单人操作胆道镜引导碎石与大球囊括约肌成形术治疗困难胆管结石的随机试验疗效比较
该随机试验纳入经球囊或网篮取石失败的困难胆管结石患者66例,比较单人操作胆道镜引导激光碎石(SOC-LL,n=33)与大球囊括约肌成形术(LBS,n=33)的单次取石成功率。
要点
- SOC-LL单次胆管清除率93.9%优于LBS的72.7%
- 结石/肝外胆管直径比≤1与SOC-LL成功独立相关
- 远端胆管渐细者LBS单用成功率低,可能需辅助碎石
核心结论
- 对标准方法无法清除的困难胆管结石,SOC引导碎石的单次胆管清除率显著高于LBS。
研究设计与样本
- 随机试验,2016年6月至2018年8月纳入气球或网篮取石失败的困难胆管结石患者,SOC-LL组33例、LBS组33例。
临床怎么用
- 困难胆管结石标准取石失败后,可优先考虑SOC引导激光碎石以提高单次清除率。
- 结石直径超过肝外胆管直径或远端胆管渐细时,LBS单用成功率低,宜联合辅助碎石。
局限性
- 样本量较小(每组33例),部分次要终点置信区间宽。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND & AIMS: Although single-operator cholangioscopy (SOC)-guided lithotripsy and large balloon sphincteroplasty (LBS)-based techniques are effective rescue measures, the ideal approach to management of difficult bile duct stones is unclear. We conducted a randomized trial to compare the effectiveness of SOC-guided lithotripsy and LBS-based approaches for endoscopic management of difficult bile duct stones. METHODS: Patients with difficult bile duct stones who failed retrieval using balloon or basket were randomly assigned to groups that received SOC-guided laser lithotripsy (SOC-LL, n = 33) or LBS (n = 33), from June 2016 through August 2018. When assigned treatment was unsuccessful, patients underwent mechanical lithotripsy before crossing over to the other group. The main outcome was treatment success, defined as ability to clear the duct in 1 session. Secondary outcomes were adverse events and treatment costs. RESULTS: A higher proportion of patients in the SOC-LL group had treatment success (93.9%) than in the LBS group (72.7%; P = .021). On multiple logistic regression analysis, treatment success was significantly associated with use of SOC-LL (odds ratio [OR], 8.7; 95% CI, 1.3-59.3; P = .026), stone to extrahepatic bile duct ratio of 1 or less (OR, 28.8; 95% CI, 1.2-687.6; P = .038), and lack of a tapered bile duct (OR, 26.9; 95% CI, 1.3-558.2; P = .034). There was no significant difference between groups in adverse events (9.1% in the SOC-LL group vs 3.0% in the LBS group, P = .61) or overall treatment cost ($16,684 in the SOC-LL group vs $10,626 in the LBS group; P = .097). CONCLUSIONS: In a randomized trial of patients with difficult bile stones that cannot be cleared by standard maneuvers, SOC-guided lithotripsy leads to duct clearance in a significantly higher proportion of patients than LBS-particularly when stone size exceeds the diameter of the extrahepatic bile duct. Adjunct lithotripsy might be required in patients with tapered distal bile duct, because LBS alone is less likely to be successful. ClinicalTrials.gov no: NCT00852072.
引用
- Bang JY, Sutton B, Navaneethan U, et al. Efficacy of Single-Operator Cholangioscopy-Guided Lithotripsy Compared With Large Balloon Sphincteroplasty in Management of Difficult Bile Duct Stones in a Randomized Trial. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2020. PMID: 32057976. doi:10.1016/j.cgh.2020.02.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。