医生对既往有腺瘤的老年人是否进行监测的决策:一项全国性调查结果
一项全国性邮寄调查向1800名基层医生和600名消化内科医生询问在患者年龄(75岁和85岁)、健康状况(好、中、差)和既往腺瘤风险(低和高)不同的情景下是否推荐监测结肠镜检查。1040名应答者中874名符合条件并纳入分析。患者年龄较大、健康状况差和既往腺瘤低风险时推荐监测的比例较低。
要点
- 患者年龄较大、健康状况差和既往腺瘤低风险时,医生推荐监测结肠镜检查的比例较低。
- 约52.3%的基层医生和35.4%的消化内科医生对老年人监测的获益/风险平衡表示不确定。
- 多数基层医生(85.9%)和消化内科医生(77.0%)认为决策支持工具有帮助。
核心结论
- 在老年人中,医生推荐监测结肠镜检查的比例随患者年龄增大、健康状况变差和既往腺瘤风险降低而降低。
- 需要开展研究更好地评估老年人监测结肠镜检查的获益/风险,并开发帮助医生和患者纳入此类数据的决策支持工具。
研究设计与样本
- 全国性邮寄调查,向1800名基层医生和600名消化内科医生发放问卷。
- 调查采用情景案例,变化患者年龄(75岁和85岁)、健康状况(好、中、差)和既往腺瘤风险(低和高)。
- 1040名应答者(应答率54.8%),其中874名符合条件并纳入分析。
- 使用逻辑回归分析监测推荐与患者和医生特征之间的关联。
主要发现
- 患者年龄较大时推荐监测的比例较低(调整后比例20.6% vs 较年轻患者49.8%)。
- 患者健康状况差时推荐监测的比例较低(调整后比例7.1% vs 中等健康28.8% vs 好67.7%)。
- 既往腺瘤为低风险时推荐监测的比例较低(调整后比例29.7% vs 高风险41.6%)。
- 家庭医学医生最可能推荐监测,消化内科医生最不可能推荐(调整后比例40.0% vs 30.9%)。
- 约52.3%的基层医生和35.4%的消化内科医生报告对老年人监测的获益/风险平衡不确定;85.9%的基层医生和77.0%的消化内科医生认为决策支持工具有帮助;约32.8%的基层医生 vs 71.5%的消化内科医生认为决定监测结肠镜检查是消化内科医生的职责。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: There is no clear guidance on when surveillance colonoscopies should stop in older adults with prior adenomas. We aimed to examine physicians' decision-making regarding surveillance colonoscopies in older adults. METHODS: In a national mailed survey of 1,800 primary care physicians (PCP) and 600 gastroenterologists, we asked whether physicians would recommend surveillance colonoscopy in vignettes where we varied patient age (75 and 85 years), health (good, medium, and poor), and prior adenoma risk (low and high). We examined the association between surveillance recommendations and patient and physician characteristics using logistic regression. We also assessed decisional uncertainty, need for decision support, and decision-making roles. RESULTS: Of 1,040 respondents (response rate 54.8%), 874 were eligible and included. Recommendation for surveillance colonoscopies was lower if patient was older (adjusted proportions 20.6% vs 49.8% if younger), in poor health (adjusted proportions 7.1% vs 28.8% moderate health, 67.7% good health), and prior adenoma was of low risk (adjusted proportions 29.7% vs 41.6% if high risk). Family medicine physicians were most likely and gastroenterologists were least likely to recommend surveillance (adjusted proportions 40.0% vs 30.9%). Approximately 52.3% of PCP and 35.4% of gastroenterologists reported uncertainty regarding the benefit/harm balance of surveillance in older adults. Most (85.9% PCP and 77.0% gastroenterologists) would find a decision support tool helpful. Approximately 32.8% of PCP vs 71.5% of gastroenterologists perceived it as the gastroenterologist's role to decide about surveillance colonoscopies. DISCUSSION: Studies to better evaluate the benefits/harms of surveillance colonoscopy in older adults and decisional support tools that help physicians and patients incorporate such data are needed.
引用
- Schoenborn NL, Pollack CE, Gupta S, et al. Physician Decision-Making About Surveillance in Older Adults With Prior Adenomas: Results From a National Survey. Am J Gastroenterol. 2023. PMID: 36662579. doi:10.14309/ajg.0000000000002193
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。