文献速递消化内镜消化道肿瘤与早癌

培训与反馈对内镜下光学诊断微小息肉时预测直肠乙状结肠肿瘤性病变准确性及选择监测间隔的影响

Effects of Training and Feedback on Accuracy of Predicting Rectosigmoid Neoplastic Lesions and Selection of Surveillance Intervals by Endoscopists Performing Optical Diagnosis of Diminutive Polyps.
PubMed 文献 · Gastroenterology · 2018-02-06

在荷兰13个中心开展前瞻性研究,39名结肠镜医师经验证模块培训后,27名完成培训并对4504枚微小息肉行窄带成像光学诊断,预测直肠乙状结肠肿瘤性病变的汇总阴性预测值为90.8%(95%CI 88.6-92.6),监测间隔与组织学一致率为95.4%(95%CI 94.0-96.6),反馈组与无反馈组无差异;16名(59%)医师个体阴性预测值大于90%且监测间隔一致率大于90%。

要点

  • 27名完成培训的医师对4504枚微小息肉光学诊断,汇总阴性预测值90.8%(95%CI 88.6-92.6)。
  • 监测间隔与组织学一致率95.4%(95%CI 94.0-96.6)。
  • 反馈组与无反馈组在终点上无差异;个体表现存在差异,建议监测。

核心结论

  • 经过验证培训模块后,选定的一组内镜医师在1年内预测直肠乙状结肠肿瘤性病变的汇总阴性预测值大于90%,并为超过90%的患者准确选择监测间隔。
  • 定期提供关于肿瘤性病变预测准确性和监测间隔选择准确性的中期反馈未导致这些终点出现差异。
  • 由于个体表现存在差异,建议进行监测。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性研究,在荷兰13个中心纳入39名获准进行结肠镜检查的内镜医师,对象为肠道癌症筛查项目中粪便免疫化学检测阳性的参与者。
  • 内镜医师使用经验证的模块(Workgroup serrAted polypS and Polyposis)接受光学诊断培训,达到预设性能阈值后进入为期1年的继续阶段。
  • 在继续阶段进行窄带成像分析并预测组织学发现及置信水平,内镜医师被随机分配至接受或不接受关于预测准确性的反馈组。

主要发现

  • 初始培训的39名内镜医师中27名(69%)完成培训。
  • 继续阶段27名内镜医师共进行3144次结肠镜检查,切除4504枚微小息肉。
  • 内镜医师识别肿瘤性病变的汇总阴性预测值为90.8%(95%CI 88.6-92.6)。
  • 提出的监测间隔与组织学分析确定的一致率为95.4%(95%CI 94.0-96.6)。
  • 反馈组与无反馈组之间 findings 无差异;16名内镜医师(59%)识别直肠乙状结肠肿瘤性病变的阴性预测值大于90%且监测间隔一致率大于90%。

关键数值与推荐

  • 指南要求光学诊断识别直肠乙状结肠肿瘤性病变的阴性预测值需大于90%(以组织学为参考)。
  • 指南要求监测间隔与组织学确定的一致率需大于90%。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议进行监测,因为个体表现存在差异。
  • 定期中期反馈未显示对肿瘤性病变预测准确性或监测间隔选择准确性带来差异。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND & AIMS: Real-time differentiation of diminutive polyps (1-5 mm) during endoscopy could replace histopathology analysis. According to guidelines, implementation of optical diagnosis into routine practice would require it to identify rectosigmoid neoplastic lesions with a negative predictive value (NPV) of more than 90%, using histologic findings as a reference, and agreement with histology-based surveillance intervals for more than 90% of cases. METHODS: We performed a prospective study with 39 endoscopists accredited to perform colonoscopies on participants with positive results from fecal immunochemical tests in the Bowel Cancer Screening Program at 13 centers in the Netherlands. Endoscopists were trained in optical diagnosis using a validated module (Workgroup serrAted polypS and Polyposis). After meeting predefined performance thresholds in the training program, the endoscopists started a 1-year program (continuation phase) in which they performed narrow band imaging analyses during colonoscopies of participants in the screening program and predicted histological findings with confidence levels. The endoscopists were randomly assigned to groups that received feedback or no feedback on the accuracy of their predictions. Primary outcome measures were endoscopists' abilities to identify rectosigmoid neoplastic lesions (using histology as a reference) with NPVs of 90% or more, and selecting surveillance intervals that agreed with those determined by histology for at least 90% of cases. RESULTS: Of 39 endoscopists initially trained, 27 (69%) completed the training program. During the continuation phase, these 27 endoscopists performed 3144 colonoscopies in which 4504 diminutive polyps were removed. The endoscopists identified neoplastic lesions with a pooled NPV of 90.8% (95% confidence interval 88.6-92.6); their proposed surveillance intervals agreed with those determined by histologic analysis for 95.4% of cases (95% confidence interval 94.0-96.6). Findings did not differ between the group that did vs did not receive feedback. Sixteen endoscopists (59%) identified rectosigmoid neoplastic lesions with NPVs greater than 90% and selected surveillance intervals in agreement with those determined from histology for more than 90% of patients. CONCLUSIONS: In a prospective study following a validated training module, we found that a selected group of endoscopists identified rectosigmoid neoplastic lesions with pooled NPVs greater than 90% and accurately selected surveillance intervals for more than 90% of patients over the course of 1 year. Providing regular interim feedback on the accuracy of neoplastic lesion prediction and surveillance interval selection did not lead to differences in those endpoints. Monitoring is suggested, as individual performance varied. ClinicalTrials.gov no: NCT02516748; Netherland Trial Register: NTR4635.

来源:Gastroenterology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Vleugels JLA, Dijkgraaf MGW, Hazewinkel Y, et al. Effects of Training and Feedback on Accuracy of Predicting Rectosigmoid Neoplastic Lesions and Selection of Surveillance Intervals by Endoscopists Performing Optical Diagnosis of Diminutive Polyps. Gastroenterology. 2018. PMID: 29425923. doi:10.1053/j.gastro.2018.01.063

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。