林奇综合征患者结肠镜检查:第三代窄带成像与靛胭脂染色内镜的背靠背比较
一项多中心前瞻性非劣效试验纳入138例林奇综合征错配修复突变携带者,先后行NBI和ICC结肠镜检查。NBI检出至少一个腺瘤的患者为20.3%,NBI联合ICC为30.4%(差值10.1%,95%CI -0.1%-20.3%),未能证实NBI非劣效于联合方案,故不推荐NBI替代ICC。
要点
- 在林奇综合征患者中,NBI单用检出腺瘤患者比例低于NBI联合ICC(20.3% vs 30.4%)。
- NBI的中位退镜时间8分钟,短于ICC的13分钟,但腺瘤检出率不足。
- 不推荐用第三代NBI替代靛胭脂染色内镜用于林奇综合征结肠镜筛查。
核心结论
- 在林奇综合征患者中,第三代NBI单用检出腺瘤的患者比例非劣效于NBI联合ICC的假设未成立,不推荐NBI替代ICC。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心、前瞻性、非劣效性试验,采用背靠背设计,138例林奇综合征错配修复突变携带者先后接受NBI和ICC结肠镜检查。
主要发现
- NBI初次检查检出至少一个腺瘤的患者为28例(20.3%),NBI联合ICC后为42例(30.4%),差值10.1%(95%CI -0.1%-20.3%)。
- ICC在25例患者(18.1%)中检出额外腺瘤,腺瘤检出率相对增加50.0%。
- NBI中位退镜时间8分钟(四分位距6-11),ICC中位退镜时间13分钟(四分位距8-17)。
关键数值与推荐
- 非劣效性主要结局为NBI后至少一个腺瘤的患者数与NBI联合ICC后至少一个腺瘤的患者数比较。
- 138例可分析患者均为林奇综合征错配修复突变携带者:MLH1 33%、MSH2 47%、MSH6 15%、PMS2 4%、EPCAM 1%。
- 平均年龄40.5岁(SD 14.7),男性64例(46.4%)。
临床怎么用
- 在林奇综合征结肠镜监测中,不应以第三代NBI替代靛胭脂染色内镜。
- 若考虑使用NBI,需联合ICC以提高腺瘤检出,但退镜时间可能延长。
局限性
- 原文未报告
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Colonoscopic screening with indigo carmine chromoendoscopy (ICC) in patients with Lynch syndrome (LS) improves the adenoma detection rate but is time consuming and poorly used in clinical practice. Narrow-band imaging (NBI), a virtual chromoendoscopy technique, highlights superficial mucosal vessels and improves adenoma characterization. We conducted a prospective multicenter trial in a back-to-back fashion to compare the third-generation NBI with ICC for detecting colonic adenomas in patients with LS. METHODS: In a multicenter, prospective, noninferiority trial, 138 patients underwent a double colonoscopy, first with NBI, followed by ICC, in a back-to-back design. The primary noninferiority outcome measure was the number of patients with at least one adenoma after NBI compared with the number of patients with at least one adenoma after NBI and ICC. RESULTS: The 138 analyzable patients were all proven mismatch repair mutation carriers for LS (MLH1 = 33%, MSH2 = 47%, MSH6 = 15%, PMS2 = 4%, and EPCAM = 1%). The mean age (SD) was 40.5 (14.7) years, and 64 (46.4%) were men. The median withdrawal time for an NBI procedure was 8 minutes (interquartile range 6-11) compared with 13 minutes (interquartile range 8-17) for ICC. At least one adenoma was detected during the initial NBI pass in 28 patients (20.3%), and 42 patients (30.4%) had at least one adenoma detected after both NBI and ICC (difference, 10.1%; 95% confidence interval, -0.1%-20.3%); this represents an increase of 50.0% of the adenoma detection rate. ICC detected additional adenomas in 25 patients (18.1%). DISCUSSION: Colonoscopy combining NBI and ICC detects more adenomas than third-generation NBI alone in patients with LS, respectively, 30.4% vs 20.3% (difference, 10.1%; 95% confidence interval, -0.1 to 20.3), thus failing the noninferiority assumption of NBI compared with combined NBI and ICC. Although less time consuming, colonoscopy using the third-generation NBI cannot be recommended to replace ICC in patients with LS.
引用
- Cellier C, Perrod G, Colas C, et al. Back-to-Back Comparison of Colonoscopy With Virtual Chromoendoscopy Using a Third-Generation Narrow-Band Imaging System to Chromoendoscopy With Indigo Carmine in Patients With Lynch Syndrome. Am J Gastroenterol. 2019. PMID: 31498154. doi:10.14309/ajg.0000000000000386
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。