专科培训阶段对结肠镜检查质量与效率指标的影响
该回顾性研究分析了2012年6月至2014年12月某退伍军人医疗中心2024例门诊结肠镜检查,比较不同培训阶段专科培训医师与主治医师独立操作在腺瘤检出率、操作时间、腺瘤管理效率指数及中度镇静用药上的差异。结果显示腺瘤检出率在各阶段及与主治医师组间均无差异,操作时间随培训进展缩短但未达主治医师水平,培训医师参与与更高镇静剂用量相关。
要点
- 腺瘤检出率在不同培训阶段专科培训医师间无差异(P=.8),与主治医师独立操作相比亦无差异(P=.67)。
- 腺瘤管理效率指数随培训级别升高而改善:按培训级别升序的培训医师组分别为23.5分钟、18.3分钟、13.7分钟、13.4分钟,主治医师组为11.7分钟(P<.001)。
- 与主治医师独立操作相比,培训医师参与与更高芬太尼和咪达唑仑剂量及更频繁使用苯海拉明和胰高血糖素相关(P分别<.0001、P=.0002、P<.0001、P=.01)。
核心结论
- 腺瘤检出率在不同专科培训阶段相似,且与主治医师组相当;检测和切除息肉的效率在整个培训过程中改善但未达到主治医师水平;培训医师参与导致中度镇静使用增加,可能与操作时间较长及内镜技术经验积累有关。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入2012年6月至2014年12月在某退伍军人医疗中心接受门诊结肠镜检查的2024例患者(平均年龄60.9±10岁;94%为男性)。
- 结肠镜检查分为5组:第一年专科培训医师培训年前6个月组、第一年专科培训医师培训年后6个月组、第二年专科培训医师组、第三年专科培训医师组、仅主治医师操作组。
- 收集镇静剂剂量、辅助药物使用频率、操作时间以及息肉位置、大小和组织学数据;腺瘤管理效率指数定义为退镜期间每个切除腺瘤所需的平均时间。
主要发现
- 2024例结肠镜检查中,1675例有专科培训医师参与,349例由主治医师独立操作。
- 腺瘤检出率在不同培训阶段专科培训医师间无差异(P=.8),专科培训医师与仅主治医师操作间亦无差异(P=.67)。
- 腺瘤管理效率指数(按培训级别升序的培训医师组):23.5分钟 vs 18.3分钟 vs 13.7分钟 vs 13.4分钟 vs 主治医师组11.7分钟(P<.001)。
- 不同培训医师组间咪达唑仑和芬太尼平均剂量无差异(P=.16和P=.1)。
- 与仅主治医师操作相比,专科培训医师参与与更高芬太尼和咪达唑仑剂量及更频繁使用苯海拉明和胰高血糖素相关(P<.0001、P=.0002、P<.0001和P=.01)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Previous studies have described variable effects of fellow involvement on the adenoma detection rate (ADR), but few have stratified this effect by level of training. We aimed to evaluate the "fellow effect" on multiple procedural metrics including a newly defined adenoma management efficiency index, which may have a role in documenting colonoscopy proficiency for trainees. We also describe the impact of level of training on moderate sedation use. METHODS: We performed a retrospective review of 2024 patients (mean age, 60.9 ± 10 years; 94% men) who underwent outpatient colonoscopy between June 2012 and December 2014 at our Veterans Affairs Medical Center. Colonoscopies were divided into 5 groups. The first 2 groups were first-year fellows in the first 6 months and last 6 months of the training year. Second- and third-year fellows and attending-only procedures accounted for 1 group each. We collected data on doses of sedatives used, frequency of adjunctive agent use, procedural times, and location, size, and histology of polyps. We defined the adenoma management efficiency index as average time required per adenoma resected during withdrawal. RESULTS: Of the colonoscopies performed, 1675 involved a fellow and 349 were performed by the attending alone. There was no difference in ADR between fellows according to level of training (P = .8) or between fellows compared with attending-only procedures (P = .67). Procedural times decreased consistently during training and declined further for attending-only procedures. This translated into improvement in the adenoma management efficiency index (fellow groups by ascending level of training: 23.5 minutes vs 18.3 minutes vs 13.7 minutes vs 13.4 minutes vs attending group 11.7 minutes; P < .001). There was no difference in the average doses of midazolam and fentanyl used among fellow groups (P = .16 and P = .1, respectively). Compared with attending-only procedures, fellow involvement was associated with higher doses of fentanyl and midazolam and more frequent use of diphenhydramine and glucagon (P < .0001, P = .0002, P < .0001, and P = .01, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: ADR was similar at different stages of fellowship training and comparable with the attending group. Efficiency of detecting and resecting polyps improved throughout training without reaching the attending level. Fellow involvement led to a greater use of moderate sedation, which may relate to a longer procedure duration and an evolving experience in endoscopic technique.
引用
- Bitar H, Zia H, Bashir M, et al. Impact of fellowship training level on colonoscopy quality and efficiency metrics. Gastrointest Endosc. 2018. PMID: 29679692. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2018.04.2338
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。