指南与共识消化内镜消化道肿瘤与早癌

关于人工智能在内镜应用现状的共识声明:应对障碍并推进人工智能在胃肠病学中的应用

Consensus statements on the current landscape of artificial intelligence applications in endoscopy, addressing roadblocks, and advancing artificial intelligence in gastroenterology.
指南 / 共识 · Gastrointest Endosc · 2024-04-17

美国胃肠内镜学会(ASGE)人工智能工作组联合内镜、技术、监管等领域专家,采用改良德尔菲法制定10条共识声明,分析AI在内镜检测与表征、质量指标、智能内镜室、预测建模、大数据研究、教育培训、临床整合挑战、支付模式、证据标准及多方协作等方面的现状与障碍,指出AI算法在提升内镜医师表现等方面有前景,但评估、透明度、治理、支付、结局定义和协作等挑战仍存。

要点

  • AI算法可辅助内镜医师检测和表征内镜病变,并可用计算机视觉重新定义质量指标。
  • AI可支持智能内镜室优化工作流程,并借助机器学习和高质量多维数据进行预测建模与诊断。
  • 整合AI面临人机交互、透明度、可解释性、治理和数据采购等挑战,需多方协作推进。

核心结论

  • ASGE人工智能工作组与多学科专家达成的共识表明,AI在内镜和胃肠病学中具有提升内镜医师表现、重新定义质量指标、优化流程及辅助预测建模和诊断的潜力,但在算法评估、透明度与可解释性、治理与数据采购、支付模式、临床结局定义及利益相关方协作等方面仍存在挑战,解决这些挑战对AI在胃肠病学中的有意义进展至关重要。

研究设计与样本

  • 美国胃肠内镜学会(ASGE)人工智能工作组联合内镜、技术领域、监管机构及其他医学亚专科专家,采用改良德尔菲法制定共识声明。

主要发现

  • 声明1指出,当前AI进展使基于AI的算法可应用于内镜,以增强内镜医师在检测和表征内镜病变方面的表现。
  • 声明2指出,基于计算机视觉的算法为利用AI重新定义内镜质量指标提供了机会,可标准化并减少质量指标报告中的主观性;基于自然语言处理的算法可帮助轻松完成报告当前胃肠内镜质量指标所需的数据抽象。
  • 声明3指出,AI技术可支持智能内镜室,可能有助于优化内镜室工作流程,包括自动化文档记录。
  • 声明4指出,使用AI和机器学习有助于预测建模、诊断和预后判断;使用机器学习方法进行风险预测、特定临床状况及其结局的预后判断时,需要高质量、多维度的数据。
  • 声明5指出,大数据和云工具可帮助推进胃肠病学临床研究;多模态数据对于理解疾病状态的最大范围和解锁治疗选择至关重要。

关键数值与推荐

  • 声明6指出,理解如何评估胃肠病学文献和临床试验中的AI算法对胃肠病学家、受训人员和研究人员很重要,因此胃肠病学学会需要开展教育努力。
  • 声明7指出,将AI解决方案整合到内镜临床实践中存在若干挑战,包括理解人机交互的作用;AI算法的透明度、可解释性和可说明性在其临床采用中起关键作用;制定适当的AI治理、数据采购和AI生命周期所需工具对AI成功实施到临床实践至关重要。
  • 声明8指出,对于内镜中AI的支付,全面评估AI系统的潜在价值主张可能有助于指导内镜采购决策;需要可靠的成本效益研究来指导报销。
  • 声明9指出,胃肠病学中AI的相关临床结局和性能指标目前尚未明确定义;为提高该领域研究的质量和可解释性,需要采取措施定义这些证据标准。
  • 声明10指出,对AI技术持平衡观点以及医学技术产业、计算机科学家、胃肠病学家和研究人员之间的积极合作,对于AI在胃肠病学中的有意义进展至关重要。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: The American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy (ASGE) AI Task Force along with experts in endoscopy, technology space, regulatory authorities, and other medical subspecialties initiated a consensus process that analyzed the current literature, highlighted potential areas, and outlined the necessary research in artificial intelligence (AI) to allow a clearer understanding of AI as it pertains to endoscopy currently. METHODS: A modified Delphi process was used to develop these consensus statements. RESULTS: Statement 1: Current advances in AI allow for the development of AI-based algorithms that can be applied to endoscopy to augment endoscopist performance in detection and characterization of endoscopic lesions. Statement 2: Computer vision-based algorithms provide opportunities to redefine quality metrics in endoscopy using AI, which can be standardized and can reduce subjectivity in reporting quality metrics. Natural language processing-based algorithms can help with the data abstraction needed for reporting current quality metrics in GI endoscopy effortlessly. Statement 3: AI technologies can support smart endoscopy suites, which may help optimize workflows in the endoscopy suite, including automated documentation. Statement 4: Using AI and machine learning helps in predictive modeling, diagnosis, and prognostication. High-quality data with multidimensionality are needed for risk prediction, prognostication of specific clinical conditions, and their outcomes when using machine learning methods. Statement 5: Big data and cloud-based tools can help advance clinical research in gastroenterology. Multimodal data are key to understanding the maximal extent of the disease state and unlocking treatment options. Statement 6: Understanding how to evaluate AI algorithms in the gastroenterology literature and clinical trials is important for gastroenterologists, trainees, and researchers, and hence education efforts by GI societies are needed. Statement 7: Several challenges regarding integrating AI solutions into the clinical practice of endoscopy exist, including understanding the role of human-AI interaction. Transparency, interpretability, and explainability of AI algorithms play a key role in their clinical adoption in GI endoscopy. Developing appropriate AI governance, data procurement, and tools needed for the AI lifecycle are critical for the successful implementation of AI into clinical practice. Statement 8: For payment of AI in endoscopy, a thorough evaluation of the potential value proposition for AI systems may help guide purchasing decisions in endoscopy. Reliable cost-effectiveness studies to guide reimbursement are needed. Statement 9: Relevant clinical outcomes and performance metrics for AI in gastroenterology are currently not well defined. To improve the quality and interpretability of research in the field, steps need to be taken to define these evidence standards. Statement 10: A balanced view of AI technologies and active collaboration between the medical technology industry, computer scientists, gastroenterologists, and researchers are critical for the meaningful advancement of AI in gastroenterology. CONCLUSIONS: The consensus process led by the ASGE AI Task Force and experts from various disciplines has shed light on the potential of AI in endoscopy and gastroenterology. AI-based algorithms have shown promise in augmenting endoscopist performance, redefining quality metrics, optimizing workflows, and aiding in predictive modeling and diagnosis. However, challenges remain in evaluating AI algorithms, ensuring transparency and interpretability, addressing governance and data procurement, determining payment models, defining relevant clinical outcomes, and fostering collaboration between stakeholders. Addressing these challenges while maintaining a balanced perspective is crucial for the meaningful advancement of AI in gastroenterology.

来源:Gastrointest Endosc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Parasa S, Berzin T, Leggett C, et al. Consensus statements on the current landscape of artificial intelligence applications in endoscopy, addressing roadblocks, and advancing artificial intelligence in gastroenterology. Gastrointest Endosc. 2024. PMID: 38639679. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2023.12.003

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。