低风险与高风险腺瘤患者为清洁结肠重复结肠镜检查率:EPoS试验结果
基于欧洲息肉监测试验中15 581例患者数据,评估低风险与高风险腺瘤患者纳入息肉监测前需重复结肠镜的比例。961例(6.2%)接受两次及以上结肠镜,低风险组101例(1.5%),高风险组860例(9.8%)。重复检查率在各中心间差异大(低风险0%–11.8%,高风险0%–63.9%),提示需针对性质量改进。
要点
- 纳入监测前6.2%(961/15 581)患者需两次及以上结肠镜,高风险组9.8%高于低风险组1.5%。
- 重复结肠镜主因包括肠道准备不佳(21.3%)、结肠镜/息肉切除不完整(14.4%)或计划二次操作(27.8%)。
- 各中心重复结肠镜率差异大:低风险腺瘤患者0%–11.8%,高风险腺瘤患者0%–63.9%。
核心结论
- 为达到完整息肉切除所需的结肠镜次数存在相当大的实践差异,提示需要有针对性的质量改进以减轻患者负担。
研究设计与样本
- 从欧洲息肉监测试验中检索符合特定后勤和方法学标准的低风险腺瘤(1–2个<10 mm低级别异型增生管状腺瘤)和高风险腺瘤(3–10个腺瘤、≥1个腺瘤≥10 mm、高级别异型增生或绒毛成分)患者数据。
- 分析按内镜中心和入组≥30例患者的内镜医师分组的达到高质量结肠镜并进入息肉监测所需结肠镜次数的差异。
主要发现
- 研究纳入五个欧洲国家38个内镜中心的15 581例患者,其中低风险腺瘤6794例,高风险腺瘤8787例。
- 961例(6.2%,95%CI 5.8%–6.6%)在监测开始前接受两次或以上结肠镜;低风险组101例(1.5%,95%CI 1.2%–1.8%),高风险组860例(9.8%,95%CI 9.2%–10.4%)。
- 重复结肠镜主因为肠道准备不佳(21.3%)、结肠镜/息肉切除不完整(14.4%)或计划二次操作(27.8%)。
- 需要重复结肠镜的比例在各研究中心间差异大:低风险腺瘤患者0%–11.8%,高风险腺瘤患者0%–63.9%。
- 第二次结肠镜后需第三次结肠镜的两个最常见原因为分块切除(26.5%)和未说明原因(23.9%)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出为达到完整息肉切除所需的结肠镜次数存在相当大的实践差异,提示需要有针对性的质量改进以减轻患者负担。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: High-quality colonoscopy (adequate bowel preparation, whole-colon visualisation and removal of all neoplastic polyps) is a prerequisite to start polyp surveillance, and is ideally achieved in one colonoscopy. In a large multinational polyp surveillance trial, we aimed to investigate clinical practice variation in number of colonoscopies needed to enrol patients with low-risk and high-risk adenomas in polyp surveillance. DESIGN: We retrieved data of all patients with low-risk adenomas (one or two tubular adenomas <10 mm with low-grade dysplasia) and high-risk adenomas (3-10 adenomas, ≥1 adenoma ≥10 mm, high-grade dysplasia or villous components) in the European Polyp Surveillance trials fulfilling certain logistic and methodologic criteria. We analysed variations in number of colonoscopies needed to achieve high-quality colonoscopy and enter polyp surveillance by endoscopy centre, and by endoscopists who enrolled ≥30 patients. RESULTS: The study comprised 15 581 patients from 38 endoscopy centres in five European countries; 6794 patients had low-risk and 8787 had high-risk adenomas. 961 patients (6.2%, 95% CI 5.8% to 6.6%) underwent two or more colonoscopies before surveillance began; 101 (1.5%, 95% CI 1.2% to 1.8%) in the low-risk group and 860 (9.8%, 95% CI 9.2% to 10.4%) in the high-risk group. Main reasons were poor bowel preparation (21.3%) or incomplete colonoscopy/polypectomy (14.4%) or planned second procedure (27.8%). Need of repeat colonoscopy varied between study centres ranging from 0% to 11.8% in low-risk adenoma patients and from 0% to 63.9% in high-risk adenoma patients. On the second colonoscopy, the two most common reasons for a repeat (third) colonoscopy were piecemeal resection (26.5%) and unspecified reason (23.9%). CONCLUSION: There is considerable practice variation in the number of colonoscopies performed to achieve complete polyp removal, indicating need for targeted quality improvement to reduce patient burden. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT02319928.
引用
- Juul FE, Garborg K, Nesbakken E, et al. Rates of repeated colonoscopies to clean the colon from low-risk and high-risk adenomas: results from the EPoS trials. Gut. 2022. PMID: 36307178. doi:10.1136/gutjnl-2022-327696
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。