冷圈套器与冷活检钳切除微小腺瘤对节段性不完全切除率的影响
这项两中心回顾性队列研究纳入1504例患者,评估冷圈套器息肉切除术(CSP)与冷活检钳息肉切除术(CFP)切除微小管状腺瘤的节段性不完全切除率(S-IRR)。结果显示,CFP切除<6 mm管状腺瘤的节段S-IRR为13%,CSP为0%。12名结肠镜医师的总体S-IRR范围为1.1%-24.4%,平均10.3%。
要点
- CFP切除<6 mm管状腺瘤的节段S-IRR为13%,CSP为0%。
- 12名结肠镜医师总体S-IRR范围1.1%-24.4%,平均10.3%。
- 作者提出S-IRR<5%可作为所有微小息肉切除的目标指标。
核心结论
- CFP切除微小管状腺瘤的S-IRR比CSP高13%。
- 作者提出S-IRR<5%作为所有微小息肉切除的目标指标,因3/12名结肠镜医师达到了该低比率。
- S-IRR可作为比较和量化不同息肉切除方法间节段性异时性腺瘤负荷差异的方法。
研究设计与样本
- 两中心回顾性队列研究,纳入1504例患者,其中1235例最晚期病变为<6 mm管状腺瘤,269例为6-9 mm管状腺瘤。
- S-IRR通过无腺瘤结肠节段的节段性异时性腺瘤率减去指数结肠镜检查时有腺瘤节段的节段性异时性腺瘤率计算。
- 主要结局为指数结肠镜检查时经CSP或CFP切除的微小管状腺瘤的S-IRR。
主要发现
- 指数结肠镜检查时经CFP不完全切除<6 mm管状腺瘤的节段S-IRR为13%。
- 指数结肠镜检查时经CSP不完全切除<6 mm管状腺瘤的节段S-IRR为0%。
- 12名纳入的结肠镜医师总体S-IRR范围为1.1%-24.4%,平均S-IRR为10.3%。
关键数值与推荐
- CFP切除微小管状腺瘤的S-IRR比CSP高13%。
- 作者提出S-IRR<5%作为所有微小息肉切除的目标指标。
- 3/12名结肠镜医师达到了S-IRR<5%的低比率。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Polypectomy technique, for diminutive lesion resection, is variable among colonoscopists using either cold snare polypectomy (CSP) or cold forceps polypectomy (CFP). While it is well described that CSP is a preferred technique to resect small lesions, there is little data evaluating the impact resection techniques have on metachronous adenoma burden. The aim of this study was to evaluate the rate of incomplete resection attributable to CSP and CFP of diminutive adenomas. METHODS: This is a 2-center retrospective cohort study evaluating the segmental incomplete resection rate (S-IRR) of diminutive tubular adenomas (TA). S-IRR was calculated by subtracting the segmental metachronous adenoma rate in a specific colonic segment without adenoma from segments with adenoma on index colonoscopy. The primary outcome was the S-IRR of diminutive TA resected by CSP or CFP on index colonoscopy. RESULTS: A total of 1,504 patients were included in the analysis: 1,235 with TA <6 mm and 269 with TA 6-9 mm as the most advanced lesion. The S-IRR in a segment that had a <6-mm TA incompletely resected by CFP on index colonoscopy was 13%. The S-IRR in a segment that had a <6-mm TA incompletely resected by CSP was 0%. Among 12 included colonoscopists, the range of overall S-IRR was 1.1%-24.4% with an average S-IRR of 10.3%. DISCUSSION: S-IRR was 13% higher with CFP resection of diminutive TA than with CSP. A proposed S-IRR metric of <5% is a target goal for all diminutive polyp resection because 3/12 colonoscopists achieved this low rate. S-IRR can be used as a methodology to compare and quantify the difference in segmental metachronous adenoma burden across various polypectomy removal methods.
引用
- Van J, Alsayid M, Ma K, et al. Impact of Cold Snare vs Cold Forceps Resection of Diminutive Adenomas on Segmental Incomplete Resection Rate. Am J Gastroenterol. 2023. PMID: 37040556. doi:10.14309/ajg.0000000000002289
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。