溃疡性结肠炎中Paddington国际虚拟染色内镜评分在计算机化模块培训后展现出非常好的评分者间一致性:一项跨学术与社区实践的多中心研究(含视频)
这项多中心研究让5个中心的15名参与者学习计算机化培训模块后,评估其对溃疡性结肠炎内镜视频的评分一致性。培训后PICaSSO的黏膜和血管成分ICC分别提升至0.848和0.746,且与组织学相关性很强。PICaSSO可能用于细化溃疡性结肠炎患者的分层治疗策略。
要点
- 培训后PICaSSO黏膜成分ICC为0.848,血管成分为0.746。
- PICaSSO黏膜和血管成分与组织学相关系数分别为ρ=0.925和ρ=0.873。
- PICaSSO区分静止期与轻度组织学分层的AUROC黏膜为0.781、血管为0.715。
核心结论
- PICaSSO在不同经验水平中均显示出良好的观察者间一致性,且与组织学相关性极好。
- 鉴于其能区分细微内镜特征,PICaSSO可能用于细化溃疡性结肠炎患者的 stratified 治疗策略。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心研究,5个中心的15名参与者审阅了概述高清和EVC(iScan)结肠镜模式的计算机化培训模块。
- 使用结肠镜视频库(培训前30例和培训后30例)测试观察者间一致性;培训后6个月进行第二轮知识可持续性重测(42例;15名参与者中的9名)。
主要发现
- 培训前Mayo内镜子评分ICC为0.775,UCEIS糜烂/溃疡ICC为0.770,UCEIS总体ICC为0.786,PICaSSO黏膜成分ICC为0.754,血管成分ICC为0.622。
- UCEIS血管成分一致性仅为中等(ICC为0.429),培训后未提高(ICC为0.417);而PICaSSO培训后改善(黏膜ICC为0.848;血管为0.746)。
- 使用New York Mt. Sinai系统进行组织学相关性分析,PICaSSO两个成分均强相关(黏膜Spearman ρ=0.925;血管ρ=0.873;两者P<.001)。
- 区分静止期与轻度组织学分层的准确性以PICaSSO最强(黏膜AUROC为0.781;血管为0.715),优于Mayo(AUROC为0.708)和UCEIS(总体AUROC为0.705;血管为0.562;出血为0.645;糜烂/溃疡为0.696)。
- 第二轮参与者中PICaSSO的评分者间信度得以维持(第一轮和第二轮黏膜ICC分别为0.873和0.869;血管分别为0.715和0.783),组织学相关性亦维持(ρ黏膜为0.934;血管为0.938;两者P<.001)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为PICaSSO可能用于细化溃疡性结肠炎患者的 stratified 治疗策略。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Electronic virtual chromoendoscopy (EVC) can demonstrate ongoing disease activity in ulcerative colitis (UC), even when Mayo subscores suggest healing. However, applicability of EVC technology outside the expert setting has yet to be determined. METHODS: Fifteen participants across 5 centers reviewed a computerized training module outlining high-definition and EVC (iScan) colonoscopy modes. Interobserver agreement was then tested (Mayo score, Ulcerative Colitis Endoscopic Index of Severity [UCEIS], and the Paddington International Virtual Chromoendoscopy Score [PICaSSO] for UC), using a colonoscopy video library (30 cases reviewed pretraining and 30 post-training). Knowledge sustainability was retested in a second round (42 cases; 9/15 participants), 6 months after training provision. RESULTS: Pretraining intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) were good for the Mayo endoscopic subscore (ICC, .775), UCEIS scoring erosions/ulcers (ICC, .770), and UCEIS overall (ICC, .786) and for mucosal (ICC, .754) and vascular components of PICaSSO (ICC, .622). For the vascular components of UCEIS, agreement was only moderate (ICC, .429) and did not enhance post-training (ICC, .417); conversely, use of PICaSSO improved post-training (mucosal ICC, .848; vascular, .746). Histologic correlation using the New York Mt. Sinai System was strong for both PICaSSO components (Spearman's ρ for mucosal: .925; vascular, .873; P < .001 for both). Moreover, accuracy in specifically discriminating quiescent from mild histologic strata was strongest for PICaSSO (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve [AUROC] for mucosal, .781; vascular, .715) compared with Mayo (AUROC, .708) and UCEIS (AUROC for UCEIS overall, .705; vascular, .562; bleeding, .645; erosions/ulcers, .696). Inter-rater reliability for PICaSSO was sustained by round 2 participants (round 1 and 2 ICC for mucosal, .873 and .869, respectively; vascular, .715 and .783, respectively), together with histologic correlation (ρ mucosal, .934; vascular, .938; P < .001 for both). CONCLUSIONS: PICaSSO demonstrates good interobserver agreement across all levels of experience, providing excellent correlation with histology. Given the ability to discriminate subtle endoscopic features, PICaSSO may be applied to refine stratified treatment paradigms for UC patients.
引用
- Trivedi PJ, Kiesslich R, Hodson J, et al. The Paddington International Virtual Chromoendoscopy Score in ulcerative colitis exhibits very good inter-rater agreement after computerized module training: a multicenter study across academic and community practice (with video). Gastrointest Endosc. 2018. PMID: 29548940. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2018.02.044
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。