血友病A与血友病B患者出血频率及血友病性关节病差异的回顾性分析
回顾性分析2007年1月至2010年12月中国医学科学院血液病医院211例男性血友病患者(HA 150例、HB 61例),比较出血频率与关节X线Arnold-Hilgartner分级。HA总体出血频率高于HB,中间型差异显著;中间型HB关节X线进展较中间型HA慢;关节出血次数和外伤是X线分级进展的独立危险因素。
要点
- HA总体中位年均总出血20.5次、关节出血13.5次,高于HB的13次和8次。
- 中间型HA出血频率高于中间型HB,重型HA与HB出血频率无显著差异。
- 关节出血次数和外伤是关节X线Arnold-Hilgartner分级进展的独立危险因素。
核心结论
- HB患者出血频率低于HA患者,中间型患者差异尤其明显。
- 中间型HB患者关节X线分级进展较中间型HA患者慢。
- 关节出血次数和外伤是血友病患者关节X线Arnold-Hilgartner分级进展的独立危险因素。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究纳入2007年1月至2010年12月中国医学科学院血液病医院收治的211例血友病患者,均为男性,其中HA 150例、HB 61例。
- 对部分血友病关节出血患者随访5年,复查病变关节X线Arnold-Hilgartner分级。
主要发现
- HA组总体中位年均总出血次数20.5(0~48)次、中位年均关节出血次数13.5(0~38)次;HB组分别为13(1~40)次、8(0~33)次。
- 中间型HA中位年均总出血次数26(1~48)次高于中间型HB 12(1~36)次(P<0.001);中位年均关节出血次数18(0~36)次高于7.5(0~26)次(P=0.001)。
- 重型HA与重型HB中位年均总出血次数33(1~41)次对26(1~40)次(P=0.702)、中位年均关节出血次数22(0~36)次对18(0~33)次(P=0.429),差异无统计学意义。
- HA患者血友病严重程度与关节X线Arnold-Hilgartner分级呈正相关(r=0.063,P=0.004);HB患者无相关性(r=0.045,P=0.082)。
- 5年后复查X线,总体HA与HB患者进展程度差异无统计学意义(z=1.941,P=0.052),但中间型HA进展程度高于中间型HB(z=0.076,P=0.002),重型HA与重型HB差异无统计学意义(z=3.139,P=0.945)。
关键数值与推荐
- HA总体中位年均总出血次数20.5(0~48)次,HB为13(1~40)次。
- HA总体中位年均关节出血次数13.5(0~38)次,HB为8(0~33)次。
- 中间型HA中位年均总出血次数26(1~48)次 vs 中间型HB 12(1~36)次(P<0.001),中位年均关节出血次数18(0~36)次 vs 7.5(0~26)次(P=0.001)。
- 关节X线分级进展独立危险因素:关节出血次数OR=1.166(95%CI 1.097~1.239,P<0.001);外伤OR=2.842(95%CI 1.196~6.755,P=0.018)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To analyze the difference of bleeding frequency, plain radiographic (X-ray) , risk factors in hemophilic arthropathy progression and the Arnold-Hilgartner classification. Methods: A retrospective study was conducted in 211 hemophilia patients hospitalized in our medical center between January 2007 and December 2010, some patients with hemarthrosis were followed up for 5 years. Results: All patients were male, including 150 hemophilia A (HA) and 61 hemophilia B (HB) . The HA patients bled more frequently than HB patients with annualized total bleeding rate 20.5 (0-48) vs 13 (1-40) ; annualized joint bleeding rate 13.5 (0-38) vs 8 (0-33) , especially in moderate hemophilia [26 (1-48) vs 12 (1-36) , P<0.001; 18 (0-36) vs 7.5 (0-26) , P=0.001], but severe hemophilia had no difference in bleeding frequency [33 (1-41) vs 26 (1-40) , P=0.702; 22 (0-36) vs 18 (0-33) , P=0.429]. The condition of the affected joints of 108 HA and 54 HB was evaluated on roentgenography. In HA patients, the Arnold-Hilgartner classification increased with the severity ratings (r=0.063, P=0.004) . However, similar associations were not found in HB patients (r=0.045, P=0.082) . Five years later, 36 HA and 19 HB patients received the same joint X-ray, there were no significant differences in joints radiographic progression between the total HA and HB groups (z=1.941, P=0.052) . However, significant difference between moderate HA and HB was observed (z=0.076, P=0.002) . Multivariate unconditioned Logistic analysis showed that annualized joint bleeding rate [P<0.001, OR=1.166 (95%CI 1.097-1.239) ] and articular structural injuries [P=0.018, OR=2.842 (95% CI 1.196-6.755) ] were independent risk factors for the joints radiographic progression. Conclusion: The study suggests that there was a difference in bleeding phenotype between HA and HB, especially in moderate hemophilia. HB patients showed mild but progressive development over time, compared with HA patients. Annualized joint bleeding rate and articular structural injuries were independent risk factors for the joints radiographic progression. 目的: 分析血友病A(HA)和血友病B(HB)的出血频率和X线分级情况、X线分级进展的危险因素及差异。 方法: 回顾性分析2007年1月至2010年12月中国医学科学院血液病医院收治的211例血友病患者的临床资料,随访部分患者出血关节的X线Arnold-Hilgartner诊断分级结果。 结果: 211例患者均为男性,其中HA 150例,HB 61例。HA组总体中位年均总出血次数、中位年均关节出血次数分别为20.5(0~48)、13.5(0~38)次,HB组总体中位年均总出血次数、中位年均关节出血次数分别为13(1~40)、8(0~33)次,中间型HA患者中位年均总出血次数和中位年均关节出血次数高于中间型HB患者[26(1~48)次对12(1~36)次,P<0.001;18(0~36)次对7.5(0~26)次,P=0.001],而重型HA和HB患者中位年均总出血次数和中位年均关节出血次数比较差异无统计学意义[33(1~41)次对26(1~40)次,P=0.702;22(0~36)次对18(0~33)次,P=0.429]。108例HA、54例HB患者入院时行出血关节普通X线检查,HA患者血友病严重程度与关节X线Arnold-Hilgartner诊断分级呈正相关(r=0.063,P=0.004);HB患者严重程度分级与关节X线Arnold-Hilgartner诊断分级无相关性(r=0.045,P=0.082);36例HA和19例HB患者5年后复查病变关节X线片,总体HA与HB患者X线进展程度比较差异无统计学意义(z=1.941,P=0.052),但中间型HA患者进展程度高于中间型HB患者(z=0.076,P=0.002),重型HA和重型HB患者比较差异无统计学意义(z=3.139,P=0.945)。多因素分析显示关节出血次数[P<0.001,OR=1.166(95%CI 1.097~1.239)]和外伤[P=0.018,OR=2.842(95%CI 1.196~6.755)]是血友病患者关节X线Arnold-Hilgartner诊断分级进展的独立危险因素。 结论: HB患者出血频率低于HA患者,中间型患者差异尤其明显。中间型HB患者关节X线分级进展较中间型HA患者慢。关节出血次数和外伤是血友病患者关节X线Arnold-Hilgartner诊断分级进展的独立危险因素。.
引用
- Wang SX, Guan Y, Nie YB, et al. [Retrospectively analysis of the difference of bleeding frequency and hemophilic arthropathy between hemophilia A and hemophilia B patients]. Zhonghua Xue Ye Xue Za Zhi. 2017. PMID: 28565740. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.0253-2727.2017.05.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。