无透视EUS辅助ERCP与ERCP治疗胆总管结石的前瞻性随机试验
前瞻性随机研究纳入114例胆总管结石患者,等分为无透视EUS辅助ERCP(EGEWF)组与ERCP组。EGEWF组插管成功率96.35%与ERCP组100%相似(P=.243),但结石清除率85.5%低于ERCP组100%(P=.002)。两组不良事件率与总操作时间无差异。
要点
- EGEWF组结石清除率85.5%低于ERCP组100%(P=.002),插管成功率两组相似(P=.243)。
- 以取石数目与EUS检出数目一致判定的结石清除正确率为94%。
- 结石数目多于2枚可能增加EGEWF组结石清除失败率。
核心结论
- EGEWF在结石清除方面劣于ERCP,但无辐射暴露对特定患者有益。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机研究,纳入符合入选标准的胆总管结石患者114例,等随机分为EGEWF组与ERCP组。
- 排除3例后,EGEWF组55例,ERCP组56例。
- EGEWF组行无透视插管的ERCP,乳头括约肌切开后球囊清扫取石直至取石数目与EUS检出数目一致,并经胆管造影确认结石清除。
- ERCP组按标准方式行ERCP。
- 分析插管率、结石清除率、总操作时间、透视时间及不良事件率。
主要发现
- EGEWF组插管成功率96.35% vs ERCP组100%,两组相似(P=.243)。
- EGEWF组结石清除率85.5% vs ERCP组100%,EGEWF组低于ERCP组(P=.002)。
- 以取石数目与EUS检出数目一致判定的结石清除正确率为94%。
- 结石数目多于2枚可能增加EGEWF组结石清除失败率。
- 两组不良事件率与总操作时间无差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: ERCP with stone removal is the standard treatment for common bile duct stones (CBDSs). Radiation exposure is a risk to the endoscopist and patient. EUS-guided ERCP without fluoroscopy (EGEWF) in patients with CBDSs is feasible, but the efficacy and safety compared with ERCP is unknown. We aimed to compare the efficacy and safety of EGEWF with ERCP in CBDS removal. METHODS: A prospective randomized study was done in 114 patients with CBDSs who met inclusion criteria. These patients were equally randomized into the EGEWF and ERCP groups. In the EGEWF group, ERCP was performed by cannulation without fluoroscopy. Balloon sweeping was done after sphincterotomy to clear the stones until the number of stones matched the number detected by EUS and the stone clearance (SC) was confirmed by cholangiography. In the ERCP group, ERCP was performed in the standard manner. The cannulation rates, SC rates, total procedure and fluoroscopic times, and adverse event rates were analyzed. RESULTS: After exclusion of 3 patients, 55 were in the EGEWF group and 56 in the ERCP group. Demographic data, laboratory data, stone characteristics, CBD diameter, and number of patients with periampullary diverticulum were not different between the 2 groups. The cannulation success rates in the EGEWF (96.35%) and ERCP (100%) groups were similar (P = .243). The SC rate in the EGEWF group (85.5%) was inferior to the ERCP group (100%) (P = .002). The SC rate based on the number of stones retrieved that matched the number by EUS was correct in 94%. More than 2 stones may increase the failure rate of SC in EGEWF. The adverse event rates and the total procedure times were not different between the groups. CONCLUSIONS: EGEWF was inferior to ERCP in terms of SC; however, no radiation exposure is beneficial for selected patients. (Clinical trial registration number: NCT02870686.).
引用
- Netinatsunton N, Sottisuporn J, Attasaranya S, et al. Prospective randomized trial of EUS-assisted ERCP without fluoroscopy versus ERCP in common bile duct stones. Gastrointest Endosc. 2017. PMID: 28392365. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2017.03.1539
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。