肝门部及围肝门部胆管癌的胆道引流:一家三级癌症中心25年经验
该回顾性研究分析了1997至2023年333例胆管癌患者共1050次ERCP的胆道引流策略,发现自膨式金属支架(SEMS)临床成功率高于塑料支架(PS),但支架相关不良事件(AE)风险也更高;双猪尾塑料支架较直塑料支架的支架相关AE更少;双侧SEMS组52%患者死于胆管炎。
要点
- SEMS/单侧SEMS的临床成功率分别为89%/91%,高于PS/单侧PS的85%/85%及PS套SEMS/单侧PS套SEMS的71%/74%。
- 与PS相比,SEMS和PS套SEMS的支架相关AE风险更高(OR分别为4.85和9.99)。
- 直塑料支架较双猪尾支架的支架相关AE更多(OR 6.74),PS可移除并可能更利于后续PTBD。
核心结论
- SEMS相对较高的临床成功率被其较高的支架相关AE率所抵消。
- PS可被移除并可能更好地促进PTBD。
- 在PS类型中,双猪尾支架的支架相关AE可能更少。
- 需要球囊扩张(BD)及内镜下见脓液的患者可能从更早的再干预中获益。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入1997年至2023年接受胆道引流的胆管癌患者。
- 按患者分析PTBD率、ERCP中位次数和总生存期(OS);按操作分析临床成功(CS)、支架特异性AE及按支架类型和侧别(单侧和双侧)的平均重复ERCP时间。
主要发现
- 共333例患者接受1050次ERCP,85%使用塑料支架(PS)。
- 最终23%的PS患者行PTBD,其中35%在PTBD前已移除PS。
- SEMS/单侧SEMS的CS为89%/91%,PS/单侧PS均为85%,PS套SEMS/单侧PS套SEMS为71%/74%(P = .013/P = .054)。
- 与PS相比,SEMS和PS套SEMS的支架相关AE更高(OR 4.85 [95%CI 3.23-7.27] 和 OR 9.99 [95%CI 5.33-18.71];P < .001)。
- 直PS较双猪尾支架的支架相关AE更多(OR 6.74 [95%CI 3.95-11.45];P < .001)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: This study analyzed the optimal biliary stenting strategy for palliation in cholangiocarcinoma (CCA). METHODS: This was a retrospective study of patients with CCA who underwent biliary drainage from 1997 to 2023. A per-patient analysis of percutaneous transhepatic biliary drainage (PTBD) rates, the median number of ERCPs, and overall survival (OS) and a per-procedure analysis of clinical success (CS), stent-specific adverse events (AEs), and mean time to repeat ERCP by stent type and laterality (unilateral and bilateral) are presented. RESULTS: A total of 333 patients underwent 1050 ERCPs, 85% with plastic stents (PSs). PTBD was eventually done in 23% of PS patients, 35% of whom had their PS removed before PTBD. ERCPs with the use of self-expandable metal stents (SEMSs)/unilateral SEMSs had higher CS (89%/91%) versus PSs/unilateral plastic stents (uPSs) (85% both) and PSs within SEMSs (PS-SEMSs)/uPS-SEMSs (71%/74%; P = .013/P = .054). Compared with PSs, SEMSs and PS-SEMSs were associated with higher stent-specific AEs (odds ratios [ORs]: SEMSs 4.85 [95% confidence interval (CI), 3.23-7.27], PS-SEMSs 9.99 [95% CI, 5.33-18.71]; P < .001). Straight PSs were associated with more stent-specific AEs compared with double-pigtail stents (OR 6.74 [95% CI, 3.95-11.45]; P < .001). More 7F stents were used in cases with balloon dilation (BD) (109 with BD vs 88 without BD; P < .001). BD had a 79% CS rate versus 87% without BD (P < .001). Cases with pus on ERCP and those with BD had a shorter mean time to repeat ERCP. On regression analyses, higher Bismuth class, PS use, and PS-SEMS use were associated with a shorter mean time to repeat ERCP. Fifty-two percent of patients in the bilateral SEMS arm died from cholangitis (P = .005). CONCLUSIONS: The relatively higher CS rate of SEMSs is countered by the higher stent-specific AE rate. PSs can be removed and may better facilitate PTBD. Within PS types, double-pigtail stents may have fewer stent-specific AEs. Cases requiring BD and with endoscopic evidence of pus may benefit from earlier reintervention.
引用
- Al Nakshabandi A, Ali FS, Albustami I, et al. Biliary drainage in hilar and perihilar cholangiocarcinoma: 25-year experience at a tertiary cancer center. Gastrointest Endosc. 2023. PMID: 38092128. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2023.12.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。