个体化反馈对内镜学习曲线的影响:整群随机对照试验
这项多中心整群随机对照试验比较了结构化个体化学习曲线反馈与标准反馈对消化内科受训医师胃镜和结肠镜学习曲线的影响。共13个项目132名受训者参与,结果显示季度个体化学习曲线反馈在临床意义上未显著影响胃镜和结肠镜的学习曲线。
要点
- 个体化学习曲线反馈未显著改善胃镜和结肠镜的整体技术及认知技能学习曲线。
- 仅胃镜整体认知技能在干预组优于对照组,但整体技术技能无差异。
- 结肠镜的整体认知和技术技能在两组间均无差异。
核心结论
- 以个体化学习曲线形式提供的季度反馈未以临床有意义的方式影响胃镜和结肠镜的学习曲线。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心整群随机对照试验,共纳入13个项目、132名受训者;干预组6个项目51名受训者,对照组7个项目81名受训者。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Gastroenterology fellowships need to ensure that trainees achieve competence in upper endoscopy (EGD) and colonoscopy. Because the impact of structured feedback remains unknown in endoscopy training, this study compared the effect of structured feedback with standard feedback on trainee learning curves for EGD and colonoscopy. METHODS: In this multicenter, cluster, randomized controlled trial, trainees received either individualized quarterly learning curves or feedback standard to their fellowship. Assessment was performed in all trainees using the Assessment of Competency in Endoscopy tool on 5 consecutive procedures after every 25 EGDs and colonoscopies. Individual learning curves were created using cumulative sum (CUSUM) analysis. The primary outcome was the mean CUSUM score in overall technical and overall cognitive skills. RESULTS: In all, 13 programs including 132 trainees participated. The intervention arm (6 programs, 51 trainees) contributed 558 EGD and 600 colonoscopy assessments. The control arm (7 programs, 81 trainees) provided 305 EGD and 468 colonoscopy assessments. For EGD, the intervention arm (-.7 [standard deviation {SD}, 1.3]) had a superior mean CUSUM score in overall cognitive skills compared with the control arm (1.6 [SD, .8], P = .03) but not in overall technical skills (intervention, -.26 [SD, 1.4]; control, 1.76 [SD, .7]; P = .06). For colonoscopy, no differences were found between the 2 arms in overall cognitive skills (intervention, -.7 [SD, 1.3]; control, .7 [SD, 1.3]; P = .95) or overall technical skills (intervention, .1 [SD, 1.5]; control, -.1 [SD, 1.5]; P = .77). CONCLUSIONS: Quarterly feedback in the form of individualized learning curves did not affect learning curves for EGD and colonoscopy in a clinically meaningful manner. (Clinical trial registration number: NCT02891304.).
引用
- Han S, Obuch JC, Keswani RN, et al. Effect of individualized feedback on learning curves in EGD and colonoscopy: a cluster randomized controlled trial. Gastrointest Endosc. 2019. PMID: 31715173. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2019.10.032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。