文献速递消化内镜消化道肿瘤与早癌

冷圈套息肉切除术中受训者能力差异:COMPLETE随机对照试验结果

Varied Trainee Competence in Cold Snare Polypectomy: Results of the COMPLETE Randomized Controlled Trial.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Gastroenterol · 2023-06-13

该单盲随机对照试验比较视频反馈与传统反馈对受训者冷圈套息肉切除术(CSP)能力的影响,共随机22名受训者(视频反馈12名、传统反馈10名),评估2339例CSP。视频反馈组2名(16.7%)达到能力,平均需135个息肉,对照组无人达到能力(P=0.481);视频反馈组总体及各步骤达标比例更高,每20例CSP能力提升3%(P=0.0004)。作者认为视频反馈有助于受训者达到能力,但学习曲线较长,当前培训方法不足以在 fellowship 结束时使受训者胜任。

要点

  • 视频反馈组2名(16.7%)达到CSP能力,平均需135个息肉,对照组无人达到(P=0.481)。
  • 视频反馈组总体及各步骤达标比例更高,每20例CSP能力提升3%(P=0.0004)。
  • 作者认为当前培训方法不足以支持受训者在 fellowship 结束时达到CSP能力。

核心结论

  • 视频反馈有助于受训者达到CSP能力,但学习曲线较长。
  • 作者认为当前培训方法不足以支持受训者在 fellowship 结束时达到能力。

研究设计与样本

  • 单盲随机对照试验,比较视频反馈与传统反馈对直径<1 cm息肉CSP能力的影响。
  • 共随机22名受训者,视频反馈组12名、传统反馈组10名,评估2339例CSP。
  • 将连续记录的CSP视频去标识后随机分配给盲法评分者,使用CSP评估工具评估。
  • 每25例CSP与受训者共享累积和(CUSUM)学习曲线;视频反馈组每两周接受个体化终端反馈,对照组在结肠镜检查中接受传统反馈。
  • 主要结局为CSP能力,同时评估各领域能力及随息肉切除量变化的情况。

主要发现

  • 视频反馈组2名(16.7%)达到能力,平均需135个息肉;对照组无人达到能力(P=0.481)。
  • 视频反馈组在总体及CSP所有步骤中达到能力的比例更高,每20例CSP能力提升3%(P=0.0004)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 学习曲线较长。
  • 作者认为当前培训方法不足以支持受训者在 fellowship 结束时达到能力。
  • 应评估基于模拟的精通学习等新培训方法能否以更快速度达到能力。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: Cold snare polypectomy (CSP) is strongly recommended as the optimal technique for the complete removal of small polyps. Though significant variability in polypectomy technique and quality has been established, the learning curve and impact of targeted training on CSP are unknown. Video feedback has shown promise as an effective pedagogy to improve performance among surgical trainees. We aimed to compare CSP performance between trainees who received video-based feedback and those who received conventional apprentice-based concurrent feedback. We hypothesized that video-based feedback would accelerate competence. METHODS: We conducted a single-blinded, randomized controlled trial on competence for CSP of polyps <1 cm, comparing video-based feedback with conventional feedback. We randomly assigned deidentified consecutively recorded CSP videos to blinded raters to assess using the CSP Assessment Tool. We shared cumulative sum learning curves every 25 CSP with each trainee. The video feedback trainees also received biweekly individualized terminal feedback. Control trainees received conventional feedback during colonoscopy. The primary outcome was CSP competence. We also assessed competence across domains and change over polypectomy volume. RESULTS: We enrolled and randomized 22 trainees, 12 to video-based feedback and 10 to conventional feedback, and evaluated 2,339 CSP. The learning curve was long; 2 trainees (16.7%) in the video feedback achieved competence, after a mean of 135 polyps, and no one in the control ( P = 0.481) achieved competence. Overall and in all steps of CSP, a higher percentage of the video feedback group met competence, increasing 3% every 20 CSP ( P = 0.0004). DISCUSSION: Video feedback aided trainees to competence in CSP. However, the learning curve was long. Our findings strongly suggest that current training methods are not sufficient to support trainees to competency by the completion of their fellowship programs. The impact of new training methods, such as simulation-based mastery learning, should be assessed to determine whether such methods can result in achievement of competence at a faster rate; ClinicalTrials.gov : NCT03115008.

来源:Am J Gastroenterol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kaltenbach T, Patel SG, Nguyen-Vu T, et al. Varied Trainee Competence in Cold Snare Polypectomy: Results of the COMPLETE Randomized Controlled Trial. Am J Gastroenterol. 2023. PMID: 37307537. doi:10.14309/ajg.0000000000002368

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。