文献速递消化道肿瘤与早癌消化内镜

结直肠癌诉讼:1988-2018年

Colorectal Cancer Litigation: 1988-2018.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Gastroenterol · 2020-01-01

该研究分析美国1988-2018年240例结直肠癌相关医疗诉讼,辩护胜诉101例(42.1%),原告胜诉37例(15.4%),和解96例(40%)。主要被告为初级保健医生61例(25.4%)和消化内科医生55例(22.9%)。最常见指控为有症状患者未行诊断性结肠镜检查67例(27.9%)、未按筛查指南行结肠镜筛查46例(19.2%)、结肠镜检查未检出结直肠癌45例(18.7%)。

要点

  • 有症状患者未行诊断性结肠镜是最常见指控(67例,27.9%)。
  • 2005年中位年份前非结肠镜方法未检出癌症常见(22例,24.2%),之后仅3例(3.09%)。
  • 初级保健医生和消化内科医生是主要被告(分别为61例和55例)。

核心结论

  • 过去20年结直肠癌医疗诉讼中最常见的原因是原告指控的诊断错误,具体诊断指控(如未筛查与未检出)及监测方法可能随时间变化。
  • 识别结直肠癌筛查中的此类缺陷并探索改进领域,对最大化患者照护和满意度、减少医生医疗诉讼很重要。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究查询法律数据库VerdictSearch的医疗诉讼部分,收集结直肠癌为主要成分的病例,分析原告指控、判决、经济赔偿、病例年份、患者人口学、医疗结局和医生特征。
  • 共收集1988-2018年240例结直肠癌相关医疗诉讼病例。

主要发现

  • 判决结果为辩护胜诉101例(42.1%)、原告胜诉37例(15.4%)、和解96例(40%)。
  • 主要被告为初级保健医生61例(25.4%)和消化内科医生55例(22.9%)。
  • 最常见原告指控为有症状患者未行诊断性结肠镜检查67例(27.9%)、未按筛查指南行结肠镜筛查46例(19.2%)、结肠镜检查未检出结直肠癌45例(18.7%)。
  • 2005年中位年份前非结肠镜方法未检出结直肠癌为常见诊断错误(22例,24.2%),2005年后为3例(3.09%)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: The purpose of this study was to examine colorectal cancer (CRC) malpractice suits over the past 20 years in the United States and evaluate the most common allegations, lawsuit outcomes, indemnity payment amounts, patient outcomes, and physician characteristics. METHODS: The malpractice section of VerdictSearch, a legal database, was queried for cases in which CRC was a principle component of the lawsuit. Legal notes were used to characterize plaintiff allegations, verdict, financial compensation, and case year. Clinical history for each case were analyzed for patient demographics, medical outcomes, and physician characteristics. RESULTS: A total of 240 CRC-related malpractice cases (1988-2018) were collected, resulting in defense (n = 101, 42.1%), plaintiff (n = 37, 15.4%), or settlement (n = 96, 40%) verdict. The primary defendants were often primary care physicians (n = 61, 25.4%) and gastroenterologists (n = 55, 22.9%). Most common plaintiff allegations are failure to perform diagnostic colonoscopy for patients with symptoms (n = 67, 27.9%), failure to perform screening colonoscopy according to screening guidelines (n = 46, 19.2%), or failure to detect CRC with colonoscopy (n = 45, 18.7%). A common alleged error in diagnosis before the median year of 2005 was failure to detect CRC by the noncolonoscopic methods (<2005: n = 22, 24.2%; >2005: n = 3, 3.09%). DISCUSSION: Plaintiff-alleged errors in diagnosis are consistently the most common reason for CRC malpractice litigation in the past 20 years, whereas specific diagnostic allegations (i.e., failure to screen vs failure to detect) and methods used for surveillance may vary over time. It is important to identify such pitfalls in CRC screening and explore areas for improvement to maximize patient care and satisfaction and reduce physician malpractice litigations.

来源:Am J Gastroenterol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Panuganti PL, Hartnett DA, Eltorai AEM, et al. Colorectal Cancer Litigation: 1988-2018. Am J Gastroenterol. 2020. PMID: 32453040. doi:10.14309/ajg.0000000000000705

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。