文献速递消化内镜

基于德尔福调查的消化内镜教学最佳实践

Best Practices in Teaching Endoscopy Based on a Delphi Survey of Gastroenterology Program Directors and Experts in Endoscopy Education.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol · 2019-05-21

本研究通过文献回顾和专家访谈制定18项内镜教学胜任力,邀请36名消化病学专科培训项目主任和内镜教育专家进行两轮德尔福调查,以70%同意阈值为共识标准。结果显示14项(77.8%)达成共识,其中10项(55.6%)被认为必需,4项(22.2%)被认为重要但非必需。研究识别出10项必需内镜教学胜任力,可用于框架师资发展和标准化消化病学专科培训项目。

要点

  • 14项(77.8%)内镜教学胜任力在两轮德尔福调查后达成共识,其中10项(55.6%)为必需。
  • 必需胜任力包括与受训者讨论患者病史和手术计划(100%)、在受训者无法进展或患者安全担忧时接管手术(100%)。
  • 必需胜任力还包括全程保持注意力(96.8%)和讨论患者下一步管理(96.8%)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Teaching endoscopy is a key objective of gastroenterology (GI) fellowship programs but the best approach is not known. We sought to characterize which teaching competencies experts considered most critical for endoscopy education. METHODS: We developed and refined 18 endoscopy teaching competencies based on literature review, personal experience, and interviews with experts. We invited GI fellowship program directors and endoscopy education experts to participate in a Delphi process to rate each proposed competency as essential, important but not essential, or not important using a 70% agreement threshold for consensus. Thirty-four GI fellowship program directors and 2 experts in endoscopy education participated (n = 36). RESULTS: Most survey participants were male (61.8%), associate professors (55.9%), and had performed at least a quarter of procedures with fellows (80.6%). Survey response rates were 94% (34 of 36) for round 1 and 91% (31 of 34) for round 2 (overall 31 of 36; 86.1%). After 2 rounds we achieved the predefined consensus level for most competencies. Fourteen of 18 competencies (77.8%) reached consensus after round 2: 10 (55.6%) were deemed essential and 4 (22.2%) were deemed important but not essential. Essential competencies included the following: discusses patient history and plans for procedure with trainee (100%), assumes control of procedure when trainee is unable to progress or if patient safety concerns arise (100%), maintains attention throughout the case (96.8%), and discusses the next steps in management for the patient (96.8%). CONCLUSIONS: In a national Delphi survey of endoscopy education experts, we identified 10 essential endoscopy teaching competencies. These can be used to frame faculty development and standardize GI fellowship programs to promote high-quality endoscopy education.

来源:Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kumar NL, Smith BN, Lee LS, et al. Best Practices in Teaching Endoscopy Based on a Delphi Survey of Gastroenterology Program Directors and Experts in Endoscopy Education. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2019. PMID: 31125782. doi:10.1016/j.cgh.2019.05.023

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。