文献速递肝病

评估消化内科专科培训医师向肝病患者提供信息的能力

Assessment of Abilities of Gastroenterology Fellows to Provide Information to Patients With Liver Disease.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol · 2017-01-20

研究通过包含4个肝病病例的客观结构化临床考试(OSCE)评估12名来自4个胃肠培训项目的专科培训医师向标准化患者(SP)传达信息的能力。结果显示,医师在新诊断肝硬化和丙型肝炎病例中表现较好,但在乙型肝炎和终末期肝病病例中表现较差;医师自我评价与SP观察在多个方面不一致。研究者认为OSCE有助于培训医师平衡信息传递与共情。

要点

  • 多数医师能在新诊断肝硬化和丙型肝炎病例中总结发现并讨论计划,但在乙型肝炎和终末期病例中成功率较低。
  • 医师自我评价与SP观察在多个方面不一致,例如终末期病例中医师自认表现良好但SP认为仅少数能成功总结和讨论计划。
  • 医师最大挑战是试图在单次门诊 visit 中涵盖大量信息。

核心结论

  • 照顾肝病患者可能复杂且耗时;患者与医师的观察在多个方面不一致,例如医师认为自己在终末期病例中表现出色,但SP认为仅小部分医师能成功总结和讨论计划。
  • OSCE有助于培训医师在信息传递与共情之间取得恰当平衡,从而改善患者教育、依从性、融洽关系和满意度。

研究设计与样本

  • 开发了4个突出肝病不同方面的病例并创建4站OSCE:乙型肝炎、急性丙型肝炎、新诊断肝硬化和终末期肝硬化非移植候选者。
  • 12名来自4个胃肠培训项目的专科培训医师参与;SP使用检查表评分,教职人员和SP观察并提供反馈,医师接受调查。

主要发现

  • 多数医师能成功总结发现并与患者讨论计划:新诊断肝硬化病例为76.92%,丙型肝炎病例为100%。
  • 医师在乙型肝炎病例(30.77%)和终末期病例(41.67%)中成功率较低。
  • 总体而言,小部分医师反思自己做得不错(22%-33%),终末期病例除外(67%)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND & AIMS: Patient education is critical in ensuring patient compliance and good health outcomes. Fellows must be able to effectively communicate with their patients, delivering enough information for the patient to understand their medical problem and maximize patient compliance. We created an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) with 4 liver disease cases to assess fellows' knowledge and ability to inform standardized patients (SPs) about their clinical condition. METHODS: We developed 4 cases highlighting different aspects of liver disease and created a 4-station OSCE: hepatitis B, acute hepatitis C, new diagnosis of cirrhosis, and an end-stage cirrhotic nontransplant candidate. The SP with hepatitis B was minimizing the fact that she could not read English. The acute hepatitis C SP was a nursing student who is afraid that having hepatitis C might jeopardize her career. The SP with the new diagnosis of alcoholic cirrhosis needed to stop drinking, and the end-stage liver disease patient had to grapple with his advanced directives. Twelve fellows from 4 GI training programs participated. Our focus was to assess the fellows' knowledge about liver diseases and the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education competencies of health literacy, shared decision making, advanced directives, and goals of care. The goal for the fellows was to communicate effectively with the SPs, and acknowledge that each patient had an emotionally charged issue to overcome. The SPs used a checklist to rate fellows' performance. Faculty and the SPs observed the cases and provided feedback. The fellows were surveyed on their performance regarding the case. RESULTS: The majority of fellows were able to successfully summarize findings and discuss a plan with the patient in the new diagnosis of cirrhosis (76.92%) and hepatitis C case (100%), but were less successful in the hepatitis B case (30.77%) and the end-of-life case (41.67%). Overall, a small percentage of fellows reflected that they did a good job (22%-33%), except at the end-of-life case (67%). The fellows' greatest challenge was trying to cover a lot of information in a single outpatient visit. CONCLUSIONS: Caring for patients with liver diseases can be complex and time consuming. The patients and fellows' observations were discordant in several areas: for example, the fellows believed they excelled in the end-of-life case, but the SP thought only a small percentage of fellows were able to successfully summarize and discuss the plan. This discrepancy and others highlight important areas of focus in training programs. OSCEs are important to help the fellows facilitate striking the right balance of information delivery and empathy, and this will lead to better patient education, compliance, rapport, and satisfaction.

来源:Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chaudhary N, Lucero C, Villanueva G, et al. Assessment of Abilities of Gastroenterology Fellows to Provide Information to Patients With Liver Disease. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2017. PMID: 28111335. doi:10.1016/j.cgh.2016.12.037

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。