透明帽辅助结肠镜对结肠镜学习曲线和质量的影响:一项随机对照试验
该随机对照试验将203例结肠镜检查随机分为透明帽辅助结肠镜(CAC)组101例和标准结肠镜(SC)组102例,由3名无经验消化科 fellows 操作。CAC组独立盲肠插管率显著高于SC组(79.2% vs 66.7%,P=.04),总体盲肠插管时间显著更短(13.7分钟 vs 16.5分钟,P=.02),ACE工具运动和认知评分更高。息肉检出率、息肉漏检率和腺瘤检出率组间无显著差异。
要点
- CAC组独立盲肠插管率79.2% vs SC组66.7%(P=.04)。
- CAC组总体盲肠插管时间13.7分钟 vs SC组16.5分钟(P=.02)。
- 独立插管成功时盲肠插管时间11.6分钟 vs 12.7分钟(P=.29),无显著差异。
核心结论
- 与SC相比,CAC使无既往结肠镜经验的受训者独立盲肠插管率、总体ACE工具评分显著改善,学习曲线趋向 competency 阈值更早。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,纳入3名无既往经验的消化科 fellows 操作的所有结肠镜检查,排除患者年龄<18或>90岁、妊娠、既往结肠切除、憩室炎、结肠梗阻、严重便血、转诊行EMR或无镇静操作。
- 患者按1:1随机分为CAC组或SC组,共分析203例结肠镜检查,CAC组101例,SC组102例。
主要发现
- CAC组独立盲肠插管率79.2% vs SC组66.7%(P=.04)。
- CAC组总体盲肠插管时间13.7分钟 vs SC组16.5分钟(P=.02)。
- 独立插管成功时盲肠插管时间CAC组11.6分钟 vs SC组12.7分钟(P=.29),无显著差异。
- CAC组总体ACE工具运动和认知评分更高。
- ICIR学习曲线在使用透明帽时更早接近 competency 阈值,但仅1名 fellow 达到 competency;息肉检出率、息肉漏检率和腺瘤检出率组间无显著差异。
局限性
- 学习曲线中仅1名 fellow 达到 competency。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Colonoscopy competency assessment in trainees traditionally has been informal. Comprehensive metrics such as the Assessment of Competency in Endoscopy (ACE) tool suggest that competency thresholds are higher than assumed. Cap-assisted colonoscopy (CAC) may improve competency, but data regarding novice trainees are lacking. We compared CAC versus standard colonoscopy (SC) performed by novice trainees in a randomized controlled trial. METHODS: All colonoscopies performed by 3 gastroenterology fellows without prior experience were eligible for the study. Exclusion criteria included patient age <18 or >90 years, pregnancy, prior colon resection, diverticulitis, colon obstruction, severe hematochezia, referral for EMR, or a procedure done without patient sedation. Patients were randomized to either CAC or SC in a 1:1 fashion. The primary outcome was the independent cecal intubation rate (ICIR). Secondary outcomes were cecal intubation time, polyp detection rate, polyp miss rate, adenoma detection rate, ACE tool scores, and cumulative summation learning curves. RESULTS: A total of 203 colonoscopies were analyzed, 101 in CAC and 102 in SC. CAC resulted in a significantly higher cecal intubation rate, at 79.2% in CAC compared with 66.7% in SC (P = .04). Overall cecal intubation time was significantly shorter at 13.7 minutes for CAC versus 16.5 minutes for SC (P =.02). Cecal intubation time in the case of successful independent fellow intubation was not significantly different between CAC and SC (11.6 minutes vs 12.7 minutes; P = .29). Overall ACE tool motor and cognitive scores were higher with CAC. Learning curves for ICIR approached the competency threshold earlier with cap use but reached competency for only 1 fellow. The polyp detection rate, polyp miss rate, and adenoma detection rate were not significantly different between groups. CONCLUSIONS: CAC resulted in significant improvement in ICIR, overall ACE tool scores, and trend toward competency on learning curves when compared with SC in colonoscopy trainees without prior colonoscopy experience. (Clinical trial registration number: NCT02472730.).
引用
- Tang Z, Zhang DS, Thrift AP, et al. Impact of cap-assisted colonoscopy on the learning curve and quality in colonoscopy: a randomized controlled trial. Gastrointest Endosc. 2017. PMID: 28648577. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2017.06.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。