大流行期间肝移植方案的国际多中心研究:四维平衡的案例
该国际多中心研究调查了2020年3月大流行期间17个肝移植中心的移植优先政策演变,提出四维平衡(QE)评分框架,综合受者结局、供者/移植物安全、等待名单死亡率和医疗资源4个因素,用于在资源受限时平衡肝移植需求与国家资源。
要点
- 来自4大洲12个国家的17个大中型肝移植中心参与研究。
- 10个中心选择限制移植活动,倾向「最重优先」策略。
- 部分较大中心选择继续常规移植活动以平衡等待名单死亡率。
核心结论
- 四维平衡模型可应对当前大流行中的伦理张力,作为通用框架指导移植活动调控以应对医疗系统负担增加。
研究设计与样本
- 国际多中心研究,调查2020年3月大流行期间移植中心移植优先政策的演变。
- 17个来自12个国家、4大洲的大中型肝移植中心参与。
主要发现
- 10个中心选择限制移植活动,倾向「最重优先」策略。
- 部分较大中心选择继续常规移植活动以平衡等待名单死亡率。
- 对7个国家计算QE评分,评分随时间波动准确反映大流行期间移植活动伦理张力的动态变化。
关键数值与推荐
- QE评分使用4个因素:受者结局、供者/移植物安全、等待名单死亡率和医疗资源。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND & AIMS: The outbreak of COVID-19 has vastly increased the operational burden on healthcare systems worldwide. For patients with end-stage liver failure, liver transplantation is the only option. However, the strain on intensive care facilities caused by the pandemic is a major concern. There is an urgent need for ethical frameworks to balance the need for liver transplantation against the availability of national resources. METHODS: We performed an international multicenter study of transplant centers to understand the evolution of policies for transplant prioritization in response to the pandemic in March 2020. To describe the ethical tension arising in this setting, we propose a novel ethical framework, the quadripartite equipoise (QE) score, that is applicable to liver transplantation in the context of limited national resources. RESULTS: Seventeen large- and medium-sized liver transplant centers from 12 countries across 4 continents participated. Ten centers opted to limit transplant activity in response to the pandemic, favoring a "sickest-first" approach. Conversely, some larger centers opted to continue routine transplant activity in order to balance waiting list mortality. To model these and other ethical tensions, we computed a QE score using 4 factors - recipient outcome, donor/graft safety, waiting list mortality and healthcare resources - for 7 countries. The fluctuation of the QE score over time accurately reflects the dynamic changes in the ethical tensions surrounding transplant activity in a pandemic. CONCLUSIONS: This four-dimensional model of quadripartite equipoise addresses the ethical tensions in the current pandemic. It serves as a universally applicable framework to guide regulation of transplant activity in response to the increasing burden on healthcare systems. LAY SUMMARY: There is an urgent need for ethical frameworks to balance the need for liver transplantation against the availability of national resources during the COVID-19 pandemic. We describe a four-dimensional model of quadripartite equipoise that models these ethical tensions and can guide the regulation of transplant activity in response to the increasing burden on healthcare systems.
引用
- Chew CA, Iyer SG, Kow AWC, et al. An international multicenter study of protocols for liver transplantation during a pandemic: A case for quadripartite equipoise. J Hepatol. 2020. PMID: 32454041. doi:10.1016/j.jhep.2020.05.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。