计算机辅助结直肠息肉检测的临床后果
这项多中心试验在946例患者中比较计算机辅助检测(CADe)与内镜医师的息肉检出,CADe对腺瘤的敏感性更高,但总体息肉敏感性不优于人类(94.6% vs 96.0%)。揭盲后额外检出86个真阳性息肉(每例患者腺瘤检出率增加1.1%),腺瘤检出率的额外增益很小,随访间隔仅2.3%的患者改变,但非肿瘤性息肉的额外检查增加,手术时间延长6.6±6.5分钟(+42.6%)。
要点
- CADe对腺瘤的敏感性优于内镜医师,但总体息肉敏感性不优于人类(94.6% vs 96.0%)。
- 揭盲后额外检出86个真阳性息肉,腺瘤检出率每例患者仅增加1.1%,73.8%的额外检出息肉<5 mm。
- CADe使非肿瘤性息肉检出绝对增加4.9%的病例,手术时间延长6.6±6.5分钟(+42.6%)。
核心结论
- CADe似乎比人类内镜医师稍敏感,但腺瘤检出率的额外增益很小,随访间隔很少改变。
- 非肿瘤性病变的额外检查增加,增加了检查或息肉切除的工作量。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心试验,纳入946例患者(51.9%男性,平均年龄64岁),使用结合卷积和循环神经网络的CADe进行息肉检测。
- 由第二位观察者实时监测盲法内镜医师并访问CADe,CADe检测触发重新检查。
- 研究前和研究后测量腺瘤检出率和息肉检出率,组织学评估由独立病理学家完成。
- 主要结局比较内镜医师与CADe的息肉检测。
主要发现
- 共识别2141个息肉,包括989个腺瘤。
- CADe总体息肉敏感性不优于人类(94.6% vs 96.0%),但限于腺瘤时优于人类。
- 揭盲导致额外86个真阳性息肉检出(每例患者腺瘤检出率增加1.1%;73.8%的额外检出息肉<5 mm)。
- CADe使非肿瘤性息肉检出绝对增加4.9%的病例(整个息肉负荷增加1.8%)。
- 手术时间增加6.6±6.5分钟(+42.6%)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIM: Randomised trials show improved polyp detection with computer-aided detection (CADe), mostly of small lesions. However, operator and selection bias may affect CADe's true benefit. Clinical outcomes of increased detection have not yet been fully elucidated. METHODS: In this multicentre trial, CADe combining convolutional and recurrent neural networks was used for polyp detection. Blinded endoscopists were monitored in real time by a second observer with CADe access. CADe detections prompted reinspection. Adenoma detection rates (ADR) and polyp detection rates were measured prestudy and poststudy. Histological assessments were done by independent histopathologists. The primary outcome compared polyp detection between endoscopists and CADe. RESULTS: In 946 patients (51.9% male, mean age 64), a total of 2141 polyps were identified, including 989 adenomas. CADe was not superior to human polyp detection (sensitivity 94.6% vs 96.0%) but outperformed them when restricted to adenomas. Unblinding led to an additional yield of 86 true positive polyp detections (1.1% ADR increase per patient; 73.8% were <5 mm). CADe also increased non-neoplastic polyp detection by an absolute value of 4.9% of the cases (1.8% increase of entire polyp load). Procedure time increased with 6.6±6.5 min (+42.6%). In 22/946 patients, the additional detection of adenomas changed surveillance intervals (2.3%), mostly by increasing the number of small adenomas beyond the cut-off. CONCLUSION: Even if CADe appears to be slightly more sensitive than human endoscopists, the additional gain in ADR was minimal and follow-up intervals rarely changed. Additional inspection of non-neoplastic lesions was increased, adding to the inspection and/or polypectomy workload.
引用
- Sinonquel P, Eelbode T, Pech O, et al. Clinical consequences of computer-aided colorectal polyp detection. Gut. 2024. PMID: 38876773. doi:10.1136/gutjnl-2024-331943
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。