鉴别肠结核与克罗恩病的Meta分析贝叶斯模型
该研究通过系统检索MEDLINE、PUBMED和EMBASE(截至2015年9月)的文献,对55项预测指标进行Meta分析,并将异质性I²<50%且组间差异显著的指标纳入贝叶斯预测模型。模型基于38项研究(2117例克罗恩病、1589例肠结核)构建,在49例患者中验证,诊断肠结核的敏感度90.9%、特异度92.6%、准确率91.8%。
要点
- 贝叶斯模型整合Meta分析结果与局部验前概率,可估计肠结核与克罗恩病的概率。
- 模型在49例患者中验证,诊断肠结核的敏感度90.9%、特异度92.6%、准确率91.8%。
- 模型可通过公开网络应用用于患者。
核心结论
- 基于Meta分析结果的贝叶斯模型可估计肠结核与克罗恩病的概率,并根据局部患病率校准。
- 该模型可通过公开网络应用用于患者。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索MEDLINE、PUBMED和EMBASE从建库至2015年9月的文献,纳入鉴别肠结核与克罗恩病的研究。
- 共纳入38项研究,包括2117例克罗恩病患者和1589例肠结核患者。
- 进行55项独立的Meta分析以估计每个预测指标的比值比。
- 将组间差异显著且异质性低至中度(I²<50%)的估计值纳入贝叶斯预测模型,模型整合局部验前概率。
- 模型在49例患者(27例克罗恩病,22例肠结核)中通过性别、临床表现、内镜和病理表现进行验证。
主要发现
- 模型中发现显著支持克罗恩病的指标包括:男性、便血、肛周病变、肠梗阻、肠外表现;内镜见纵行溃疡、鹅卵石样外观、肠腔狭窄、黏膜桥、直肠受累;病理见灶性增强性结肠炎;CTE见不对称肠壁增厚、肠壁分层、梳齿征、纤维脂肪增生。
- 模型中发现显著支持肠结核的指标包括:发热、盗汗、肺部受累、腹水;内镜见横行溃疡、回盲瓣开放、盲肠受累;病理见融合性或黏膜下肉芽肿、淋巴细胞套、组织细胞排列的溃疡;CTE见短段受累;干扰素-γ释放试验阳性。
- 模型在49例患者中验证,诊断肠结核的敏感度为90.9%、特异度为92.6%、准确率为91.8%。
关键数值与推荐
- Meta分析纳入的指标需满足组间差异显著且异质性低至中度(I²<50%)方被纳入贝叶斯预测模型。
- 模型验证中诊断肠结核的敏感度90.9%、特异度92.6%、准确率91.8%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为该模型可通过公开网络应用用于患者,以估计肠结核与克罗恩病的概率。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Distinguishing intestinal tuberculosis (ITB) from Crohn's disease (CD) is difficult, although studies have reported clinical, endoscopic, imaging, and laboratory findings that help to differentiate these two diseases. We aimed to produce estimates of the predictive power of these findings and construct a comprehensive model to predict the probability of ITB vs. CD. METHODS: A systematic literature search for studies differentiating ITB from CD was conducted in MEDLINE, PUBMED, and EMBASE from inception until September 2015. Fifty-five distinct meta-analyses were performed to estimate the odds ratio of each predictive finding. Estimates with a significant difference between CD and ITB and low to moderate heterogeneity (I2<50%) were incorporated into a Bayesian prediction model incorporating the local pretest probability. RESULTS: Thirty-eight studies comprising 2,117 CD and 1,589 ITB patients were included in the analyses. Findings in the model that significantly favored CD included male gender, hematochezia, perianal disease, intestinal obstruction, and extraintestinal manifestations; endoscopic findings of longitudinal ulcers, cobblestone appearance, luminal stricture, mucosal bridge, and rectal involvement; pathological findings of focally enhanced colitis; and computed tomographic enterography (CTE) findings of asymmetrical wall thickening, intestinal wall stratification, comb sign, and fibrofatty proliferation. Findings that significantly favored ITB included fever, night sweats, lung involvement, and ascites; endoscopic findings of transverse ulcers, patulous ileocecal valve, and cecal involvement; pathological findings of confluent or submucosal granulomas, lymphocyte cuffing, and ulcers lined by histiocytes; a CTE finding of short segmental involvement; and a positive interferon-γ release assay. The model was validated by gender, clinical manifestations, endoscopic, and pathological findings in 49 patients (27 CD, 22 ITB). The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy for diagnosis of ITB were 90.9%, 92.6%, and 91.8%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: A Bayesian model based on the meta-analytic results is presented to estimate the probability of ITB and CD calibrated to local prevalence. This model can be applied to patients using a publicly available web application.
引用
- Limsrivilai J, Shreiner AB, Pongpaibul A, et al. Meta-Analytic Bayesian Model For Differentiating Intestinal Tuberculosis from Crohn's Disease. Am J Gastroenterol. 2017. PMID: 28045023. doi:10.1038/ajg.2016.529
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。