ERCP中污染十二指肠镜的检测灵敏度及漏检风险
该研究结合2015年3月至2022年6月的十二指肠镜微生物监测数据与使用数据,评估患者暴露于被肠道或口腔来源微生物污染十二指肠镜的情况。共纳入556份十二指肠镜培养,185份(33.3%)被肠道或口腔来源微生物污染,十二指肠镜总使用次数为5226次。根据三种情景假设,污染使用百分比为12.3%至23.7%,培养灵敏度为82.2%至98.9%。结论认为十二指肠镜培养灵敏度有限,导致内镜清除不彻底,增加暴发风险。
要点
- 556份十二指肠镜培养中185份(33.3%)被肠道或口腔来源微生物污染。
- 根据情景假设,污染使用百分比为12.3%至23.7%,培养灵敏度为82.2%至98.9%。
- 十二指肠镜培养灵敏度有限,导致内镜清除不彻底,增加暴发风险。
核心结论
- 十二指肠镜培养灵敏度有限,导致内镜清除不彻底,增加暴发风险;应重新评估单次培养结束隔离的适用性。
研究设计与样本
- 结合2015年3月至2022年6月十二指肠镜微生物监测数据与使用数据,评估患者暴露于被肠道或口腔来源微生物污染十二指肠镜的情况。
- 纳入556份十二指肠镜培养,总使用次数为5226次;使用分子分型确认菌种遗传相关性,定义持续污染期和聚集。
- 采用3种情景假设污染使用和培养灵敏度。
主要发现
- 556份十二指肠镜培养中185份(33.3%)被肠道或口腔来源微生物污染。
- 识别出1个持续污染期、6个未确认期和2个聚集。
- 根据情景假设,污染使用百分比为12.3%至23.7%,培养灵敏度为82.2%至98.9%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Periodic duodenoscope cultures are essential to timely detect contamination, but their sensitivity remains unknown. This study aims to determine the sensitivity of duodenoscope cultures and to estimate the prevalence of contaminated duodenoscope use. METHODS: We combined duodenoscope microbiologic surveillance data from March 2015 to June 2022 with usage data to evaluate patient exposure to duodenoscopes contaminated with microorganisms of gut or oral origin (MGO). We identified duodenoscopes with repeated species-level contamination within a year and used molecular typing to confirm genetic relatedness. Genetically related microorganisms over multiple duodenoscope cultures of a single duodenoscope indicated a period of sustained contamination, and a cluster was defined as overlapping periods of sustained contamination between different duodenoscopes. If microorganisms were not available for molecular analysis, we marked the period as unconfirmed. A sample was defined as false negative if it did not show the target microorganism(s) in a period of sustained contamination. We used 3 scenarios to hypothesize about contaminated use and culture sensitivity. RESULTS: We included 556 duodenoscope cultures with 185 (33.3%) contaminated with MGO. The total usage of duodenoscopes was 5226. We identified 1 period of sustained contamination, 6 unconfirmed periods, and 2 clusters. Depending on our scenario assumptions, the percentage of contaminated use varied from 12.3% to 23.7% and culture sensitivity ranged from 82.2% to 98.9%. CONCLUSIONS: Limited sensitivity of duodenoscope cultures leads to improper clearance of duodenoscopes for clinical use, increasing risks of outbreaks. The applicability of a single culture to end a duodenoscope's quarantine should be re-evaluated.
引用
- van der Ploeg K, Severin JA, Klaassen CHW, et al. Contaminated duodenoscopes in ERCP: sensitivity of detection and risk of underdetection. Gastrointest Endosc. 2024. PMID: 39128530. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2024.08.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。