淋巴结切除活检比粗针活检提供更精确的淋巴瘤诊断:法国淋巴病理网络调查
该研究基于法国淋巴病理网络登记的32285例疑似淋巴瘤病例,比较粗针活检与手术切除活检的诊断准确性。粗针活检在92.3%病例中提供明确诊断,手术切除为98.1%;粗针活检的诊断不一致率更高(23.1% vs 21.2%,P=.004),专家复核对手术切除的纠正效率更高(93.3% vs 81.4%,P<10⁻⁶)。
要点
- 粗针活检明确诊断率92.3%,低于手术切除的98.1%。
- 粗针活检诊断不一致率23.1%,高于手术切除的21.2%(P=.004)。
- 专家复核纠正未分类/可疑病例的效率:手术切除93.3% vs 粗针活检81.4%(P<10⁻⁶)。
核心结论
- 粗针活检在多数疑似淋巴瘤病例中能准确诊断,但增加错误或非明确结论的风险。
- 该大规模调查强调对疑似淋巴瘤病例进行系统专家复核的必要性,尤其是粗针活检样本。
研究设计与样本
- 研究回顾了法国淋巴病理网络登记的32285例病例,该网络对法国所有淋巴瘤诊断进行系统专家复核。
- 比较粗针活检与手术切除活检在常规病理实践中按世界卫生组织分类准确诊断的百分比。
主要发现
- 粗针活检提供明确诊断的比例为92.3%,手术切除为98.1%。
- 转诊与专家诊断的不一致率:粗针活检23.1% vs 手术切除21.2%(P=.004)。
- 转诊病理医生通过粗针活检提供了更多未分类淋巴瘤或可疑病变病例。
- 专家复核对未分类/可疑病例的分类效率:手术切除93.3% vs 粗针活检81.4%(P<10⁻⁶)。
- 反应性病变的诊断一致性手术切除高于粗针活检(P=.009)。
关键数值与推荐
- 粗针活检明确诊断率92.3%,手术切除98.1%。
- 诊断不一致率:粗针活检23.1% vs 手术切除21.2%(P=.004)。
- 专家复核分类效率:手术切除93.3% vs 粗针活检81.4%(P<10⁻⁶)。
- 反应性病变诊断一致性手术切除高于粗针活检(P=.009)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
According to expert guidelines, lymph node surgical excision is the standard of care for lymphoma diagnosis. However, core needle biopsy (CNB) has become widely accepted as part of the lymphoma diagnostic workup over the past decades. The aim of this study was to present the largest multicenter inventory of lymph nodes sampled either by CNB or surgical excision in patients with suspected lymphoma and to compare their diagnostic performance in routine pathologic practice. We reviewed 32 285 cases registered in the French Lymphopath network, which provides a systematic expert review of all lymphoma diagnoses in France, and evaluated the percentage of CNB and surgical excision cases accurately diagnosed according to the World Health Organization classification. Although CNB provided a definitive diagnosis in 92.3% and seemed to be a reliable method of investigation for most patients with suspected lymphoma, it remained less conclusive than surgical excision, which provided a definitive diagnosis in 98.1%. Discordance rates between referral and expert diagnoses were higher on CNB (23.1%) than on surgical excision (21.2%; P = .004), and referral pathologists provided more cases with unclassified lymphoma or equivocal lesion through CNB. In such cases, expert review improved the diagnostic workup by classifying ∼90% of cases, with higher efficacy on surgical excision (93.3%) than CNB (81.4%; P < 10-6). Moreover, diagnostic concordance for reactive lesions was higher on surgical excision than CNB (P = .009). Overall, although CNB accurately diagnoses lymphoma in most instances, it increases the risk of erroneous or nondefinitive conclusions. This large-scale survey also emphasizes the need for systematic expert review in cases of lymphoma suspicion, especially in those sampled by using CNB.
引用
- Syrykh C, Chaouat C, Poullot E, et al. Lymph node excisions provide more precise lymphoma diagnoses than core biopsies: a French Lymphopath network survey. Blood. 2022. PMID: 35797472. doi:10.1182/blood.2022015520
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。