大型结肠腺瘤内镜整块切除与分块切除:一项随机试验的碳足迹事后分析
本研究为RESECT-COLON随机试验的事后分析,前瞻性收集359例患者两种切除方式所用器械,采用生命周期评估比较碳足迹。单次P-EMR为63.5 kg CO2e,ESD为73.2 kg CO2e;纳入随访后P-EMR为93.5 kg CO2e,ESD为76.3 kg CO2e,ESD每例绝对减少17 kg CO2e(18%)。若P-EMR切除与随访均在本地中心完成,18个月随访总影响为67.3 kg CO2e,结果有利于P-EMR。
要点
- 单次手术碳足迹P-EMR 63.5 kg CO2e vs ESD 73.2 kg CO2e,其中患者交通约占一半。
- 纳入随访后P-EMR 93.5 kg CO2e vs ESD 76.3 kg CO2e,ESD每例减少17 kg CO2e(18%)。
- 模拟P-EMR切除与随访均在本地中心完成,18个月总影响67.3 kg CO2e,有利于P-EMR。
核心结论
- 对于直径超过25 mm的病变,ESD策略可通过减少相关随访结肠镜和患者交通降低环境影响。
- 若P-EMR能在本地中心以相似质量完成,结果将有利于本地P-EMR。
研究设计与样本
- RESECT-COLON随机试验的碳足迹事后分析。
- 前瞻性收集359例患者两种手术所用器械。
- 采用生命周期评估,评估内镜与一次性医疗产品、电力消耗、麻醉产品、患者交通4项参数。
- 对两组随访碳足迹在不同情景下进行模拟,分析18个月碳足迹。
主要发现
- 单次P-EMR碳足迹为63.5 kg二氧化碳当量(CO2e),ESD为73.2 kg CO2e,其中患者交通约占一半。
- 纳入本地中心随访后,P-EMR产生93.5 kg CO2e,ESD产生76.3 kg CO2e,ESD每例绝对减少17 kg CO2e(18%)。
- 模拟P-EMR切除与随访均在本地中心完成,18个月随访的总体影响为67.3 kg CO2e,有利于P-EMR而非ESD。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Endoscopy makes a significant contribution to the carbon footprint of healthcare. A randomized trial (RESECT-COLON) demonstrated that endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD) decreases the recurrence rate of large adenomas (>25 mm) vs piecemeal endoscopic mucosal resection (P-EMR), reducing the need for follow-up colonoscopy. We aimed to compare the carbon footprint of those 2 strategies. METHODS: Devices used for both procedures were collected prospectively for each of the 359 patients. P-EMR and ESD were assessed using the life cycle assessment, evaluating 4 parameters: endoscopes and disposable medical products, electricity consumption, anesthetic products, and patient transport. The carbon footprint of the follow-up was simulated in both arms with different scenarios. We performed a post hoc analysis of the carbon footprint of these 2 strategies over 18 months. RESULTS: Carbon footprint of a single P-EMR procedure was 63.5 kg carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e) vs 73.2 kg CO2e for ESD (half for patient transport). Including follow-up in local centers, P-EMR generates 93.5 kg CO2e and ESD 76.3 kg CO2e, corresponding to an absolute reduction of 17 kg CO2e (18%) per procedure for ESD. Simulating a strategy of P-EMR resection and follow-up both performed in local centers, the global impact with 18 months follow-up would be 67.3 kg CO2e, favoring P-EMR over ESD. CONCLUSIONS: ESD strategy for lesions over 25 mm could reduce the environmental impact by reducing the associated follow-up colonoscopies and transports of patients. If P-EMR could be performed in local centers with similar quality, results would be in favor of local P-EMR.
引用
- Grau R, Cottinet PJ, Le MQ, et al. Endoscopic En Bloc vs Piecemeal Resection of Large Colonic Adenomas: Carbon Footprint Post Hoc Analysis of a Randomized Trial. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2025. PMID: 40049342. doi:10.1016/j.cgh.2025.01.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。