医师受训者死亡事件判定的准确性与评分者间一致性:在尸检队列中验证ISTH肺栓塞相关死亡定义
本回顾性尸检队列纳入2010年1月至2019年7月纽约长老会医院所有肺栓塞相关死亡患者及2018年非肺栓塞死亡患者,由两名医师受训者依据ISTH定义独立判定死亡原因。共判定126例死亡事件(中位年龄68岁,女性60例[48%]),其中29例(23%)经尸检确认为肺栓塞。ISTH定义的敏感度为48%(95%CI 29-67),特异度为100%(95%CI 96-100),评分者间一致性良好(一致率93%,95%CI 87-96;Cohen's Kappa 0.67,95%CI 44-85)。
要点
- ISTH肺栓塞相关死亡定义在尸检确认队列中敏感度为48%(95%CI 29-67),特异度为100%(95%CI 96-100)。
- 两名医师受训者判定肺栓塞相关死亡的评分者间一致率为93%(95%CI 87-96),Cohen's Kappa为0.67(95%CI 44-85)。
- 共判定126例死亡事件(中位年龄68岁,女性60例[48%]),其中29例(23%)经尸检确认为肺栓塞。
核心结论
- 研究结果与既往验证研究一致,进一步支持使用ISTH肺栓塞相关死亡定义,并显示不同经验判定者之间具有高度一致性。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性尸检队列研究,纳入2010年1月至2019年7月纽约长老会医院所有肺栓塞相关死亡患者及2018年非肺栓塞死亡患者。
- 由两名医师受训者基于死前临床摘要,独立使用ISTH肺栓塞相关死亡定义判定死亡原因。
- 计算ISTH定义识别尸检确认肺栓塞相关死亡的敏感度、特异度及评分者间一致性。
主要发现
- 共判定126例死亡事件(中位年龄68岁;女性60例[48%]),其中29例(23%)经尸检确认为肺栓塞。
- ISTH定义识别尸检确认肺栓塞相关死亡的敏感度为48%(95%CI 29-67),特异度为100%(95%CI 96-100)。
- 肺栓塞相关死亡的评分者间一致性良好:一致率93%(95%CI 87-96),Cohen's Kappa 0.67(95%CI 44-85)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论支持使用ISTH肺栓塞相关死亡定义,并显示不同经验判定者之间具有高度一致性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: We previously determined good agreement and high specificity of the International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis (ISTH) definition of pulmonary embolism (PE)-related death among an expert central adjudication committee (CAC). CACs are often composed of experts in the corresponding research field. Involving physician trainees in CACs would allow investigators to divide the workload and foster trainees' research experience. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the accuracy of the ISTH definition of PE-related death for PE- versus non-PE-related deaths as confirmed by autopsy and its interrater agreement among physician trainees. METHODS: This retrospective autopsy cohort included all patients with PE-related deaths between January 2010 and July 2019 as well as patients who died in 2018 from a cause other than PE at the New York-Presbyterian Hospital. Based on premortem clinical summaries, two physician trainees independently determined the cause of death using the ISTH definition of PE-related death. We calculated the sensitivity and specificity of the ISTH definition to identify autopsy-confirmed PE-related death and its interrater agreement. RESULTS: Overall, 126 death events were adjudicated (median age, 68 years; 60 [48%] women), of which 29 (23%) were due to PE, as confirmed by autopsy. Sensitivity and specificity of the ISTH definition for autopsy-confirmed PE-related death was 48% (95% CI, 29-67) and 100% (95% CI, 96-100), respectively. Interrater reliability for PE-related death was good (percentage agreement, 93%; 95% CI, 87-96, Cohen's Kappa, 0.67; 95% CI, 44-85). CONCLUSION: Our findings are consistent with our previous validation study. They further support the use of the ISTH definition of PE-related death and revealed high agreement between adjudicators with varied experience.
引用
- Marx CE, Schenker C, Xu Y, et al. Accuracy and interrater agreement of death event adjudications by physician trainees: validation of the ISTH definition of pulmonary embolism-related death in an autopsy cohort. J Thromb Haemost. 2023. PMID: 37517478. doi:10.1016/j.jtha.2023.07.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。