结肠镜培训中的计算机化反馈可改善操作表现:一项随机试验
44名参与者随机分为反馈组与对照组,在模拟结肠镜中自主练习2小时,反馈组每次到达盲肠时获得进展评分。校正性别后,反馈组最终病例进展评分较对照组高14.4分(95%CI 1.2-27.6,P=.033),练习时间多25.8分钟(95%CI 11.6-39.9,P=.001),练习中到达盲肠次数多3.2次(95%CI 2-4.5,P<.001)。
要点
- 模拟结肠镜中计算机化进展反馈使新手最终病例评分提高14.4分(95%CI 1.2-27.6)。
- 反馈组练习时间较对照组多25.8分钟(95%CI 11.6-39.9)。
- 反馈组练习中到达盲肠次数较对照组多3.2次(95%CI 2-4.5)。
核心结论
- 模拟结肠镜中自动计算机化进展评分可激励新手改善操作表现、优化练习时间与训练模式。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,共招募44名参与者,随机分为反馈组(FG)与对照组(CG)。
- 参与者获准2小时自主练习,可在1例简单和1例困难病例上按自己认为合适的方式练习。
- 对照组练习时无反馈,反馈组每次到达盲肠时获得进展评分;训练结束后所有参与者在一例不同病例上接受测试。
- 主要结局为最终病例的进展评分,次要结局为练习时间与训练模式。
- 临床试验注册号:NCT03248453。
主要发现
- 因组间性别分布不均(P=.026)且男性表现评分(37.6,标准差25.9)显著高于女性(19.7,标准差18.7;P=.012),进行了校正性别的回归分析。
- 最终病例中反馈组表现优于对照组,反馈组评分较对照组高14.4分(95%CI 1.2-27.6;P=.033)。
- 反馈组练习时间较对照组多25.8分钟(95%CI 11.6-39.9;P=.001)。
- 反馈组在简单病例上练习更多,练习期间到达盲肠次数较对照组多3.2次(95%CI 2-4.5;P<.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 最终病例进展评分:反馈组较对照组高14.4分(95%CI 1.2-27.6;P=.033)。
- 练习时间:反馈组较对照组多25.8分钟(95%CI 11.6-39.9;P=.001)。
- 练习期间到达盲肠次数:反馈组较对照组多3.2次(95%CI 2-4.5;P<.001)。
- 男性表现评分37.6(标准差25.9)高于女性19.7(标准差18.7);P=.012。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Simulation-based training in colonoscopy is increasingly replacing the traditional apprenticeship method to avoid patient-related risk. Mentoring during simulation is necessary to provide feedback and to motivate, but expert supervisors are a scarce resource. We aimed to determine whether computerized feedback in simulated colonoscopy would improve performance, optimize time spent practicing, and optimize the pattern of training. METHODS: Forty-four participants were recruited and randomized to either a feedback group (FG) or a control group (CG). Participants were allowed 2 hours of self-practice during which they could practice as they saw fit on 2 different cases: 1 easy and 1 difficult. The CG practiced without feedback, but the participants in the FG were given a score of progression every time they reached the cecum. All participants were tested on a different case after end of training. The primary outcome was the progression score in the final case, and secondary outcomes were time spent practicing and the training pattern. RESULTS: Regression analysis adjusting for sex was done because of an uneven sex distribution between groups (P = .026) and significantly higher performance scores by men (37.6, standard deviation [SD] 25.9) compared with women (19.7, SD 18.7); P = .012. The FG outperformed the CG in the final case, FG scoring 14.4 points (95% confidence interval [CI], 1.2-27.6) more than the CG; P = .033, and they spent more time practicing, FG practicing 25.8 minutes (95% CI, 11.6-39.9) more than the CG; P = .001. The FG practiced more on the easy case and reached the cecum 3.2 times more (95% CI, 2-4.5) during practice (P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: Our findings of this study revealed that an automatic, computerized score of progression during simulated colonoscopy motivates the novices to improve performance, optimizes time spent practicing, and optimizes their pattern of training. (Clinical trial registration number: NCT03248453.).
引用
- Vilmann AS, Norsk D, Svendsen MBS, et al. Computerized feedback during colonoscopy training leads to improved performance: a randomized trial. Gastrointest Endosc. 2018. PMID: 30031803. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2018.07.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。