文献速递消化内镜

内镜操作能力评估工具在食管胃十二指肠镜中的验证与可推广基准

Competency in esophagogastroduodenoscopy: a validated tool for assessment and generalizable benchmarks for gastroenterology fellows.
PubMed 文献 · Gastrointest Endosc · 2019-05-20

美国多中心前瞻性研究纳入10所学术机构的96名消化内科fellow,用ACE-E工具评估1002例EGD,确定ACE-E均分3.5、独立D2插管率≥95%、D2插管时间≤4.75分钟为最低胜任标准,平均需150例达到插管操作充分、250例达到认知与运动技能最低胜任。

要点

  • ACE-E均分3.5涵盖各核心技能的全部最低胜任阈值。
  • 独立D2插管率≥95%、D2插管时间≤4.75分钟、平均总操作时间≤12.5分钟区分胜任与非胜任组。
  • 平均需100例和150例分别达到D2插管率与时间标准,其余指标需200至250例。

核心结论

  • 描述了消化内科fellow EGD技能的全美可推广学习曲线。
  • 推荐ACE-E均分3.5、独立D2插管率95%、D2插管时间≤4.75分钟作为最低胜任标准。
  • 平均仅需150例即可充分驱动内镜,但达到其余认知与运动技能最低胜任需250例。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性多中心试验,美国10所学术机构的96名各培训阶段消化内科fellow,共评估1002例EGD。
  • 由带教使用ACE-E工具评估核心认知与运动技能,每50例评估一次,一学年内完成。
  • ACE-E采用4分评分量表定义从新手到胜任的技能连续体,用对比组法建立各技能总体胜任基准。

主要发现

  • ACE-E均分3.5涵盖各核心技能确定的所有最低胜任阈值。
  • 独立D2插管率≥95%、D2插管时间≤4.75分钟、平均总操作时间≤12.5分钟为区分胜任与非胜任组的界值。
  • 平均fellow达到D2插管率和时间标准分别需100例和150例,其余指标达到ACE-E阈值分通常需200至250例。

关键数值与推荐

  • 最低胜任标准推荐:ACE-E均分3.5、独立D2插管率95%、D2插管时间≤4.75分钟。
  • 区分胜任与非胜任组的界值:独立D2插管率≥95%、D2插管时间≤4.75分钟、平均总操作时间≤12.5分钟。
  • 平均fellow达到D2插管率标准需100例,达到D2插管时间标准需150例,其余指标达阈值分需200至250例。

临床怎么用

  • 作者推荐将ACE-E均分3.5、独立D2插管率95%、D2插管时间≤4.75分钟作为最低胜任标准。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: The Assessment of Competency in Endoscopy (ACE) tools for colonoscopy and EGD were both put forth by the Training Committee of the American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy (ASGE), with the intent of providing teachers and programs a means to continuously assess fellow skills in these procedures throughout their years of training. Despite the availability of the tools, there are no data that define when competency in EGD has been reached. The goal of this study is to validate the EGD ACE tool (ACE-E) and for the first time describe learning curves and competency benchmarks for EGD by examining a large national cohort of trainees. METHODS: In a prospective, multicenter trial, gastroenterology fellows at all stages of training had their core cognitive and motor skills in EGDs assessed by staff using the ACE-E tool. Evaluations occurred at set intervals of every 50 procedures over an academic year. Like the previously reported and validated ACE tool for colonoscopy, the ACE-E tool uses a 4-point grading scale to define a skills continuum from novice to competent. At each assessment interval, average scores for each skill were computed and overall competency benchmarks for each skill were established using the contrasting groups method. RESULTS: Ninety-six GI fellows at 10 U.S. academic institutions had 1002 EGDs assessed using the ACE-E tool. Average ACE-E scores of 3.5 were found to be inclusive of all minimal competency thresholds identified for each core skill. In addition, independent intubation of the second part of the duodenum (D2) at rates of ≥95% as well as D2 intubation times of ≤4.75 minutes and average total procedure times of ≤12.5 minutes were identified as the points separating competent from non-competent groups. Although the average fellow achieves the D2 intubation rates and time criteria by 100 and 150 procedures, respectively, achieving ACE-E threshold scores on the remaining metrics was typically not achieved until 200 to 250 procedures. CONCLUSIONS: Nationally generalizable learning curves for EGD skills in GI fellows are described. Average ACE-E scores of 3.5, independent D2 intubation rates of 95%, and D2 intubation times of ≤4.75 minutes are recommended as minimum competency criteria. On average, it takes GI fellows only 150 procedures to simply drive the scope adequately but 250 procedures to achieve minimum competence in the remaining cognitive and motor skills. The D2 intubation rate threshold and learning curve found in this multicenter cohort using the ACE-E tool are similar to those recently described by researchers in the United Kingdom; however, development of cognitive and overall competence requires a higher procedure threshold than previously described.

来源:Gastrointest Endosc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Miller AT, Sedlack RE. Competency in esophagogastroduodenoscopy: a validated tool for assessment and generalizable benchmarks for gastroenterology fellows. Gastrointest Endosc. 2019. PMID: 31121154. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2019.05.024

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。