用于Boškoski-Costamagna ERCP模拟器的生物乳头模型的面效度与内容效度
本研究评估由鸡心组织制成的生物乳头模型(整合于Boškoski-Costamagna ERCP训练器)的面效度与内容效度。19名参与者(无经验组10名、有经验组9名)完成标准化操作并填写问卷,结果总体认为模型逼真度为4/5,组间总体逼真度一致性良好,有经验操作者高度同意该乳头模型应纳入培训。结论显示该模型具有良好面效度和优秀内容效度,为乳头括约肌切开、预切开及乳头切除术培训提供有用、廉价、多用途且简便的工具,未来研究应探索将其纳入真实培训是否改善内镜学员学习曲线。
要点
- 生物乳头模型总体逼真度评分为4/5,组间总体逼真度一致性良好。
- 有经验操作者高度同意该乳头模型应纳入新手和中级学员的括约肌切开、预切开及乳头切除术培训。
- 该模型为乳头括约肌切开、预切开及乳头切除术培训提供有用、廉价、多用途且简便的工具。
核心结论
- 该生物乳头模型联合Boškoski-Costamagna ERCP训练器具有良好面效度和优秀内容效度。
- 该新工具为括约肌切开、预切开及乳头切除术培训提供有用、廉价、多用途且简便的工具。
- 未来研究应探索将该模型纳入真实培训是否改善内镜学员的学习曲线。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入2组参与者:无经验组(终生ERCP操作<600例)10名和有经验组(终生ERCP操作>600例)9名,共19名。
- 两组均受邀在模型上完成标准化操作:括约肌切开和预切开,有经验组还完成乳头切除术。
- 操作后所有参与者填写问卷评估模型逼真度,有经验内镜医师另用5点Likert量表评估其教学价值。
主要发现
- 关于工具逼真度的参数(总体外观、括约肌切开、预切开和乳头切除术)总体被认为逼真(4/5),组间总体逼真度一致性良好。
- 有经验操作者报告最高逼真度的项目为「将内镜和针刀定位在视野中」、「预切开过程中」、「预切开时小增量切割」和「乳头切除术中控制内镜」。
- 有经验操作者高度同意该乳头模型应纳入新手和中级学员的括约肌切开、预切开和乳头切除术培训。
关键数值与推荐
- 逼真度采用5点Likert量表评分,总体逼真度评分为4/5。
- 有经验内镜医师使用5点Likert量表评估教学价值。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为该生物乳头模型联合Boškoski-Costamagna ERCP训练器为括约肌切开、预切开及乳头切除术培训提供有用、廉价、多用途且简便的工具。
- 作者认为未来研究应探索将该模型纳入真实培训是否改善内镜学员的学习曲线。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: A biological papilla made of chicken heart tissue, incorporated into the Boškoski-Costamagna ERCP Trainer simulator, was recently designed to allow training in sphincterotomy. This study aimed to evaluate the face and content validity of this tool. METHOD: Participants from 2 groups (nonexperienced and experienced [<600 or >600 lifetime ERCPs, respectively]) were invited to perform standardized assignments on the model: sphincterotomy and precut for both groups and papillectomy for the experienced group. Following these assignments, all participants filled out a questionnaire to rate their appreciation of the realism of the model, and experienced endoscopists were also asked to evaluate its didactic value using a 5-point Likert scale. RESULTS: A total of 19 participants were included (nonexperienced, n = 10; experienced, n = 9). Parameters regarding the realism of the tool in terms of general appearance, sphincterotomy, precut, and papillectomy were overall considered realistic (4 of 5), with good agreement rates in terms of overall realism between groups. Experienced operators reported the highest realism for "positioning the scope and needle-knife in the field of view" and "during precut," "cutting in small increments during precut," and "controlling the scope during papillectomy," and they highly agreed that this papilla should be included for training novice and intermediate trainees in sphincterotomy, precut, and papillectomy. CONCLUSIONS: Our results show good face validity and excellent content validity of this biological papilla combined with the Boškoski-Costamagna ERCP Trainer. This new tool provides a useful, inexpensive, versatile, and easy tool for training regarding sphincterotomy, precut, and papillectomy. Future studies should explore whether including this model in real-life training improves the learning curve of endoscopy trainees.
引用
- Teles de Campos S, Boskoski I, Voiosu T, et al. Face and content validity of a biological papilla designed for the Boškoski-Costamagna ERCP simulator. Gastrointest Endosc. 2023. PMID: 37390863. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2023.06.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。