新型远端附件对学术筛查中心结肠镜检查性能的影响
该试点服务评估研究在2013年4月至2014年9月纳入粪便隐血阳性的国家肠癌计划患者,比较使用远端附件Endocuff Vision前、中、后三个连续阶段的结肠镜性能。结果显示使用期间平均腺瘤检出率提高16%(P < .03),每次操作平均腺瘤数增加83%(P = .007),盲肠插管时间和退镜时间缩短,镇静需求和患者不适无增加。
要点
- 使用Endocuff Vision期间平均腺瘤检出率较使用前提高16%(P < .03)。
- 使用期间每次操作平均腺瘤数较使用前增加83%(P = .007)。
- 使用期间平均盲肠插管时间7分钟,较使用前8分钟降低12.5%(P = .002)。
核心结论
- 在这项试点服务评估研究中,使用Endocuff Vision似乎与结肠镜操作者整体性能改善相关。
- 使用期间腺瘤检出率和每次操作平均腺瘤数增加,插管和退镜时间缩短,镇静需求或患者不适无增加。
研究设计与样本
- 试点服务评估研究,2013年4月至2014年9月纳入粪便隐血阳性的国家肠癌计划患者。
- 研究分为3个连续阶段:使用前(未用装置)、使用期间(使用装置)、使用后(未用装置)。
- 使用期间4名筛查认证结肠镜医师酌情决定是否使用Endocuff Vision,为非随机设计。
- 共完成410例完整结肠镜检查(使用前137例,使用期间136例,使用后137例)。
主要发现
- 从使用前到使用期间,平均腺瘤检出率提高16%(P < .03)。
- 从使用前到使用期间,每次操作平均腺瘤数增加83%(P = .007)。
- 使用期间平均盲肠插管时间7分钟,较使用前8分钟降低12.5%(P = .002),较使用后9分钟降低28.6%(P = .002)。
- 使用期间平均阴性结肠镜退镜时间8分30秒,低于使用前12分钟和使用后9分45秒(P ≤ .001)。
- 多因素回归分析显示使用Endocuff Vision与镇静需求或患者不适评分无关。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Distal attachments placed on the colonoscope tip may positively affect performance by assisting insertion and polyp detection. The original Endocuff (ARC Medical Design, Leeds, United Kingdom) appears to improve adenoma detection rate (ADR), but no data assess the performance of the second-generation Endocuff Vision. METHODS: A pilot service evaluation study (April 2013 to September 2014) was conducted on patients with positive fecal occult blood tests within the National Bowel Cancer Programme during 3 consecutive periods: precuff/no device used, during-cuff/device used, and postcuff/no device used. During the middle period the use of the Endocuff Vision by the 4 screening-accredited colonoscopists was discretional (nonrandomized design). Data were analyzed using pairwise comparisons during the 3 designated periods to examine key performance indicators: adenoma detection, procedural time, sedation requirements, and patient comfort. RESULTS: Four hundred ten complete colonoscopies were performed (137 precuff, 136 cuff, and 137 postcuff period). Overall, there was a notable increase in the mean ADR of 16% (P < .03) and in the mean number adenoma per procedure (MAP) of 83% (P = .007) from precuff to cuff period. The mean cecal intubation time was statistically lower during the cuff period (7 minutes) in relation to the precuff period (8 minutes; reduction of 12.5%, P = .002) and the postcuff period (9 minutes; increase of 28.6%, P = .002). The mean negative colonoscopy withdrawal time was also significantly lower during the cuff period (8 minutes, 30 seconds) when compared with the precuff (12 minutes) or postcuff period (9 minutes, 45 seconds; P ≤ .001). Multivariate regression analysis showed that the use of the Endocuff Vision was not associated with sedation requirements or patient discomfort scores. No adverse events were reported from the use of the Endocuff Vision, although it was electively removed in 6 patients where severe sigmoid colon diverticulosis was encountered and 2 patients because of discomfort during anal insertion. CONCLUSIONS: In this pilot service evaluation study, the use of the Endocuff Vision appears to be associated with an improvement in overall colonoscopy operator performance. We found increased ADR and MAP as well as decreased time for colonoscope insertion and withdrawal time with no increase in sedation requirements or patient discomfort.
引用
- Tsiamoulos ZP, Misra R, Rameshshanker R, et al. Impact of a new distal attachment on colonoscopy performance in an academic screening center. Gastrointest Endosc. 2017. PMID: 28412271. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2017.04.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。