EXTENT研究:国际专家德尔菲共识定义超声参数测量克罗恩病肠管损伤的结果
该研究通过三轮国际德尔菲法,由30名超声和/或磁共振小肠造影专家参与,就使用肠道超声评估克罗恩病肠管损伤的Lémann指数参数达成共识。共22条陈述达成共识(≥80%同意),其中10条定义用于LI-IUS评分的狭窄和穿透性病变超声参数,12条涉及集中审阅的超声动态图像采集方案。对小肠和结肠1级狭窄病变的超声等效参数未达成共识。
要点
- 22条陈述达成共识:10条定义LI-IUS狭窄和穿透病变超声参数,12条为超声动态图像采集方案
- 小肠和结肠1级狭窄病变的超声等效参数未达成共识
- 共识支持IUS作为肠管损伤评估替代工具的潜在应用
核心结论
- 推导出与已验证的MRE和结肠镜LI标准对齐的超声等效参数,用于评估克罗恩病小肠和结肠损伤。
- 这些陈述是EXTENT项目的第一阶段,支持IUS作为肠管损伤评估替代工具在临床实践和疾病修饰试验中的潜在应用。
- 对小肠和结肠1级狭窄病变缺乏共识,提示需要进一步探索IUS参数。
研究设计与样本
- 国际专家德尔菲共识,30名国际肠道超声和/或磁共振小肠造影专家参与。
- 共3轮德尔菲过程:2轮在线反馈和评分,最终面对面轮讨论并投票未解决项目。
- 同意率至少80%的陈述被接受。
主要发现
- 22条陈述达成共识:10条定义用于LI-IUS评分的狭窄和穿透性病变的IUS参数。
- 12条陈述涉及集中审阅的最佳IUS动态图像采集方案。
- 对小肠和结肠1级狭窄病变的IUS等效参数未达成共识。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识接受阈值:至少80%同意。
- 22条陈述达成共识(10条LI-IUS参数,12条采集方案)。
- 1级狭窄病变(小肠和结肠)的IUS等效参数未达成共识。
局限性
- 对小肠和结肠1级狭窄病变的IUS等效参数未达成共识,提示需要进一步探索IUS参数。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND & AIMS: A primary aim in managing Crohn's disease (CD) is preventing bowel damage. The Lémann index (LI) quantifies structural bowel damage using magnetic resonance enterography (MRE) or computed tomography enterography (CTE) and, for colonic CD, colonoscopy. Intestinal ultrasonography (IUS) provides a noninvasive imaging alternative, although its role in LI assessment remains unexplored. This study aimed to establish a consensus on parameters and acquisition protocol for scoring small bowel and colonic damage using IUS in evaluating the LI. METHODS: Thirty international experts in IUS and/or MRE participated in a 3-round Delphi process. Participants provided feedback and rated statements on IUS parameters and acquisition protocol in 2 online rounds. During the final in-person round, unresolved items were discussed and voted upon. Statements with at least 80% agreement were accepted. RESULTS: Twenty-two statements reached a consensus: 10 defined IUS parameters for stricturing and penetrating lesions for scoring LI-IUS, and 12 addressed optimal IUS cineloop acquisition for centralized review. No consensus on IUS equivalents for grade 1 stricturing lesions in the small bowel and colon was reached. CONCLUSIONS: Ultrasonographic equivalents for assessing small bowel and colonic damage in CD were derived to align with the validated LI criteria for MRE and colonoscopy. These statements mark the first phase of the EXTENT project, supporting the potential use of IUS in clinical practice and disease modification trials as an alternative tool for bowel damage assessment. The lack of consensus on grade 1 stricturing lesions suggests further exploration of IUS parameters is required.
引用
- Palmela C, Torres J, Frias-Gomes C, et al. The EXTENT Study: Results From an International Expert Delphi Consensus to Define Ultrasonographic Parameters for Measuring Bowel Damage in Crohn's Disease. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2025. PMID: 40738277. doi:10.1016/j.cgh.2025.07.024
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。