水下与传统内镜切除非微小无蒂结直肠病变的前瞻性随机对照试验
UR与CR不完全切除率低且无差异(2% vs 1.9%,P=.91);对≥10mm病变UR切除更快(10-19mm:2.9 vs 5.6分钟,P<.0001;≥20mm:7.3 vs 9.5分钟,P=.015)。
要点
- UR与CR的不完全切除率均低且无显著差异(2% vs 1.9%,P=.91)。
- 对≥10mm无蒂病变,UR切除速度显著快于CR。
- UR对较大病变可避免黏膜下注射,有潜在成本节约优势。
核心结论
- UR与CR均可实现低不完全切除率,UR对≥10mm病变切除更快且安全有效。
主要发现
- UR与CR不完全切除率分别为2%与1.9%,差异无统计学意义(P=.91)。
- 对10-19mm病变,UR切除时间2.9分钟 vs CR 5.6分钟,P<.0001。
- 对≥20mm病变,UR切除时间7.3分钟 vs CR 9.5分钟,P=.015。
关键数值与推荐
- 小病变(6-9mm)两臂均使用专用冷圈套器切除。
- CR大病变在黏膜下注射后使用热圈套器切除;UR大病变不使用黏膜下注射,直接使用热圈套器切除。
- 以切除部位四周四象限活检评估不完全切除。
临床怎么用
- 对≥10mm无蒂结直肠病变,可考虑采用UR以缩短切除时间并避免黏膜下注射。
- UR可作为提高结肠镜检查效率、维持切除质量的附加方法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Incomplete resection of colorectal neoplasia decreases the efficacy of colonoscopy. Conventional resection (CR) of polyps, performed in a gas-distended colon, is the current standard, but incomplete resection rates of approximately 2% to 30% for nondiminutive (>5 mm), nonpedunculated lesions are reported. Underwater resection (UR) is a novel technique. The aim of this study was to determine the incomplete resection rates of colorectal lesions removed by UR versus CR. METHODS: In a randomized controlled trial, patients with small (6-9 mm) and large (≥10 mm) nonpedunculated lesions were assigned to CR (gas-distended lumen) or UR (water-filled, gas-excluded lumen). Small lesions in both arms were removed with a dedicated cold snare. For CR, large lesions were removed with a hot snare after submucosal injection. For UR, large lesions were removed with a hot snare without submucosal injection. Four-quadrant biopsy samples around the resection sites were used to evaluate for incomplete resection. RESULTS: Four hundred sixty-two eligible polyps (248 UR vs 214 CR) from 255 patients were removed. Incomplete resection rates for UR and CR were low and did not differ (2% vs 1.9%, P = .91). UR was performed significantly faster for lesions ≥10 mm in size (10-19 mm, 2.9 minutes vs 5.6 minutes, P < .0001); ≥20 mm, 7.3 minutes vs 9.5 minutes, P = .015). CONCLUSIONS: Low incomplete resection rates are achievable with UR and CR. UR is effective and safe with the advantage of faster resection and potential cost savings for removal of larger (≥10 mm) lesions by avoiding submucosal injection. As an added approach, UR has potential to improve the cost-effectiveness of colonoscopy by increasing efficiency and reducing cost while maintaining quality. (Clinical trial registration number: NCT02889679.).
引用
- Yen AW, Leung JW, Wilson MD, et al. Underwater versus conventional endoscopic resection of nondiminutive nonpedunculated colorectal lesions: a prospective randomized controlled trial (with video). Gastrointest Endosc. 2019. PMID: 31628954. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2019.09.039
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。