文献速递消化内镜消化道肿瘤与早癌

基于模拟方法为小 colorectal 息肉光学诊断制定易采纳的能力标准

Guidance for setting easy-to-adopt competence criteria for optical diagnosis of diminutive colorectal polyps: a simulation approach.
PubMed 文献 · Gastrointest Endosc · 2021-04-19

本研究利用两个前瞻性队列(结肠镜筛查和 FIT 筛查)进行模拟,系统改变虚拟内镜医师对小息肉各亚型的诊断正确比例,以蒙特卡洛法重复 1000 次评估是否满足 PIVI-1 和 PIVI-2。结果显示达到 PIVI 所需总体诊断准确率因临床场景和指南而异:结肠镜筛查中,正确诊断≥92% 的所有小息肉可达 PIVI-1,≥89% 可达 PIVI-2;FIT 筛查中分别为≥77% 和≥94%;使用 ESGE 指南时,40% 正确即可满足 PIVI-1。

要点

  • 结肠镜筛查中,正确诊断≥92% 小息肉可满足 PIVI-1,≥89% 满足 PIVI-2。
  • FIT 筛查中,正确诊断≥77% 满足 PIVI-1,≥94% 满足 PIVI-2。
  • 使用 ESGE 指南时,仅需 40% 正确诊断即可满足 PIVI-1。

核心结论

  • 与固定 PIVI 标准不同,模拟研究显示不同正确诊断小息肉比例阈值导致不同临床后果,取决于指南和临床场景。
  • 达到 PIVI 所需正确诊断小息肉比例可作为更易采纳的能力标准。

研究设计与样本

  • 模拟研究,使用两个前瞻性队列数据集:结肠镜筛查和 FIT 筛查场景。
  • 虚拟内镜医师或计算机辅助诊断系统以固定诊断性能策略对所有至少有一个小息肉个体进行光学诊断。
  • 策略通过系统改变腺瘤、增生性息肉、无蒂锯齿状病变各亚型的正确诊断比例定义。
  • 采用蒙特卡洛抽样重复 1000 次,以组织学为参考,评估是否满足 PIVI-1 和 PIVI-2。

主要发现

  • 在结肠镜筛查场景,所有小息肉(不论组织学)正确诊断≥92% 的策略达到与美国监测间隔≥90% 一致(即 PIVI-1)。
  • 在结肠镜筛查场景,所有小息肉正确诊断≥89% 的策略达到直肠乙状结肠肿瘤性病变阴性预测值≥90%(即 PIVI-2)。
  • 在 FIT 筛查场景,达到 PIVI-1 和 PIVI-2 的正确诊断比例分别为≥77% 和≥94%。
  • 使用 ESGE 指南时,两种场景下所有小息肉正确诊断仅 40% 即已满足 PIVI-1。

关键数值与推荐

  • PIVI-1 定义为与美国或 ESGE 监测指南一致性≥90%。
  • PIVI-2 定义为直肠乙状结肠肿瘤性病变阴性预测值≥90%。
  • 结肠镜筛查场景:PIVI-1 需正确诊断≥92% 小息肉,PIVI-2 需≥89%。
  • FIT 筛查场景:PIVI-1 需正确诊断≥77% 小息肉,PIVI-2 需≥94%。
  • 使用 ESGE 指南时,PIVI-1 在两种场景下 40% 正确诊断即满足。

临床怎么用

  • 可根据临床场景(结肠镜筛查或 FIT 筛查)和采用的监测指南(美国或 ESGE),选择相应的小息肉正确诊断比例阈值作为能力标准。
  • 该模拟方法提供的阈值比固定 PIVI 标准更易在日常实践中采纳。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: One reason the optical diagnosis strategy for diminutive colorectal polyps has not yet been implemented is that the current competence criteria (Preservation and Incorporation of Valuable Endoscopic Innovation [PIVI] initiative) are difficult to use in daily practice. To provide guidance for setting alternative easy-to-adopt competence criteria, we determined the lowest proportion of diminutive polyps that should have a correct optical diagnosis to meet the PIVI. METHODS: For this simulation study, we used datasets from 2 prospectively collected cohorts of patients who underwent colonoscopy in either a primary colonoscopy or fecal immunochemical test (FIT) screening setting. In the simulation approach, virtual endoscopists or computer-aided diagnosis systems performed optical diagnosis of diminutive polyps with a fixed diagnostic performance level (strategy) on all individuals in the cohort who had ≥1 diminutive polyp. Strategies were defined by systematically varying the proportion of correct optical diagnoses for each polyp subtype (ie, adenomas, hyperplastic polyps, sessile serrated lesions). For each strategy, we determined whether PIVI-1 (≥90% agreement with U.S. or European Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy [ESGE] surveillance guidelines) and PIVI-2 (≥90% negative predictive value [NPV] for neoplastic lesions in the rectosigmoid) were met using Monte Carlo sampling with 1000 repetitions, with histology as reference. RESULTS: The level of overall diagnostic accuracy to achieve the PIVI differed significantly depending on the clinical setting and guidelines used. In the colonoscopy screening setting, all diagnostic strategies in which 92% of all diminutive polyps (regardless of histology) were diagnosed correctly led to 90% or more agreement with U.S. surveillance intervals (ie, PIVI-1). For all diagnostic strategies in which ≥89% of all diminutive polyps were correctly diagnosed, at least 90% NPV was achieved (ie, PIVI-2). For the FIT screening setting, values were respectively ≥77% and ≥94%. When using ESGE guidelines, PIVI-1 was in both settings already met when 40% of all diminutive polyps were diagnosed correctly. CONCLUSIONS: In contrast to the fixed PIVI criteria, our simulation study shows that different thresholds for the proportion of correctly diagnosed diminutive polyps lead to different clinical consequences depending on guidelines and clinical setting. However, this target proportion of diminutive colorectal polyps correctly diagnosed with optical diagnosis represents easier-to-adopt competence criteria.

来源:Gastrointest Endosc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Houwen BBSL, Greuter MJE, Vleugels JLA, et al. Guidance for setting easy-to-adopt competence criteria for optical diagnosis of diminutive colorectal polyps: a simulation approach. Gastrointest Endosc. 2021. PMID: 33887268. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2021.04.008

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。