COVID-19大流行期间高级胃肠内镜操作的分类管理:基于德尔菲法的共识建议
本研究由14名内镜专家组成专家组,针对ASGE指南中41项高级内镜常见指征,采用改良德尔菲法就患者重要结局达成共识,并将各指征分为时间敏感急诊(1周内)、时间敏感紧急(1至8周内)和非时间敏感(推迟超过8周后重新评估时机)三类。预设51%共识阈值用于确定患者重要结局,预设66.7%共识阈值用于时间分类。41项指征中40项达成时间分类共识,其中12项达100%共识,20项达75%至99%共识。
要点
- 14名专家对41项高级内镜指征进行3轮匿名投票分类。
- 40/41项指征达成66.7%共识阈值的时间分类。
- 12/41项指征达100%共识,20/41项达75%至99%共识。
核心结论
- 采用优先考虑患者重要结局的改良德尔菲法,制定了高级内镜常见指征的操作时机共识建议。
- 这些建议及结构化决策框架可为内镜服务重新开放时的决策提供参考。
研究设计与样本
- 研究选取14名内镜专家组成专家组,从ASGE胃肠内镜合理使用指南中识别41项高级内镜操作常见指征。
- 采用改良德尔菲法,先就每项操作指征的患者重要结局达成共识,再将各指征归入3个操作时间期,允许3轮匿名投票。
主要发现
- 全部14名受邀专家同意参与研究。
- 为每项高级内镜指征分配患者重要结局时,达到预设51%共识阈值。
- 41项高级内镜指征中40项在归入3个操作时间期之一时达到预设66.7%共识阈值。
- 41项指征中12项达100%共识,20项达75%至99%共识。
关键数值与推荐
- 操作时间分类:时间敏感急诊(1周内安排)、时间敏感紧急(1至8周内安排)、非时间敏感(推迟超过8周后重新评估时机)。
- 患者重要结局共识阈值为51%,操作时间分类共识阈值为66.7%。
- 41项指征中40项达成66.7%共识阈值的时间分类,12项达100%共识,20项达75%至99%共识。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: There is a lack of consensus on which GI endoscopic procedures should be performed during the COVID-19 pandemic, and which procedures could be safely deferred without having a significant impact on outcomes. METHODS: We selected a panel of 14 expert endoscopists. We identified 41 common indications for advanced endoscopic procedures from the ASGE Appropriate Use of GI Endoscopy guidelines. Using a modified Delphi method, we first achieved consensus on the patient-important outcome for each procedural indication. Panelists prioritized consensus patient-important outcome when categorizing each indication into one of the following 3 procedural time periods: (1) time-sensitive emergent (schedule within 1 week), (2) time-sensitive urgent (schedule within 1 to 8 weeks), and (3) non-time sensitive (defer for >8 weeks and then reassess the timing). Three anonymous rounds of voting were allowed before attempts at consensus were abandoned. RESULTS: All 14 invited experts agreed to participate in the study. The prespecified consensus threshold of 51% was achieved for assigning patient-important outcome(s) to each advanced endoscopy indication. The prespecified consensus threshold of 66.7% was achieved for 40 of 41 advanced endoscopy indications in stratifying them into 1 of 3 procedural time periods. For 12 of 41 indications, 100% consensus was achieved; for 20 of 41 indications, 75% to 99% consensus was achieved. CONCLUSIONS: By using a Modified Delphi method that prioritized patient-important outcomes, we developed consensus recommendations on procedural timing for common indications for advanced endoscopy. These recommendations and the structured decision framework provided by our study can inform decision making as endoscopy services are reopened.
引用
- Sawhney MS, Bilal M, Pohl H, et al. Triaging advanced GI endoscopy procedures during the COVID-19 pandemic: consensus recommendations using the Delphi method. Gastrointest Endosc. 2020. PMID: 32425235. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2020.05.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。