盲肠插管率因计算方法而异:呼吁内镜关键绩效指标标准化
该研究通过系统综述比较了英国、ESGE和ASGE指南及37项研究中盲肠插管率(CIR)的计算方法,并以2011年6月至2016年间获结肠镜认证的733名学员(36,650例操作)为验证队列。结果显示不同定义下粗CIR中位数从96%(ESGE)到98%(ASGE)不等,未达标(CIR≥90%)学员比例从4.9%(ASGE粗CIR定义)到18.6%(ESGE无辅助CIR定义)不等。结论认为CIR计算方法差异影响学员绩效评价,需标准化内镜关键绩效指标的定义与计算。
要点
- 不同指南与研究对CIR的计算方法存在差异,涉及调整标准和是否规定无辅助CIR。
- 验证队列中粗CIR中位数从96%(ESGE)到98%(ASGE)不等(P < .001)。
- 未达到CIR≥90%的学员比例从4.9%(ASGE粗CIR定义)到18.6%(ESGE无辅助CIR定义)不等(P < .001)。
核心结论
- CIR计算方法在指南和研究间存在差异,影响学员绩效评价,需标准化内镜关键绩效指标的定义与计算。
研究设计与样本
- 对英国、ESGE和ASGE指南及37项含学员的研究进行系统综述,并从英国电子档案中选取2011年6月至2016年间获结肠镜认证的733名学员作为验证队列,每人计算认证后50例操作的粗CIR和无辅助CIR。
主要发现
- 37项符合条件的研究中,18项涉及调整标准,18项涉及是否规定无辅助CIR。
- 验证队列共36,650例操作,粗CIR中位数从96%(ESGE)到98%(ASGE)不等(P < .001)。
- 是否规定无辅助CIR也影响结果:ESGE为94%,ASGE为96%(P < .001)。
- 未达到CIR≥90%的学员比例从4.9%(ASGE粗CIR定义)到18.6%(ESGE无辅助CIR定义)不等(P < .001)。
关键数值与推荐
- CIR最低标准为≥90%。
- 粗CIR中位数:ESGE定义96%,ASGE定义98%(P < .001)。
- 无辅助CIR:ESGE定义94%,ASGE定义96%(P < .001)。
- 未达标学员比例:ASGE粗CIR定义4.9%,ESGE无辅助CIR定义18.6%(P < .001)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: The cecal intubation rate (CIR) is a widely accepted key performance indicator (KPI) in colonoscopy but lacks a universal calculation method. We aimed to assess whether differences in CIR calculation methods could have an impact on perceived trainee outcomes. METHODS: A systematic review of CIR calculation methods was conducted on major societal guidelines (United Kingdom, European Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy [ESGE] and American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy [ASGE]) and trainee-inclusive studies. Trainees awarded colonoscopy certification between June 2011 and 2016 were identified from the United Kingdom e-portfolio and selected as a validation cohort. For each trainee, both the crude and unassisted CIR were calculated for 50 post-certification procedures using definitions from the 3 international guidelines. The resulting CIRs, and the proportions of endoscopists failing to meet the minimum standard of CIR ≥90%, were then compared across these definitions. RESULTS: Across the 3 guidelines and 37 eligible studies identified, differences in CIR calculation methodology were demonstrated. These related to adjustment criteria (18 studies) and whether unassisted CIR was stipulated (18 studies). In the validation cohort of 733 trainees (36,650 procedures), the median crude CIR ranged from 96% (ESGE) to 98% (ASGE) (P < .001) and whether unassisted CIR was specified (ESGE, 94%; ASGE, 96%; P < .001). The proportion of trainees failing to achieve CIR ≥90% varied significantly across the different definitions, from 4.9% for the crude ASGE definition to 18.6% for the unassisted ESGE definition (P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: CIR calculation methods vary among guidelines and research studies; this has an impact on trainee performance measures. With CIR used as an example, this study highlights the need for standardized definitions and calculations of KPIs in endoscopy.
引用
- Siau K, Hodson J, Ravindran S, et al. Variability in cecal intubation rate by calculation method: a call for standardization of key performance indicators in endoscopy. Gastrointest Endosc. 2019. PMID: 30659830. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2018.12.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。