已发表指南的系统综述:肛周及直肠阴道瘘性克罗恩病的麻醉下检查、挂线置入与拆除时机推荐
结果显示,肛周脓肿普遍推荐EUA并常置入挂线,无症状单纯瘘则普遍不推荐;挂线拆除时机推荐差异大。指南间异质性显著,亟需国际共识标准化外科管理。
要点
- 肛周脓肿普遍推荐麻醉下检查并常置入挂线。
- 无症状单纯瘘不广泛推荐麻醉下检查与挂线。
- 挂线拆除时机推荐差异大,缺乏统一标准。
核心结论
- 肛周瘘性克罗恩病外科管理相关指南在麻醉下检查、挂线置入与拆除推荐上存在显著异质性和局限性,需国际多学科共识标准化诊疗。
主要发现
- 肛周脓肿普遍推荐麻醉下检查(常同时置入挂线),有症状的复杂性肛周瘘性克罗恩病也频繁推荐。
- 无症状复杂性瘘或有症状单纯瘘的推荐不一致,常取决于是否存在直肠炎或计划生物制剂治疗。
- 无症状单纯瘘不广泛推荐麻醉下检查与挂线。
- 挂线拆除推荐差异大,从抗TNF治疗启动后预定义间隔到基于临床或影像学反应的个体化标准不等。
- 多数指南未考虑症状类型/严重度、既往手术、手术闭合适宜性及影像学发现的无症状脓肿。
临床怎么用
- 临床可参照指南对肛周脓肿行麻醉下检查并考虑挂线置入,对有症状复杂性肛周瘘性克罗恩病频繁推荐麻醉下检查。
- 对无症状单纯瘘不常规推荐麻醉下检查与挂线;挂线拆除时机需结合抗TNF治疗启动后的预定义间隔或临床/影像学反应个体化决策。
- 决策时应综合考虑症状类型与严重度、既往手术、手术闭合适宜性及影像学发现的无症状脓肿,弥补现有指南未覆盖的维度。
局限性
- 指南间存在显著异质性,多数未考虑症状类型/严重度、既往手术、手术闭合适宜性及影像学发现的无症状脓肿。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Perianal fistulising Crohn's disease (pfCD) is a heterogeneous phenotype of Crohn's disease with marked variability in anatomical complexity, symptomatology, and disease trajectory. This often creates uncertainty in the optimal approach to management, particularly the surgical aspects of when to perform examination under anaesthesia (EUA) and when to insert or remove setons. METHODS: We conducted a systematic review following PRISMA guidelines. Multiple databases were searched from inception through December 2025. Eligible publications included clinical guidelines on pfCD and/or rectovaginal fistulas that reported indications for EUA, seton insertion, and/or seton removal. We stratified recommendations by fistula complexity, the presence of abscesses, and clinical symptoms. Risk of bias was assessed using the AGREE II Instrument. RESULTS: Twenty-four guidelines met inclusion criteria. EUA (and often seton placement) was universally recommended for perianal abscesses and frequently for symptomatic complex pfCD. For asymptomatic complex or symptomatic simple fistulas, recommendations were variable and often conditional on the presence of proctitis or plans for biologic therapy. In contrast, EUA and setons were not broadly endorsed for asymptomatic simple fistulas. Recommendations for seton removal varied widely, ranging from predefined intervals after anti-TNF therapy initiation to individualised criteria based on clinical or radiologic response. Most guidelines did not consider symptom type/severity, prior surgery, suitability for surgical closure, and asymptomatic abscesses detected by imaging. CONCLUSION: Substantial heterogeneity and limitations exist across guidelines on the surgical management of pfCD. This underscores the need for international consensus informed by multidisciplinary expertise to standardise care in this complex population.
引用
- Medawar E, Chaudhary H, Zoughlami A, et al. Systematic Review of Published Guidelines: Recommendations for Exams Under Anaesthesia, Seton Insertion and Timing of Seton Removal for Perianal and Rectovaginal Fistulising Crohn's Disease. Aliment Pharmacol Ther. 2026. PMID: 41693361. doi:10.1111/apt.70569
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。