美国胃肠内镜学会制定专门高级内镜 fellowship 项目中高级内镜培训标准
美国胃肠内镜学会采用 RAND UCLA 适宜性方法(改良德尔菲法)制定非认证高级内镜 fellowship 项目(AEFP)的质量指标。20 名专家经 3 轮反馈,从 89 项候选指标中确定 37 项为适宜质量指标,并为 19 项相关指标定义最低阈值。最终指标包括受训者应至少每季度使用验证工具接受定性和定量能力评估并记录反馈,以及追踪特定操作的结果和质量指标。
要点
- 37 项质量指标被判定为适宜,涵盖培训前活动、AEFP 结构及 ERCP、EUS、EMR、管腔支架置入培训。
- 19 项相关质量指标定义了最低阈值,涉及培训师数量、fellowship 期间操作量和能力评估前操作量。
- 受训者应至少每季度使用验证工具接受定性和定量能力评估并记录反馈,并追踪特定操作的结果和质量指标。
核心结论
- 该共识流程采用验证方法建立了 AEFP 标准,以确保 fellowship 期间最常见介入内镜操作(ERCP、EUS、EMR 和管腔支架置入)的充分培训。
- AEFP 的重要组成部分是使用基于能力的评估,并符合毕业后医学教育认证委员会(Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education)的 Next Accreditation System,目标是确保受训者在达到认知和技术能力的过程中实现特定里程碑。
研究设计与样本
- 美国胃肠内镜学会成立的工作组采用 RAND UCLA 适宜性方法(一种描述完善的改良德尔菲流程)制定质量指标。
- 在 6 个类别中起草潜在质量指标(结构、过程和结果):培训前活动;AEFP 结构;ERCP、EUS 和 EMR 培训;以及管腔支架置入。
- 来自 20 名专家的 3 轮迭代反馈:第 0 轮讨论项目细节;第 1 轮专家在 9 点区间量表(1=高度不适宜至 9=高度适宜)上独立对候选质量指标排序;集体会议讨论并改写后第 2 轮独立重新排序并提供基准(适用时)。
- 计算每个质量指标的中位分数和平均绝对偏差,使用 BIOMED 适宜性定义、P 值法和调整对称性的百分位间范围定义评估适宜性;中位分数 ≥7 且满足全部 3 种统计方法适宜性标准才判定为适宜。
主要发现
- 89 项候选质量指标中,37 项声明符合质量指标适宜性标准:培训前活动 2 项;AEFP 结构 10 项;ERCP 培训 7 项;EUS 培训 8 项;EMR 培训 7 项;管腔支架置入 3 项。
- 为 19 项相关质量指标定义了最低阈值,涉及培训师数量、fellowship 期间操作量和能力评估前操作量。
关键数值与推荐
- 最终适宜质量指标包括:所有受训者应至少每季度使用验证工具接受定性和定量能力评估,并在整个培训期间记录反馈。
- 最终适宜质量指标包括:受训者应追踪特定操作的结果和相关质量指标。
- 19 项相关质量指标定义了最低阈值,涉及培训师数量、fellowship 期间操作量和能力评估前操作量。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Training in interventional endoscopy is offered by nonaccredited advanced endoscopy fellowship programs (AEFPs). The number of these programs has increased dramatically with a concurrent increase in the breadth and complexity of interventional endoscopy procedures. Accreditation is governed by competency-based education, yet what constitutes a "high-quality" nonaccredited AEFP has not been defined. Using an evidence-based consensus process, we aimed to establish standards for AEFPs. METHODS: The RAND UCLA appropriateness method, a well-described modified Delphi process to develop quality indicators, was used. A task force established by the American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy drafted potential quality indicators (structure, process, and outcome) in 6 categories: activity preceding training; structure of AEFPs; training in ERCP, EUS, and EMR; and luminal stent placement. Three rounds of iterative feedback from 20 experts were conducted. Round 0 involved discussion of project details. In round 1, experts independently ranked proposed quality indicators on a 9-point interval scale ranging from highly inappropriate (1) to highly appropriate (9). Next, proposed quality indicators were discussed and reworded in a group meeting followed by round 2, in which experts independently reranked proposed quality indicators and provided benchmarks (when applicable). The median score for each quality indicator was calculated. Mean absolute deviation from the median was calculated, and appropriateness of potential quality indicators was assessed using the BIOMED concerted action on appropriateness definition, P value method, and interpercentile range adjusted for symmetry definition. A quality indicator was deemed appropriate if the median score was ≥7 and met criteria for appropriateness using all 3 defined statistical methods. RESULTS: Of 89 proposed quality indicators, 37 statements met criteria as appropriate for a quality indicator (activity preceding training, 2; structure of AEFPs, 10; training in ERCP, 7; training in EUS, 8; training in EMR, 7; luminal stent placement, 3). Minimum thresholds were defined for 19 relevant quality indicators for number of trainers, procedures during fellowship, and procedures before assessment of competence. Among the final appropriate quality indicators were that all trainees should undergo qualitative and quantitative competence assessments using validated tools at least quarterly with documented feedback throughout the training period and that trainees should track outcomes and relevant quality metrics for specific procedures. CONCLUSIONS: This consensus process using validated methodology established standards for an AEFP in an effort to ensure adequate training in the most commonly taught interventional endoscopic procedures (ERCP, EUS, EMR, and luminal stent placement) during fellowship. An important component of an AEFP is the use of competency-based assessments that are compliant with the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education's Next Accreditation System, with the goal of ensuring that trainees achieve specific milestones in their progression to achieving cognitive and technical competency.
引用
- Wani S, Cote GA, Keswani RN, et al. Development of American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy standards for training in advanced endoscopy within dedicated advanced endoscopy fellowship programs. Gastrointest Endosc. 2024. PMID: 38935016. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2024.03.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。