设定超声内镜与内镜逆行胰胆管造影培训的最低标准:一项评估高级内镜受训者学习曲线与胜任力的前瞻性多中心研究结果
该前瞻性多中心研究纳入来自32个高级内镜培训项目的37名受训者,按每第5例超声内镜(EUS)和经内镜逆行胰胆管造影(ERCP)检查用经验证工具评分,并用累积和及广义线性混合效应模型生成总体学习曲线。平均受训者在约225例EUS和250例ERCP时达到核心技能胜任力,但ERCP难度2级的总体技术胜任力约需300例。
要点
- 平均高级内镜受训者在约225例EUS和250例ERCP时达到核心技能胜任力。
- ERCP难度2级的总体技术胜任力约需300例。
- 作者认为上述阈值可供美国胃肠内镜学会(ASGE)和培训项目设定最低病例量标准。
核心结论
- 平均高级内镜受训者在约225例EUS和250例ERCP时达到核心EUS和ERCP技能胜任力,ERCP难度2级的总体技术胜任力约需300例。
- 作者认为所提供阈值可供美国胃肠内镜学会(ASGE)和高级内镜培训项目用于设定培训期间最低病例量暴露标准。
研究设计与样本
- 邀请美国胃肠内镜学会(ASGE)认可的高级内镜培训项目参与的前瞻性多中心研究。
- 来自32个培训项目的37名高级内镜受训者参与,对每第5例EUS和ERCP检查用经验证工具按4分制评分。
- 使用累积和分析生成EUS和ERCP总体、技术及认知部分的学习曲线,并每季度与受训者和培训师共享。
- 采用以每名受训者为随机截距的广义线性混合效应模型生成汇总学习曲线。
- 临床试验注册号:NCT02509416。
主要发现
- 多数受训者在开始培训前有EUS操作经验(52%,中位20例)和ERCP操作经验(68%,中位50例)。
- 每名受训者完成的EUS和ERCP中位数分别为400例(范围200-750)和361例(范围250-650)。
- 共评分2616例检查(EUS 1277例;ERCP胆道1143例、胰腺196例)。
- 多数评分EUS检查为胰胆适应证(69.9%),多数评分ERCP检查为ASGE胆道难度1级(72.1%)。
- 平均受训者在约225例EUS和250例ERCP时达到核心EUS和ERCP技能胜任力,ERCP难度2级的总体技术胜任力约在300例时达到。
关键数值与推荐
- 平均高级内镜受训者达到核心EUS技能胜任力约需225例。
- 平均高级内镜受训者达到核心ERCP技能胜任力约需250例。
- ERCP难度2级的总体技术胜任力约需300例。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为所提供阈值可供美国胃肠内镜学会(ASGE)和高级内镜培训项目用于设定培训期间最低病例量暴露标准。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Minimum EUS and ERCP volumes that should be offered per trainee in "high quality" advanced endoscopy training programs (AETPs) are not established. We aimed to define the number of procedures required by an "average" advanced endoscopy trainee (AET) to achieve competence in technical and cognitive EUS and ERCP tasks to help structure AETPs. METHODS: American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy (ASGE)-recognized AETPs were invited to participate; AETs were graded on every fifth EUS and ERCP examination using a validated tool. Grading for each skill was done using a 4-point scoring system, and learning curves using cumulative sum analysis for overall, technical, and cognitive components of EUS and ERCP were shared with AETs and trainers quarterly. Generalized linear mixed-effects models with a random intercept for each AET were used to generate aggregate learning curves, allowing us to use data from all AETs to estimate the average learning experience for trainees. RESULTS: Among 62 invited AETPs, 37 AETs from 32 AETPs participated. Most AETs reported hands-on EUS (52%, median 20 cases) and ERCP (68%, median 50 cases) experience before starting an AETP. The median number of EUS and ERCPs performed per AET was 400 (range, 200-750) and 361 (range, 250-650), respectively. Overall, 2616 examinations were graded (EUS, 1277; ERCP-biliary, 1143; pancreatic, 196). Most graded EUS examinations were performed for pancreatobiliary indications (69.9%) and ERCP examinations for ASGE biliary grade of difficulty 1 (72.1%). The average AET achieved competence in core EUS and ERCP skills at approximately 225 and 250 cases, respectively. However, overall technical competence was achieved for grade 2 ERCP at about 300 cases. CONCLUSION: The thresholds provided for an average AET to achieve competence in EUS and ERCP may be used by the ASGE and AETPs in establishing the minimal standards for case volume exposure for AETs during their training. (Clinical trial registration number: NCT02509416.).
引用
- Wani S, Han S, Simon V, et al. Setting minimum standards for training in EUS and ERCP: results from a prospective multicenter study evaluating learning curves and competence among advanced endoscopy trainees. Gastrointest Endosc. 2019. PMID: 30738985. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2019.01.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。