫产)。
核心结论
- 各指南推荐产后血栓预防的比例存在重要差异,RCOG推荐比例最高。
- 指南推荐肝素预防的VTE风险阈值似乎很低,可能导致较高的需治疗人数。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性病历审查研究,纳入2019年1月在日内瓦大学医院分娩的344名女性。
- 使用验证的Sultan风险预测模型间接估算个体绝对VTE风险。
主要发现
- 总人群平均估计VTE风险为0.07%,RCOG推荐预防人群为0.12%。
- ACOG和ACCP推荐预防的剖宫产人群估计VTE风险为0.20%。
- RCOG将40.1%的总分娩、25.4%的阴道分娩和88.8%的剖宫产归类为需预防。
- ACOG和ACCP分别将35.0%和40.0%的剖宫产归类为高风险。
关键数值与推荐
- RCOG指南推荐40.1%的总分娩人群使用血栓预防。
- ACOG指南推荐35.0%的剖宫产人群使用血栓预防。
- ACCP指南推荐40.0%的剖宫产人群使用血栓预防。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应了解不同指南产后血栓预防推荐比例的显著差异。
- 低风险阈值可能导致过度预防,需权衡预防获益与出血风险及治疗负担。
局限性
- 单中心研究,样本量344例,结果外推需谨慎。
- VTE风险为间接估算,非实际观察发生率。
- 指南推荐基于专家意见,风险阈值定义不明确。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Guidelines for postpartum thromboprophylaxis are mostly expert based. Acceptable postpartum venous thromboembolism (VTE) risk thresholds to justify the use of thromboprophylaxis are ill defined. OBJECTIVE: To compare the proportion of postpartum women with recommended thromboprophylaxis according to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (RCOG), American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), and American College of Chest Physicians (ACCP) guidelines, and to estimate their threshold of risk of VTE. METHODS: We collected maternal, obstetrical, and fetal characteristics among all women who delivered at the Geneva University Hospitals in January 2019 through medical chart review. We determined for each woman the recommended strategy of thromboprophylaxis according to each guideline. We indirectly estimated individual absolute VTE risks using a validated risk prediction model (Sultan). RESULTS: Among 344 women (mean age 32.2 years), with 23.3% of cesarean deliveries (CD), the RCOG guideline categorized 40.1% of all deliveries, 25.4% of vaginal deliveries (VD), and 88.8% of CD as requiring thromboprophylaxis. The ACOG and ACCP guidelines, which focus on CD, categorized fewer women as high risk (35.0% and 40.0% of CD, respectively). The mean estimated risk of VTE was 0.07% in all participants, 0.12% in those with recommended thromboprophylaxis according to the RCOG, and 0.20% among women after CD with recommended thromboprophylaxis by the ACOG and ACCP guidelines. CONCLUSIONS: Our data highlight important variations in the proportion of thromboprophylaxis recommendation between guidelines. Risk thresholds to recommend the use of heparin appear very low, and may correlate with a high, and perhaps undesirable, number needed to treat to prevent VTE events.
引用
- Gassmann N, Viviano M, Righini M, et al. Estimating the risk thresholds used by guidelines to recommend postpartum thromboprophylaxis. J Thromb Haemost. 2020. PMID: 33176061. doi:10.1111/jth.15166
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。