呼吁标准化定义、数据收集和结局评估以改善酒精相关性肝病的诊疗
酒精相关性肝病(ALD)患病率高且死亡率上升,优化诊疗需多学科综合方法。本文指出当前临床定义(如酒精相关性肝炎)与病理不符、研究多依赖临床诊断缺乏病理确认,导致疗效与移植数据受异质性限制,且复发报告定义不一、评估不可靠。作者呼吁建立标准化定义和数据收集工具,以生成可靠可重复的研究结果。
要点
- 超过95%的重度酒精相关性肝炎发生于肝硬化背景,但不足60%的肝移植标本有肝炎病理表现。
- 多数ALD研究依赖临床诊断而缺乏病理确认,疗效与移植数据受试验间和试验内异质性限制。
- 作者呼吁统一定义并建立标准化数据收集工具,以生成可靠可重复的结果。
核心结论
- 为优化患者诊疗并最佳利用有限资源,必须系统性改变该人群的研究方法,建立一致的定义以生成可靠可重复的结果。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为文献综述,简要回顾文献以总结ALD治疗与管理现状、定义异质性及临床与研究改进的重大机会。
主要发现
- 超过95%的重度酒精相关性肝炎发生于肝硬化背景,而不足60%的肝移植标本有肝炎病理表现。
- 多数ALD研究依赖临床诊断且缺乏病理确认,既往药物治疗疗效或移植应用数据可能受试验间和试验内异质性限制。
- 当前领域局限性还包括复发报告不一致、使用不同定义且评估不可靠。
- 研究未能一致捕获可能影响该人群主要结局(死亡和复发)的数据变量。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 当前临床定义未反映超过95%的重度酒精相关性肝炎发生于肝硬化且不足60%的肝移植标本有肝炎病理表现。
- 多数ALD研究依赖临床诊断且缺乏病理确认,既往治疗疗效或移植数据可能受试验间和试验内异质性限制。
- 复发报告不一致,使用不同定义且评估不可靠。
- 研究未能一致捕获可能影响死亡和复发主要结局的数据变量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Alcohol-related liver disease (ALD) is highly prevalent and appears to be increasingly reported with worsening mortality; thus, optimizing care in this patient population is imperative. This will require a multidisciplinary, multifaceted approach that includes recognizing alcohol use disorder (AUD) and existing treatments for AUD. We must also acknowledge the full spectrum of ALD clinically and histologically. For example, our current clinical definitions of alcohol-related hepatitis (AH) do not address that >95% of severe AH occurs in the setting of cirrhosis with <60% of liver explants having hepatitis. Given that the majority of ALD studies rely on clinical diagnosis and lack pathologic confirmation, prior data on the efficacy of medical treatment or use of transplantation are likely limited by intertrial and intratrial heterogeneity. Added limitations of the current field include the inconsistent reporting of relapse with the use of varying definitions and unreliable assessments. Moreover, studies fail to consistently capture the data variables that likely influence the main outcomes of interest in this population-mortality and relapse-and a global effort to create a standardized data collection tool moving forward could help effectively and efficiently aid in the advancement of this field. Conclusion: To optimize patient care and make best use of a limited resource, a systematic change in the approach to research in this population must be undertaken that creates consistent definitions for use in future research to generate reliable and reproducible results. With this in mind, we concisely reviewed the literature to summarize the current state of treating and managing ALD, the heterogeneity in definitions, and the significant opportunities for clinical and research improvement.
引用
- Shen NT, Salajegheh A, Brown RS, et al. A Call to Standardize Definitions, Data Collection, and Outcome Assessment to Improve Care in Alcohol-Related Liver Disease. Hepatology. 2019. PMID: 30802988. doi:10.1002/hep.30587
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。