标准化克罗恩病内镜评分惯例:一项国际RAND/UCLA适宜性研究
该研究采用两轮改良RAND/UCLA适宜性方法,由15名消化科医生对克罗恩病内镜评分相关陈述进行9分制评分。小组投票认为所有溃疡均应计入内镜评分,内镜愈合应反映无溃疡,狭窄应定义为明确管腔直径减小,瘢痕和炎性息肉不宜计入受累面积评分。
要点
- 所有溃疡均应计入克罗恩病内镜评分,包括阿弗他溃疡、吻合口溃疡和肛管溃疡(在直肠计分)。
- 内镜愈合应反映无溃疡,狭窄应定义为明确管腔直径减小,不可通过的狭窄为狭窄,位于两段交界处时在远端段计分。
- 瘢痕和炎性息肉不宜计入受累面积评分,定义溃疡深度的最佳方法仍不确定。
核心结论
- 研究概述了克罗恩病简单内镜评分和克罗恩病内镜严重程度指数的评分惯例,指出这两种评分均存在局限性,并确定了未来研究重点以及开发和验证更具代表性内镜指数的步骤。
研究设计与样本
- 采用两轮改良RAND/UCLA适宜性方法研究,由15名消化科医生组成小组,使用9分Likert量表对与克罗恩病简单内镜评分、克罗恩病内镜严重程度指数及克罗恩病内镜评分相关的陈述进行适宜性评分。
主要发现
- 小组投票认为所有溃疡均应计入克罗恩病内镜评分,包括阿弗他溃疡、手术吻合口溃疡和肛管溃疡(在直肠计分)。
- 内镜愈合应反映无溃疡。
- 狭窄应定义为明确管腔直径减小;狭窄应定义为不可通过的狭窄,若发生在两段交界处,则在远端段计分。
- 瘢痕和炎性息肉被认为不宜计入受累面积评分。
- 定义溃疡深度的最佳方法仍不确定。
关键数值与推荐
- 所有溃疡均应计入内镜评分,包括阿弗他溃疡、吻合口溃疡和肛管溃疡(在直肠计分)。
- 内镜愈合应反映无溃疡。
- 狭窄应定义为明确管腔直径减小;狭窄应定义为不可通过的狭窄,若发生在两段交界处,则在远端段计分。
- 瘢痕和炎性息肉不宜计入受累面积评分。
- 定义溃疡深度的最佳方法仍不确定。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文指出克罗恩病简单内镜评分和克罗恩病内镜严重程度指数均存在局限性。
- 定义溃疡深度的最佳方法仍不确定。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Endoscopic assessment of disease activity is integral for evaluating treatment response in patients with Crohn's disease (CD). We aimed to define appropriate items for evaluating endoscopic activity and conventions for consistent endoscopic scoring rules in CD. METHODS: A 2-round modified RAND/University of California at Los Angeles Appropriateness Method study was conducted. A panel of 15 gastroenterologists used a 9-point Likert scale to rate the appropriateness of statements pertaining to the Simple Endoscopic Score for CD, Crohn's Disease Endoscopic Index of Severity, and additional items relevant to endoscopy scoring in CD. Each statement was voted as appropriate, uncertain, or inappropriate based on the median panel rating and presence of disagreement. RESULTS: Panelists voted that it is appropriate for all ulcers to contribute to endoscopic scoring in CD, including aphthous ulcers, ulcerations at a surgical anastomosis, and anal canal ulcers (scored in the rectum). Endoscopic healing should reflect an absence of ulcers. Narrowing should be defined as a clear decrease in luminal diameter; stenosis should be defined by an impassable narrowing, and if occurring at the junction of 2 segments, scored in the distal segment. Scarring and inflammatory polyps were considered inappropriate for including in the affected area score. The optimal method for defining ulcer depth remains uncertain. CONCLUSIONS: We outlined scoring conventions for the Simple Endoscopic Score for CD and Crohn's Disease Endoscopic Index of Severity, noting that both scores have limitations. Therefore, we identified priorities for future research and steps for developing and validating a more representative endoscopic index in CD.
引用
- Khanna R, Ma C, Hogan M, et al. Standardizing Scoring Conventions for Crohn's Disease Endoscopy: An International RAND/UCLA Appropriateness Study. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2023. PMID: 37308036. doi:10.1016/j.cgh.2023.05.029
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。