冷圈套与热圈套内镜黏膜切除术治疗大型(≥15 mm)平坦无蒂结直肠息肉:一项随机对照试验
这项单中心随机对照试验将177例15-50 mm平坦腺瘤性无蒂结直肠息肉患者随机分至冷圈套内镜黏膜切除术(C-EMR)组(n=87)或热圈套内镜黏膜切除术(H-EMR)组(n=90)。C-EMR组6个月复查结肠镜复发率显著高于H-EMR组(18.4% vs 1.1%;RR 16.6,95%CI 2.24至122;p<0.001),但H-EMR组临床显著EMR后出血更多(7.8% vs 1.1%;p=0.034)。结论认为C-EMR安全性更优且技术成功率相当,但内镜复发率显著更高是当前局限。
要点
- C-EMR组6个月复发率18.4%(16/87),显著高于H-EMR组的1.1%(1/90)。
- H-EMR组临床显著EMR后出血7.8%(7/90),高于C-EMR组的1.1%(1/87)。
- 两组技术成功率相当:C-EMR 98.9%(86/87)vs H-EMR 100%(90/90)。
核心结论
- 与H-EMR相比,C-EMR治疗平坦腺瘤性大型无蒂结直肠息肉安全性更优且技术成功率相当。
- 但冷圈套切除的内镜复发率显著更高,是目前该技术的局限。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心随机对照试验,前瞻性纳入15-50 mm平坦腺瘤性大型无蒂结直肠息肉,随机分配至C-EMR组或H-EMR联合边缘热消融组。
主要发现
- 177例患者的177枚息肉随机分组:C-EMR组87枚,H-EMR组90枚。
- 6个月监测结肠镜复发:C-EMR组16/87(18.4%)vs H-EMR组1/90(1.1%);RR 16.6,95%CI 2.24至122;p<0.001。
- 技术成功:C-EMR组86/87(98.9%)vs H-EMR组90/90(100%);p=0.31。
- 迟发性穿孔:H-EMR组1/90(1.1%)vs C-EMR组0;p=0.32。
- 临床显著EMR后出血:H-EMR组7/90(7.8%)vs C-EMR组1/87(1.1%);RR 6.77,95%CI 0.85至53.9;p=0.034。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Conventional hot snare endoscopic mucosal resection (H-EMR) is effective for the management of large (≥20 mm) non-pedunculated colon polyps (LNPCPs) however, electrocautery-related complications may incur significant morbidity. With a superior safety profile, cold snare EMR (C-EMR) of LNPCPs is an attractive alternative however evidence is lacking. We conducted a randomised trial to compare the efficacy and safety of C-EMR to H-EMR. METHODS: Flat, 15-50 mm adenomatous LNPCPs were prospectively enrolled and randomly assigned to C-EMR or H-EMR with margin thermal ablation at a single tertiary centre. The primary outcome was endoscopically visible and/or histologically confirmed recurrence at 6 months surveillance colonoscopy. Secondary outcomes were clinically significant post-EMR bleeding (CSPEB), delayed perforation and technical success. RESULTS: 177 LNPCPs in 177 patients were randomised to C-EMR arm (n=87) or H-EMR (n=90). Treatment groups were equivalent for technical success 86/87 (98.9%) C-EMR versus H-EMR 90/90 (100%); p=0.31. Recurrence was significantly greater in C-EMR (16/87, 18.4% vs 1/90, 1.1%; relative risk (RR) 16.6, 95% CI 2.24 to 122; p<0.001).Delayed perforation (1/90 (1.1%) vs 0; p=0.32) only occurred in the H-EMR group. CSPEB was significantly greater in the H-EMR arm (7/90 (7.8%) vs 1/87 (1.1%); RR 6.77, 95% CI 0.85 to 53.9; p=0.034). CONCLUSION: Compared with H-EMR, C-EMR for flat, adenomatous LNPCPs, demonstrates superior safety with equivalent technical success. However, endoscopic recurrence is significantly greater for cold snare resection and is currently a limitation of the technique. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT04138030.
引用
- O'Sullivan T, Cronin O, van Hattem WA, et al. Cold versus hot snare endoscopic mucosal resection for large (≥15 mm) flat non-pedunculated colorectal polyps: a randomised controlled trial. Gut. 2024. PMID: 38964854. doi:10.1136/gutjnl-2024-332807
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。