肝素诱导性血小板减少症实验室检测质量的国际评估
该研究通过2013至2017年ECAT基金会分发的10份样本,评估肝素/PF4抗体检测的定性一致性。437家实验室提交3149个结果,ELISA和定量快速免疫分析对共识样本分类一致率>95%,而定性快速免疫分析一致率较低,且不同ELISA方法的光密度值变异大、不可互换。
要点
- 定量快速免疫分析和ELISA对>95%的样本分类与共识一致。
- 定性快速免疫分析一致率较低,对共识阳性样本的阴性分类比例超出预期。
- 不同ELISA方法的光密度值变异系数为35%至50%,不可互换。
核心结论
- 定量快速免疫分析和ELISA对>95%的样本分类与共识一致,而定性快速免疫分析一致率较低。
- 不同ELISA方法的光密度值变异大且不可互换。
研究设计与样本
- 2013至2017年,ECAT基金会国际分发10份样本进行外部能力验证。
- 共437家实验室提交3149个结果,ELISA占1484个(47%),快速免疫分析占1665个(53%)。
主要发现
- ELISA对共识阳性和共识阴性样本的分类一致率均为96%。
- 阳性样本光密度值的变异系数在合并ELISA方法时范围为35%至50%。
- 定量快速免疫分析对共识阳性样本分类一致率97%,对共识阴性样本98%。
- 定性快速免疫分析对共识阳性样本分类一致率88%,对共识阴性样本73%。
- 仅乳胶免疫分析和IgG特异性化学发光法在快速免疫分析中与共识一致率>95%。
关键数值与推荐
- ELISA对共识阳性和阴性样本一致率均为96%。
- 定量快速免疫分析对共识阳性样本一致率97%,共识阴性样本98%。
- 定性快速免疫分析对共识阳性样本一致率88%,共识阴性样本73%。
- 阳性样本光密度值变异系数在合并ELISA方法时为35%至50%。
临床怎么用
- 定量快速免疫分析和ELISA与共识分类一致率高,可用于肝素/PF4抗体检测。
- 不同ELISA方法的光密度值不可互换,解读时应考虑方法差异。
- 定性快速免疫分析对共识阳性样本存在较高比例的阴性分类,挑战其作为排除试验的使用。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Accurate diagnosis of heparin-induced thrombocytopenia (HIT) is essential to ensure timely treatment and prevent complications. Current diagnostic assays include enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) and rapid immunoassays (RIs). RIs offer fast turnaround times but were not significantly represented in previous external proficiency testing challenges. OBJECTIVES: To use external proficiency testing to assess qualitative concordance for heparin/PF4 antibody detection. METHODS: From 2013 to 2017, the External Quality Control for Assays and Tests (ECAT) Foundation distributed 10 samples internationally. RESULTS: In total, 437 laboratories submitted 3149 results. ELISAs accounted for 1484 (47%) responses with RIs accounting for 1665 (53%) responses. RI use increased over the 5-year period. ELISAs classified 96% of both consensus positive and consensus negative samples concordantly. The coefficient of variation (CV) for positive sample optical densities (ODs) ranged from 35% to 50% when combining ELISA assay methods together. Quantitative RIs classified 97% of consensus-positive and 98% of consensus-negative samples concordantly. Qualitative RIs had a higher proportion of discordant responses and classified 88% of consensus-positive samples and 73% of consensus-negative samples concordantly. Of RIs only latex immunoassays and IgG specific chemiluminescent assays identified > 95% of samples concordantly with consensus. CONCLUSION: Quantitative RIs and ELISAs classify > 95% of samples concordantly. The ODs from different ELISA methods vary considerably and are not interchangeable. Qualitative RI use is increasing despite a greater proportion of discordant classifications. This includes a higher than expected number of negative classifications for consensus-positive samples among many RIs, challenging their use as "rule out" tests.
引用
- Liederman Z, Van Cott EM, Smock K, et al. Heparin-induced thrombocytopenia: An international assessment of the quality of laboratory testing. J Thromb Haemost. 2019. PMID: 31420903. doi:10.1111/jth.14611
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。